|

Columns

And now it's the election date

Wignall's World

Mark Wignall

Sunday, December 04, 2011



'It is a shame that the people of Jamaica have no one to lead them. 'Four years ago, the JLP used allegations of corruption to wrest the country from the PNP. Fast-forward to today and the PNP is trying to use the same strategy (allegations of corruption) to try to unseat the JLP.

'Basically what we have for political leadership in this country are scoundrels who are basically securing their children's future from the public purse while the rest of us suffer. I did a little sociology in school and I know that only a revolution can save this country. Somebody has to stand up to these two sets of scoundrels. I am a public servant so I cannot be quoted. Something is brewing and you will hear about it in time.'

The person who recently sent me the e-mail quoted above mirrors much of the thinking of a significant percentage of the electorate. Basically it is apathy mixed with more than a dose of cynicism. They have seen it before — cycle after cycle of fancy promises, then elections, then the dashed hopes.

To be fair to the prime minister, he has not promised the nation anything more than the unvarnished truth that tough times will be ahead. To the sane likely voter, all he has to do is cast his eyes on events unfolding on the European continent and he will see that any political party in Jamaica that comes to the table with promises of pie in the sky has long decomposed. The leadership of such a party embarrasses itself and the voters to whom it makes such appeals simply because its thought processes are firmly locked in an era which is gone.

All political parties, however, that get the opportunity to choose an election date do so to suit their best chance at victory. The ruling JLP believes that it will reach the peak of its 'newness' and 'rebirth' in another few weeks to a month. After that, the love will begin to wane.

With no poll indicating a clear, safe distance ahead, the party that will win the elections will do so based on its visibility at the national and parochial levels in the next few weeks, its campaign speeches, ads and, most importantly, its ability to mobilise its party workers on election day.

On that basis, I cannot see the PNP outgunning the JLP.

Factors favouring the PNP as an opposition party are the obvious ones. The people want jobs and the national road network is a shambles. It seems to me that the allocation of JDIP funds to repair the road network was predicated on a late 2012 election date. In other words, had there been no change of JLP leadership, the first big wave of road repairs would have begun in the month leading up to elections in late 2012.

In the present instance I cannot see a big flurry of road repairs having any positive impact on the JLP's chances. Some other factors will have to trip in.

One reader e-mailed me the following: 'In your latest column, it would seem that the PM is taking a bold stance on corruption with the sacking of Mr Henry. But could it also be Mr Holness culling the herd, so to speak, and getting rid of some of the "old guard"?

'As for Mr Paulwell and his ranting, the poor PNP is like a soldier who came to fight a war with blanks in its gun. It has nothing positive to offer. It is more of the same old foolish politics. What a shame. I wonder what Norman Manley is thinking.'

As much as the PNP has used every opportunity to criticise the new prime minister on the grounds that his 'newness' is nothing new, the fact is that his bold moves in arranging the separation of the powerful Mike Henry from the transport and works ministry must be seen as a positive to the JLP and, by extension, the country. Those who say that it was a move of political expediency need to recognise that they cannot have it both ways. When Henry was there they called for his removal. After Henry left, they called it a politically expedient action.

Meanwhile, the contractor general has cited the reality of corruption in Jamaica by releasing a circular last Thursday under the heading, 'The Perception of Corruption in Jamaica Remains Unchanged'.

'The perception of the depth of corruption in Jamaica, as measured by Transparency International (TI), the global anti-corruption watchdog, indicates that nothing has changed over the past year which would lead the international community to accept that corruption is being effectively fought by the Jamaican State.

'In its 2011 Global Corruption Perception Index (CPI) Rankings, which were released late last night, TI scored Jamaica at a CPI of 3.3 out of a possible 10, with a country ranking of 86 out of 182 countries. In 2010, the country's CPI score was also 3.3, while it was ranked 87 out of 178 countries.

'In the past ten (10) years, Jamaica has never scored higher than 4.0 on TI's CPI, where a score of 10 is perceived to be least corrupt and 1 as most corrupt. 'The CPI ranks countries according to their perceived levels of public sector corruption. The 2011 index draws on different assessments and business opinion surveys that are carried out by independent reputable institutions. The surveys and assessments that are used to compile the index include questions which relate to the bribery of public officials, kickbacks in public procurement, embezzlement of public funds, and questions that probe the strength and effectiveness of public sector anti-corruption efforts.

"It should now be abundantly clear to all Jamaicans that unless they demand monumental changes in the country's existing moral, ethical and legal anti-corruption codes, and in its approach to the conjoint issues of transparency, accountability and good governance in the administration of the affairs of the Jamaican State, ten (10) years from now we will still be at the same place, talking about the same things", said Contractor General Greg Christie.

"The time has long passed for those who aspire to lead the Jamaican State to go beyond making mere lip-service statements about their intention to fight corruption. They must publicly state in lucid and specific terms the practical-step changes that they are prepared to take to effectively bring an end to corruption in Jamaica, and the respective time-frames within which these steps will be implemented. The question of what is in the best interest of Jamaica, as opposed to what is politically expedient, must be the common thread that defines all such proposed anti-corruption measures", said Mr Christie.

'Several germane remedial recommendations, in the foregoing regard, have already been formally presented by the Office of the Contractor General (OCG) to the prime minister and to the leader of the opposition for their consideration and implementation.

'TI, in its report, was moved to state that "Public-sector governance that puts the interests of its citizens first is a responsibility that is not restricted to any border. Governments must act accordingly. For their part, citizens need to continue demanding better performance from their leaders".

'Trinidad and Tobago and Guyana were the only countries in the English-speaking Caribbean that were ranked lower than Jamaica in TI's 2011 Rankings. Trinidad received a CPI score of 3.2 and a country ranking of 91, whereas Guyana was scored at 2.5 with a country ranking of 134.

'Barbados, The Bahamas, St Lucia, St Vincent and the Grenadines, and Dominica, were all scored significantly higher than Jamaica at CPI rankings of 7.8, 7.3, 7.0, 5.8 and 5.2 respectively.

'New Zealand was ranked as the least corrupt country with a CPI score of 9.5, while North Korea and Somalia were both ranked at the other end of the 182 country scale with a CPI score of 1.0.'

The intensity that attends political parties literally fighting to get and retain state power ought to automatically inform us that politicians expect more than just the opportunity to 'serve'.

In reality politicians often use state power to enrich themselves and expose their friends in high places to the largesse of the polity. In its simplest form, men and women being chauffeured in air-conditioned, high-end vehicles with security detail is a transforming process where one moves from a human to an arrogant blob of protoplasm in as quick a time as it takes for one to say, 'minister'.

The person who is called 'prime minister' after the next elections needs to act with urgency on the urgings of the contractor general.

Manchester meeting is good political strategy for the JLP

Quite apart from the fact that the JLP, while in opposition, launched its 'Deliverance' campaign from a platform in Mandeville in 1980, the mass meeting today hopes to do a lot more.

First, all eyes will be on the Central Manchester constituency where the PNP's General Secretary Peter Bunting holds the seat and will be going up against the powerful Danville Walker.

Holding the meeting there to announce the election date will complete two major objectives. One, it will give a fillip to Danville Walker's campaign. It is widely speculated in JLP circles that they expect Walker to win and, should the JLP prevail nationally, as I expect it to, Walker is tipped to be the next minister of national security.

The second objective is the major one -- keeping the PNP general secretary 'trapped' in his constituency. This is a somewhat of a double-edged sword. To keep Bunting in his constituency is to ensure that he will not have the time to assist other PNP candidates, especially the newcomers, but it will also cause Bunting to concentrate all of his energies in fighting off the strong challenge from Walker.

In the last election, the then gen sec of the JLP, Karl Samuda, had his constituency 'locked' and could afford to attend to the back-breaking and mentally debilitating tasks of attending to the other 59 constituencies.

The PNP's Bunting can make no such claims of having his constituency 'locked'. It will be very difficult for him.

Certainly, after the leadership debates and the general electioneering, much will be seen in the directions that the individual seats will be trending to. It is known that the prime minister's seat will also attract major concentration of energy and resources from the PNP. Again, that is plain and simple, good politics.

At the end I expect the PM to retain his seat and, although it will be no easy task, after election day I expect Peter Bunting to be wringing his hands.

Happy 100th birthday, Ms Riley

The gracious Alma Mock Yen has informed us of the following.

Ms Riley's birthday is December 5, 2011, when she will be 100 years old.

'Miss Ivy Riley was born in Stewart Town, Trelawny on December 5, 1911. She grew up there and was educated at the Stewart Town Elementary School.

'In the early thirties she migrated to Kingston where she was employed in the citrus industry. She worked there for a number of years then decided to become an entrepreneur operating business in the community of Southside where she still resides.

'Miss Riley has two children who predeceased her, but she has mothered many. One such is Miss Thelma Virgo (Peeny) who presently takes care of her. She enjoys good health except for loss of sight which occurred a few years ago.

