|

Columns

Mouthing hot air and adulterated garbage about the Riverton fire

Mark Wignall

Thursday, February 23, 2012



Sitting on 10 of the 100 acres at the Riverton City dump site are an estimated 12 million discarded old tyres that if set ablaze, would have catastrophic consequences for the health of Jamaicans in at least six of our 14 parishes. That fire could potentially run for months and would seriously hobble our already under-equipped fire services.

Only about 20 feet (and the narrow Duhaney River) separated the tyres from a fire which burnt there in 2006.

Recently the JLP, through Desmond McKenzie, Western Kingston MP and Opposition spokesman on urban renewal, rural development and local government, said in the House: "There are about some 12,000 people living in some 1,600 houses in proximity to the landfill and about 50 per cent of them live in Riverton itself. I don't know how the Member of Parliament for Western St Andrew (Anthony Hylton) looks at it, but I know Riverton City as an extremely poverty-stricken community, which incidentally has always backed the current government 100 per cent."

He then went on to say: "We need to show these citizens that we are not ignoring their health issues but that we are sincerely committed to ensuring that things like constant fire at the landfill, which creates a smoke-filled environment across the Corporate Area and parts of St Catherine, are addressed with urgency."

Based on what I have determined, the JLP MP was blowing smoke, politically toxic smoke.

In most of last year, those in the management of the dump site were fully aware and were repeatedly warned by those on site that a fire was imminent, either through spontaneous combustion or sabotage, because of the lack of cover fill and adequate equipment for use in the process.

The dump site, known to those with stomach for a good joke as a "landfill", takes in approximately 350 loads of unsorted garbage per day. Jamaicans on the island are not sophisticated people. A typical bag of garbage (for those who care to bag it) will contain plastic, paper, glass, metal, old cellphones and organic material, including a dead rat or two. The informal sorters who make a desperate living from the site do the obvious, but they slow down the process of dealing with the garbage on site.

"Dealing with the garbage" means using specific types of heavy machinery to push the waste material into a cell of 400 square yards then utilising another type of unit to press it flat, after which soil material is used to cover it and then the whole is compressed. That process is repeated until that cell can take no more garbage. After that, another cell in the 100 acres at Riverton is chosen.

When a cell is completely used up, the result is a fairly flat soil-covered area.

If Desmond McKenzie and Local Government Minister Noel Arscott had done their homework, they would have determined that the twice per year cover fill was not being adhered to, there was shortage of NSWMA equipment and an unwillingness to lease the needed equipment from independent contractors.

If there was a cash incentive to senior management personnel to save on operational expenses, they could not have done it better. And of course, if there was a cash incentive to medical consultants employed at government hospitals to save on operational expenses, there would be little medicine purchased, few medical procedures effected, dead patients piling up, but the senior doctors (and morticians) would be laughing all the way to the bank.

Based on what I have determined (and I challenge anyone in the last administration in local government and senior NSWMA personnel to prove me wrong), it is my belief that someone from the last JLP administration and/or the NSWMA should be hauled before a parliamentary committee to answer charges of gross dereliction of duty for bringing about the conditions that led to the February 6 fire.

It is still my understanding that the fire was deliberately set, but if standard procedure had been adopted by utilising twice per year fill and adequate equipment, the fire could have been avoided. With huge mounds of loose garbage, especially the large quantity of environmentally harmful "scandal bags" (easily flammable) used by Jamaicans, all it takes to sabotage the site is two or three people climbing atop at places with five-gallon canisters of gasoline to set the site afire. With the garbage tamped down and covered, that becomes almost impossible.

It is also my belief that the only reason the 10-acre tyre site has not been torched is due to one simple fact. Such a fire would be so devastating that the usual hauling of dirt, marl and the use of heavy machinery could not be employed, and those in that business would not be able to cash in!

On one hand, we have PNP Minister Noel Arscott declaring much too early that the fire was likely caused by spontaneous combustion. Some believe that he adopted that position to stave off the suspicions that contractors loyal to the PNP would benefit from a fire deliberately set.

On the other hand, there is a JLP spokesman Desmond McKenzie, denying himself of the knowledge that the conditions that led to the fire began under the last NSWMA regime prior to the December 29 elections.

Rely on politicians to get to the truth and all we will ever get is hot air, toxic smoke and the people no wiser than before.

observemark@gmail.com



POST A COMMENT


You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.

HOUSE RULES

 

1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.



Comment (required):

You have characters left.
captcha ec7c1989f92946feb538d9894c8a783c
Enter text seen above:

For information about privacy please read our Privacy Policy.

I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions


COMMENTS (10)

claude russell
2/26/2012
I don't get the impression that Desmond McKenzie was trying to do any such thing. It's a political tactic but he's not pretending ignorance at all.
Jay Brown
2/24/2012
Tyre can form a good source of fuel , lets go for it.
Jeff Orange
2/23/2012
and they want to import a zillion more used tyres into the country? These tyres will have a very limited life and will end up at the dump. Tyre-fire produces exponentially more and thicker smoke and is extremely difficult to extinguished. That is why they are classified as hazardous waste in the US and would the US suppliers would love to find a convenient dumping ground. The export their waste to Jamaica disguised as Fertilizer and now have their sight on our country to dump their tyres.
N Manley Blythe
2/23/2012
Mark, happy to see you calling a spade "a spade" and leveling blame to JLPNP. Then JLP led GOJ should have covered landfill, PNP Opposition should have insisted.
"Rely on politicians to get to the truth and all we will ever get is hot air, toxic smoke and the people no wiser than before."
Well said!! 
Can we now rely on your investigative journalistic skills to henceforth uncover the truth so that politicians and other so-called "leaders" will be held accountable? Sent to prison? I'm Praying!!!
christopher Isaacs
2/23/2012
Mark we all know this dump to be scandal ridden, however, I cant recall a scandal during Joan Webley's tenure, can you? There is no way that you could have completed an article of this nature without mentioning Joan Gordon Webley. It is either you lambast her or give her some credit.
Noel Richards
2/23/2012
It takes a real plan to make a country better. The tires at the Riverton dump should have already been a major part of fixing JA's roads. They should have been reused in rebuilding roads using the Arizona RAC (Rubberized Asphalt Concrete) method http://www.asphaltrubber.org/ari/Video/index.html. The Arizona RAC method is initially expensive, but nothing competes with it for safety, performance and longevity, when it's done properly. I've driven on some exceptional RAC roads. Watch the videos.
christopher Isaacs
2/23/2012
As far as I recall there has never been a year in recent memory when there was never a fire. I might not have been aware but the best that that dump has ever been run was when it was under JGW management. Prior to the last 4yrs the dump has always been know as a political feeding tree. I recall " Shut yuh damn mouth" and"umbilically connected" were phrases borne out of that fertile dump. Contractors were able to abandon tractors on the dump because they were effectively paid for. Give JGW creds
Norman Lee
2/23/2012
Despite the accusations journalists endure, they are believable! Skimping on O & M budget to ensure a bonus while putting almost a 1 m lives at risk is despicable and spells criminal negligence or at least the tort of vicarious liability on the part of NSWMA. If the proper treatment of the site was done, it is unlikely that any fire would have occur because there would have been insufficient oxygen to start ignition or maintain a flame. Equipment on site shows who ate or at the trough to feast!
Chelm News
2/23/2012
A balanced column probing at the truth without favour. Good job Mr. Wignall, now let's hope the authorities that be work towards a solution and not sit around responding to hot air. What we need is solution from useful and well intended suggestions and recommendations. Jamaicans (The People) and Jamaica (The Environment) come first.
Adam Godson
2/23/2012
was riverton city properly managed prior to the election,prior to the election on december 29

Plenty money... little sense

  0 comments

 

Usain is our Othello — Love, sex, power and racism

  0 comments

 

As your bishop...

  0 comments

 

Credit unions and crisis leadership

  0 comments

 

No such person as a good don

  11 comments

 

Crosskill's departure from TVJ marks end of an era

  5 comments

 

Issues to consider during Child Month

  0 comments

 

'Compassion without Compromise': Church throws down the gauntlet

  23 comments

 

Gloria Palomino: A lifetime of voluntary service to the police

  0 comments

 

Fast fall in a slow system

  2 comments

 

Parents have ultimate responsibility for their children

  5 comments

 

IOP ball back in Omar's court

  0 comments

 

Needed: a collective voice in the G20 for developing countries

  0 comments

 

No growth without social cohesion

  0 comments

 

Let's get our priorities right

  1 comments

 

A high price to pay for physical perfection

  0 comments

 

Don't go there, Ronnie

  0 comments

 

A time to deal with the CAL/Liat conflict

  0 comments

 

Greece gets another chance to tackle its fiscal dilemma

  0 comments

 

Time for a revolution in education

  1 comments

 

Today's Cartoon


Poll

 Do you feel buying into Facebook now is a good investment for the long-run? 
Yes
No

View Results

Results published weekly in Sunday Finance


Username:
Password: