Hear the Children's Cry condemns treatment of Mona student 3:15 PM
Health of Jamaica's children improving — Ferguson 2:58 PM
Cops looking for Jody-Ann McNarrin 2:21 PM
'Ratty' killed in motor vehicle accident 2:05 PM
Woman left lying in her own urine in jail before she died 1:15 PM
Emergency repair work disrupts water supply in St James 1:12 PM
UN: Budget cuts causing cholera deaths in Haiti 11:35 AM
Modest growth for Caribbean countries in 2012 11:32 AM
Busy denied bail 10:59 AM
Man detained over New York boy's 1979 disappearance 10:43 AM
Columns
Hope vs political reality
MARK WIGNALL
Thursday, January 12, 2012
IN early 2006 at the inauguration of Prime Minister Portia Simpson Miller, the nation had reason to leave the dashed hopes of previous years behind as it envisaged positive change for the future.
In September 2007, we were at it again as Prime Minister Bruce Golding, in his acceptance speech, gave us cause to believe in the lofty vision he had for this country. A few months ago a young and seemingly energetic Prime Minister Andrew Holness again injected hope in some of us and made us believe that the best of us could be realised.
A few days ago, Prime Minister Portia Simpson Miller was again at it, in a speech trying to inspire hope and painting a picture of brighter tomorrows. Most of us who are reasonable people want to believe the words and are quite willing to give her and her team the needed time to put the new plans into action. At the same time, there will be those of us who will have forgotten that as a collective whole, no sector or group of us can afford to sit it out and wait on themâ to get it right. We all have a stake in the proceedings.
At another level political reality has that dirty habit of awakening us from our dreamy-eyed slumber. We have been there before, have witnessed the political brinksmanship before and have seen the two tribes fighting for the sweet and intoxicating power that a win at the polls gives them.
We have seen them both trying to win us over with falsehoods from the podium; we have seen them relentlessly denigrating those from the other side, all in an effort to sway us into voting for their side. Those of us who witnessed the dawn of Independence on August 6, 1962, have some reason to be thankful, but, if we are truly honest, we also have more reason to be angry at our political leaders and at ourselves for being willing spectators to the grand game.
We truly ache to believe and to move in synch with the directions of our leaders, but intermittent doses of reality tell us that the words we have heard from them in the last 50 years have not been anywhere near representative of their deeds. More importantly, as a people, too much of our energy is spent trying to secure a one-way ticket out of Jamaica and we indulge our love/hate relationship with our island home. Someone else must do the real work, preferably themâ as we see ourselves as the victims.
In the fight for political power and the huge outlay of funds energised at all levels in the pursuit of that objective, oftentimes the development of our people and the nation come out as an unintended consequence of the real objective, too much of which is proximity to the public purse, predation and the empowerment of friends and cronies.
For those of us who dearly wish to join the leap of faith and adulation directed at the prime minister and her team, we have the past to remind us, but still there is that nagging "what if". What if we are wrong and the new PNP prime minister and her team leave the past behind and embark on real development objectives while remaining fully accountable to the people? What if we could see the sordid past as no indication of the future?
One of the main factors which blew the JLP out of power was its insistence that power meant it had to listen to no one. As long as it maintained the right macroeconomic variables and convinced itself that it was on the right path, nuh guy nuh fi sey nutten!
Ministers being chauffeured in swank air-conditioned SUVs with security detail made too many of them immerse their personalities in roles of the village tyrant and the newly liberated house slave off to the fields to lord it over the poor unfortunates toiling in the sun.
There have been more than a few who have criticised the size of the new PNP Cabinet, but they seem to forget that a political win translates to giving out long-service awards. I am, however, quite willing to buy into the prime minister's explanation that succession planning is at the heart of that process. If those who have been there before show a human face to political power, something which the JLP found most difficult, while taking promising junior ministers through the ropes, I believe that in one or two years' time a Cabinet re-shuffle should see the emergence of the younger, brighter and more energetic junior ministers to full responsibility.
The matter which is most current, certainly with those young, unemployed people who told me they voted PNP, is JEEP, the emergency employment programme which the PNP introduced as a policy proposal at its conference last year.
The prime minister has indicated that she and her team are in negotiations with the Chinese in an effort to use the JDIP funds (originally earmarked for road repairs). Most of the complaints that kept on cropping up last year with road repairs was that, unlike the old Public Works Department (PWD) formula which tended to use community residents, under the JDIP the National Works Agency (NWA) or its sub-contractors would move into an area to effect road repairs with its imported crew.
In those instances, the community benefited from a more improved road network while the unemployed residents shared in none of the employment. If JEEP embarks on an employment programme, how long will it last and to what extent will it displace or complement road repairs using community workers?
In an article in the LA Times, columnist Dimitri Papadimitriou suggests the following: At the theoretical heart of job-creation programmes is this fact: Only government, because it is not seeking profitability when it is hiring, can create a demand for labour that is elastic enough to keep a nation near full employment. During a downturn, when a government offers a demand for unemployed workers, it takes on a role analogous to the one that the Federal Reserve plays when it provides liquidity to banks. As in banking, setting an appropriate rate, in this case, a wage, is one key component for success, with the goal of employing those willing and able to work at or marginally below prevailing informal wages.
In taking a jab at the private sector and its core objectives, the writer states a truism. It's unreasonable to expect private enterprises to solve these problems. Full employment isn't an objective of businesses. Companies usually strive to keep staffing at a minimum (we've all heard the virtues of lean and mean). There simply isn't any known automatic mechanism, in the markets or elsewhere, that creates jobs in numbers that match the pool of people willing and able to work.
As a nation we need to believe that our political leaders are fully aware of our problems and have the expertise to lead us into adopting their policy proposals and plans.
If JEEP really has that engine, it could be the very start of giving our large mass of unemployed youth reason to believe that the words of our leaders can match up to the deeds. For a start, that is.
observemark@gmail.com
POST A COMMENT
You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.
HOUSE RULES
1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.
2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.
1/13/2012
Mark ; Much has been said about the arrogance of the JLP members causing the defeat. Not enough about the lack of participation of the potential voters, as a reason for the loss. Perhaps an academic research is in order.
One Love!
1/13/2012
JEEP will accomplish nothing other than send JA into deeper debt. The Chinese may accommodate the GOJ and allow the usage of JDIP money they intended to repatriate through China Harbor, but that would be out of character for them. It's likely that they will offer a different line of credit, which you may never hear of. All non housekeeping spending should have a long term ROI. JEEP has no ROI. Spend on feeding the needy with PubPriParts, supporting local farmers and hiring cooks to prepare meals
1/13/2012
JEEP is in effect similar to banks creating liquidity It is the preserve of governments as its beyond the ideology of the private sector It'll stimulate the economy, spending, tax and harness energies in rebuilding the country Remember of its unskilled beneficiaries some are young persons who are prone to gang recruitment which grows crime industries others may be older persons who has difficulties gaining employment The middle classes meanwhile can ply their qualification in the private sector
1/13/2012
Re;Donny S
I agree with your opinion that crime has to be controlled and a lot of things needs to be done to enhance the lifestyles of Jamaicans. I have written on many occasions that if only crime could be controlled, Jamaica would see an upsurge of people in the diaspora coming home to their neighborhoods. This would increase expenditure within local businesses instead of us relying on tourism. Jamaicans love coming home!
Step by step we can fix the place. We deserve better!
1/13/2012
Jamaicans should start Tebowing.
1/12/2012
The international communities will never do business in Jamaica unless they believe it is safe to do so. So why is the media not asking these tough questions to the PM? A low crime rate,low taxes, good infrastructure an great educated class thats ready to work. These are the very basic things thats needs to be taken care of before Jamaica, can be one of the best places to live an work. Let's get at the government to stare the process of bring Jamaica forward. GOD BLESS JAMAICA.
1/12/2012
Good afternoon to one an all. Here we go again. The government has a job to do an thats to sell Jamaica, to the international communities to help stimulate the econemy. It has to show that Jamaica is open for business however it is not ready for this. Jamaica needs to take care of one of it's biggest problems CRIMES. The crime problem must be solved. Thats what Jamaica is known for other than the great climet with plenty of sun shine. The PM must adress this issue an the media must ba part of it
1/12/2012
She got high hopes! She got high up in that high hopes! 'Membah, dah song deh?' That crazy goat or ram goat tried hard to butt that dam? Reality is reality; you don't put away enough energy towards your personal ambitions you not going anywhere! Gwaan go nyam out and yam out! So so bible alone will bring no rain soon to grow the food for a lazy farmer to earn. Me done do my little bit fi unnoo without thanks. Ah me God will listen when me kneel and pray. Unoo ungrateful and craven for foolishnes
1/12/2012
Wiggie, I see you are not providing quote about Govt. as employer of last resort, as a way of admitting that the JEEP indeed has merit.
That's ok Wiggie, we know that you just go outside, put up yur finger to determine which direction the wind is blowing, then write.
Just remember one thing though, that Holness is not new, not different, and was sent packing by the electorate! He was just a "Manchurian Candidate" put forward to win the election. Golding's desperate "master play" failed badly.
1/12/2012
From an observation of the economies of Greece, Ireland and even the UK, it should be clear that austerity is not a prescription for growth. At the same time, this is not a rationale for bloat, neither in govt. agencies, nor in superfluous patronage, not when we have overwhelming infrastructure, education, etc. deficits. If we are to move forward, these areas must be addressed.
1/12/2012
Remember, the core economic problem is the private sector’s inability to generate sufficient demand to employ everyone. This can be solved by supplementing demand. It creates more employment. The Jamaican government should not borrow in order to be able to afford something it could not otherwise buy. Rather, the goal of deficit spending (especially when we are at a very high unemployment) is to stimulate demand.
1/12/2012
In an economic crisis reaponsible governments consolidate their departments and reduce the number of people they employ. JEEP will clearly be a method of TEMPORARILY employing mostly unskilled labour but will mostly be a means of rewarding the grass root campaign workers for the PNP. If and when JEEP hits the road it will be a vehicle of corruption, mark my word.
1/12/2012
The point about govt. being the employer of last resort in a downturn is sensible. And if Jamaica was rich like the US or the EU, it would be the prudent thing to do. When a country is as badly off as we are, prudence would say that our priority should be investments for future success in areas like education, infrastructure or crime fighting. It is hard to argue that frittering our resources away on mindless redistribution is really moving the ball forward.
1/12/2012
Mark the engine for the JEEP is JDIP funds (borrowed money) it is Dr. Davies pet project that is why he is Transport Minister. You notice no talk on garrisons and how it contributes to crime. There are comrades who have never said anything good about the previous Govt so being objective and not buying the unrealistic promises is considered as a desire for this Govt to fail. Crime, the economy and creating a welfare state on borrowed money will be the downfall of this Govt.
1/12/2012
@Chipmink L.
Don't take this the wrong way. Sorry to burst your buble but a lot as to happen in Jamaica for it to develop the way is should. It's not just the media. Corruption needs to be crushed. We need to act instead of react. Until that's done, Jamaica ain't gonna go anywhere. I'm not trying to be mean. It's the truth. If the older ones are comfortable with the way things are, fine with them. Just please don't bring us youngsters down with you. The world is watching
1/12/2012
If the media remains politically neutral but a champion of the country's best interest, we can keep the government honest. we are not looking for negative coverage but for information that affects the general public which the government can utilize in making for a better economy.
Mark, your mission as well as the other journalists is to challenge the government to show positive growth.
Jamiaca needs to come out of the darkness in our 50th year since independence.
Walk good !
Other Stories
0 comments
Usain is our Othello — Love, sex, power and racism
0 comments
0 comments
Credit unions and crisis leadership
0 comments
11 comments
Crosskill's departure from TVJ marks end of an era
5 comments
Issues to consider during Child Month
0 comments
'Compassion without Compromise': Church throws down the gauntlet
23 comments
Gloria Palomino: A lifetime of voluntary service to the police
0 comments
2 comments
Parents have ultimate responsibility for their children
5 comments
0 comments
Needed: a collective voice in the G20 for developing countries
0 comments
No growth without social cohesion
0 comments
Let's get our priorities right
1 comments
A high price to pay for physical perfection
0 comments
0 comments
A time to deal with the CAL/Liat conflict
0 comments
Greece gets another chance to tackle its fiscal dilemma
0 comments
Time for a revolution in education
1 comments