'When asked about her longevity she replied that she never thought about it but she took good care of herself and that God saw that she deserved it and spared her life.

'Miss Riley has not been active since she lost her sight, as in her own words "Me coward fi move up an down an me no want to give anyone any trouble".

'She is grateful to God for keeping her and ensuring that she is not shelterless or hungry or naked.

'This centenarian is able to have a conversation, is witty and expresses herself well.'

Happy birthday (when it comes), Ms Riley!

observemark@gmail.com



POST A COMMENT


You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.

HOUSE RULES

 

1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.



Comment (required):

You have characters left.
captcha 4bce13181e494427ad844c9694be8cda
Enter text seen above:

For information about privacy please read our Privacy Policy.

I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions


COMMENTS (19)

Charles Morales-Lewin
12/5/2011
If only we could have a 99% movement to take the country back from the 1% of politicians. A revolution of mind and spirit, but can we think outside the tribe?
Stephen Fox
12/4/2011
We have to heed the Contractor Generals assessment because he is in the trenches doing battle. The Mike Henry resignation means nothing since he is still sitting in Gordon House. Despite Holness' promises there is no structural change in governance. A change in the corruption index can only come from a fundemental change in the laws and the enforcement thereof. The next JLPNP administration has one more chance to make these fundemental changes. After that, civil society may have something to say
SHAWN MCGREGOR
12/4/2011
Yes Mark, Peter Bunting will be pinned down in his constituency in the same way that Andrew Holness will in his. Bearing in mind that the PNP has a built-in majority in his constituency. Mr. Wignall, you are obviously campaigning for a JLP victory and blindly so. You know all too well that an organized PNP cannot lose to any JLP. So please offer fair and balanced commentary, you don't have to expose so much the signature on your paycheck.
Jay Brown
12/4/2011
Mark has been JLP then PNP, then JLP, COME on folks your thinking way too shallow.
No matter how you write you are branded, then we speak about tribalism politics, just check out these blog comments.
Jaye Stone
12/4/2011
I took one look at the local newspapers today, the PM ringing the bell with his incessant grin, Mike "unrepentant" Henry looking proud of himself and now this tribute to incompetence in leadership, and I am close to nausea. After the PNP's 18 year train to nowhere, this regime has killed my hopes in my country ever rising again. I will read of Jamaica through international unbiased eyes if I want the truth, for with an environment so toxic, all you get is a spin. Patriotism is overrated.
christopher Isaacs
12/4/2011
The JLP's election victory of 2007, marked the end of an era of promises especially with the world economy in the state that it is. The opposition is therefore in a quandary because it does not have that luxury any longer. What can the PNP then offer? Better management? but then the question would be; by whom? "no answer I suspect" The JLP has offered change, they have offered Holness and he has so far indicated some difference.
Mark Forbes
12/4/2011
Wignall, you and the other hacks are going to need chiropractors. You are twisting yourselves into some unnatural positions. Implied in all the praise of Holness as decisive is that Golding was a weak ditherer. But you cannot say it outright, because to do so would be to admit you were wrong about Golding. And if you are wrong about Golding, chances are you could be wrong about Holness, right?
christopher Isaacs
12/4/2011
I doubt very much that most have recognized the tremendous breath of fresh air and change that have been brought about since the advent of Andrew Holness to the leadership position. He has in one single swoop corrected some of Golding's most glaring mistakes especially getting rid of the most narcissistic Mike, who was so closely looking at himself, he could not see what was happening with the JIDP and that ill advised entity, "NWA" How does change not include the "NWA" BRUCE!!??
Nejeeper KNG
12/4/2011
Mark after the deadly earthquake in Japan news agencies around the world could not find any report on looting. The question was why is there no looting in Japan? One person answered; because they have honor. When I got that answer I stop looking for any other reason “because they have honor” was enough for me. When we start having honor for country and people is when we will see change. Buying votes, selling votes and being an unpatriotic diehard are dishonorable behaviors. Vote with honor.
David Barnaby
12/4/2011
Mark, you never cease to amaze me. You remind me of the blind man playing hide and seek and trying to hide behind a grass straw and even he could see your veiled attempt to bamboozle your readers. Why don't you just come and declare yourself as an advocate of the JLP? It is our right and it is okay. Until you find it necessary to do you, all your talk will be viewed as nothing but arrant nonsense.
David Armstrong
12/4/2011
I agree with your ananymous e-mail writer that what JA need is a revolution. When you have a politicial system that is corrupt inside out and the political leaders are acting non-chlantly in the face of growing social and economic problems then it's time to get rid of the whole lock, stock and barrel of them. JA need political leaders who are strong and who will implement tough policies. Such leade must rule with a iron hand to clean up the cess pool that the current leaders wallow in.
Mark Forbes
12/4/2011
Wignall, you were being biased in favor of, not being fair to Holness. Fairness is an alien concept to you. There was absolutely no embarrassment on his face when the youngest candidate in the election was prematurely 'decomposing' in his presence. He was looking on in approval when Collin Virgo was promising jobs at a time when the national govt. can't provide them. You sir, are a hack, and would be hard-pressed to reasonably justify your support of the JLP.
San Patrek
12/4/2011
Seriously Mark, this article has JLP to win the next election all over it. But as a neutral, we deserve what we get and if we vote for people like Portia, Roger Clarke and Omar Davies to run the country, then we deserve what we get. I have always said that the problem with democracy is that your choices are limited. It doesn't allow you to vote for 'none of the above (NOTA)'. Even if there are independents, NOTA should be on the ballot papers. That is true democracy.
Hugh Maxwell
12/4/2011
I dont hear any sound about pursuing the 'two term govt' policy again; 'seperation of powers'; 'change of the wesminster system'. The system of Govt will have to change in JA. Also what about corruption in the police force? Breaches of citizens employment rights in the work place. The lack of ability to invest in human capital. Barbados was able to reach first world status my investing in the latter. What about the many guns in JA? Will they just go away? I would not vote for any. Trust me.
Dan smith
12/4/2011
Wignall you wine and dine with the big wigs in the JLP so I dont expect any better from you which is a mouth piece for them trying to fool the dunce, Let me remind you about something and only one thing over 100.000 people lost their jobs since the JLP took office in 2007 spin it all you want we can't wait for election, we can't wait.
Hugh Maxwell
12/4/2011
I dont think Mark is a PNP or JLP. The man is a social scientest. Have we not heard over and over how the Mark has voted over the years? Many of us who have voted for one party over and over because ' AFFECTION MAKES US FALSE". On the next note is that for many years I have thought that Jamaica is a failed state and one of the main reason is that of how our politics are run. Holness good intentions are not eneough to make the great change for manh politician started off with good intentions...
kipodon ms
12/4/2011
It is the South St James Poll numbers i am interested in....that one should be one to watch as well with Mr Kellier being a very poor representative for 22 years
Paul Gentles
12/4/2011
Continuity of bruce's philosophy is ongoing in earnest - win at all costs - how do you account for some of the candidates?
someone can breach a cabinet order and still be foisted on the people instead of facing severe penalties? an echo of bruce knowing some candidates were not eligible but had to win at all costs. The beginning of your column should be it's entirety - we are being asked to support scoundrels!
Ronald Brown
12/4/2011
This is just another PR piece for the JLP Mark. Don't try to hide your true colours, this article has green written all over it. How do you know that the PNP cant outdo the JLP with ads and campaign speeches and mobilization on the election date...this is obvious bias on your part. You seems to know so much about the JLP one has o wonder if you are a member. thanks for revealing your true colours. now we know

As your bishop...

  0 comments

 

Credit unions and crisis leadership

  0 comments

 

No such person as a good don

  11 comments

 

Crosskill's departure from TVJ marks end of an era

  5 comments

 

Issues to consider during Child Month

  0 comments

 

'Compassion without Compromise': Church throws down the gauntlet

  23 comments

 

Gloria Palomino: A lifetime of voluntary service to the police

  0 comments

 

Fast fall in a slow system

  2 comments

 

Parents have ultimate responsibility for their children

  5 comments

 

IOP ball back in Omar's court

  0 comments

 

Needed: a collective voice in the G20 for developing countries

  0 comments

 

No growth without social cohesion

  0 comments

 

Let's get our priorities right

  1 comments

 

A high price to pay for physical perfection

  0 comments

 

Don't go there, Ronnie

  0 comments

 

A time to deal with the CAL/Liat conflict

  0 comments

 

Greece gets another chance to tackle its fiscal dilemma

  0 comments

 

Time for a revolution in education

  1 comments

 

Obama: President, not Pastor of America

  15 comments

 

Taxi drivers and a clean Kingston Harbour

  4 comments

 

Today's Cartoon


Poll

 Do you feel buying into Facebook now is a good investment for the long-run? 
Yes
No

View Results

Results published weekly in Sunday Finance


Username:
Password: