PSOJ labels Gov't attempt to control dump fire a national disgrace 4:56 PM
NSWMA acquires heavy equipment to tackle fire 3:22 PM
'Wormo', Duck Mouse' and 'Kirk' killed by cops in Rose Vale 2:20 PM
Brown Burke proves to Senate she denied US citizenship 1:49 PM
INDECOM, BSI probing fatal shooting of barber in Cherry Gardens 1:27 PM
Man dies in Temple Hall crash 12:01 PM
Columns
Torn between two lovers
LLOYD B SMITH
Wednesday, August 25, 2010
One of the few pre-election promises that Prime Minister Bruce Golding has kept is that he would not use the title reserved for Jamaican prime ministers, "the Most Honourable". He felt then, as perhaps he does now, that such a title should be deserved, not just conferred. There were those who felt at the time of his avowed decision that he was seeking to take the moral high ground and so thought that he had done the honourable thing.
Based on the revelations surrounding the Manatt, Phelps and Phillips affair and Mr Golding's own admissions in Parliament, it behoves him to do the honourable thing and step aside as the country's chief servant. Failure to do so may well in the long run gain him the dubious distinction of being a most dishonourable prime minister of Jamaica.
No doubt, Mr Golding must have persuaded himself at the outset of this great conspiracy that he was acting in the best interest of the Jamaica Labour Party of which he is leader and ultimately the country.
It is safe to assume that Mr Golding loves his party as well as his country, and so he has been torn between two lovers. The politician in him would have dictated that he put his party first and Information Minister Daryl Vaz confirmed this in an interview. But then, Mr Golding has also sworn to uphold the Constitution of Jamaica and allegiance to all those tenets of good governance. Is it that Jamaica must forever take second place in the current scheme of things?
Were Mr Golding not prime minister, or for that matter if Minister of Justice and Attorney General Senator Dorothy Lightbourne and Solicitor General Douglas Leys were much lower down on the food chain in this JLP administration, they would all have been axed and brought into public disrepute as has happened to a number of highly placed civil servants who have felt the wrath of this Golding administration. But, alas, "puss and dog don't have the same luck" and in this scenario, the same stick that lick black snake may not necessarily lick yellow snake!
According to Wikipedia, "The crime of obstruction of justice includes crimes committed by judges, prosecutors, attorneys general, and elected officials in general. It is misfeasance, malfeasance or nonfeasance in the conduct of the office. Most commonly, it is prosecuted as a crime for perjury by a non-governmental official primarily because of prosecutorial discretion. Modern obstruction of justice, in United States jurisdictions, refers to the crime of offering interference of any sort to the work of police, investigators, regulatory agencies, prosecutors, or other (usually government) officials. Often, no actual investigation or substantiated suspicion of a specific incident need exist to support a charge of obstruction of justice. Common-law jurisdictions, other than the United States, tend to use the wider offence of perverting the course of justice."
Given all the available information in the public domain, is it reasonable to assume that our esteemed prime minister may be deemed to be a person of interest by the United States authorities? And what of Mr Douglas Leys and Mr Harold Brady; not to mention the goodly Senator Dorothy Lightbourne, in all of this? I am not here casting any stones in the pig pen but if I should dare to do so, would there be squeals of mea culpa?
It has been argued that Christopher "Dudus" Coke played a very pivotal role in the 2007 general election which the JLP won by a narrow margin. It has also been posited that the "President" was a most important cog in the wheel of that major political organisation. West Kingston, aka Tivoli Gardens, is also known to be the JLP's premier bastion and has been described by Rear Admiral Hardley Lewin, former police commissioner and former chief of defence staff, as the "mother of all garrisons". It follows, therefore, that the JLP should do whatever it can to protect one of its own and no reasonable individual would argue with such a premise.
However, when it is to be recalled that Mr Coke was being sought by the US authorities to face criminal charges in that country, based on the extradition treaty arrangements in existence up till now, for the Government of Jamaica to be in any way involved in preventing this to proceed in the required way would not only smack of being a case of obstruction of justice but must be seen as unethical, corrupt and immoral.
Juxtapose those observations against the backdrop of Mr Golding telling parliamentarians and the country at large that he had sanctioned such an act of interference, and the plot thickens to the point where Jamaica is now looking down the barrel of a smoking gun. The Sunday Gleaner's e-mail revelations (thank God for the Access to Information Act) have put the icing on the cake. The JLP's initial response is to cower in silence and retreat to Belmont Road (the JLP headquarters). Will it surrender to the groundswell of public opinion and demand that heads roll, or will it come out fighting, hoping that this will be yet another nine-day wonder?
Already, there are those who had already begun to crow that Mr Golding has nine lives politically and that he is likely to go down in history as the greatest Comeback Kid of all time. Well, a cat may look at a king. It remains to be seen whether or not Jamaican civil society has the guts to rise up against such acts of infamy and deception, or whether Mr Golding will have the testicular fortitude to do the right thing. As the song says:
"Torn between two lovers, feelin' like a fool
Lovin' both of you is breakin' all the rules."
Will Bruce the statesman (putting country first) rise to the occasion, or will Bruce the politician (putting party first) sink further into the morass of deception and double standards, taking us along with him? The prosecution rests. The verdict is yours.
lloydbsmith@hotmail.com
POST A COMMENT
You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.
HOUSE RULES
1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.
2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.
8/28/2010
The Prime Minister's acknowledges that the "Manatt affair" was a mistake, and sincerely regrets the negative effects that have resulted so say Spin Doctor Mr. Vaz. Mr.
Golding should know this not an affair it is a “ Mannatt Scandal” It is a scandal when a Prime Minister who know better come to the country and tell us that the JLP hired Manatt, knowing that it cannot be done, it is illegal by the United States FARA Act. “Wheel and come again Mr. Golden but we want the truth this time, Produce the contract signed with the JLP and Manatt”.
Better yet instruct Manatt to publish all the documents proving that the contract is indeed with the JLP and not the Government case close Country move on.
8/27/2010
LOL, the Prime Minister knows why he couldn't have accepted the title of Most Honorable, he knows more than we do that Honorable is stretching it a bit much less MOST Honourable.
This whole affair is such a tangled web that it would take some snipping and clipping to detangle the web. It will take ages to get out of this one. The JLP has an excellent and enviable PR machinery, so let's wait and see if it will work for them and pull them out of this mess.
8/26/2010
The US was also investigating three ministries, who are they?
8/26/2010
Bruce will not resign and he will not let go his co-conspirators, remember he didn't have the guts to boot Rev.Miller?.PM threw Jamaica under the bus for Dudus, what else do we need to prove he's not statesman.
8/26/2010
I do not want to speculate about the PMs political future or waste any more time talking about what he said or did in the past. All I want him to do is to call for a TRUTH AND RECONCILLIATION COMMISSION to address the Dudus affair and the broader issue of garrison politics that created Dudus. Mr. Smith just like I have asked mr. Wignal to demand this I am aalos asking you to the do the same. You guys have lots of media influence and your voice on this matter will pressure the PM to do so.
8/25/2010
Lloyd again a nice analysis. I sincerely hope that civil society has the guts to rise up against the JLP and the PNP. The best thing that the Parliamentarians can do before the next election is to offer constitutional reform that enforces accountability in government. If we get some meaningful changes then and only then can they regain some semblance of credibility. In the mean time JLPNP should burn for their transgressions against our beloved country.
8/25/2010
Gary Lee, it's not about whether or not Bruce Golding hired MPP. Rather it's about whether or not MPP was hired by the JLP or by the GOJ plus the fact that all has yet to be disclosed. You don't have political parties lobbying foreign governments about treaties signed between sovereign governments. It's wrong and shows lack of respect, lack of class as well as lack of intelligence. Take off your dopey political blinders, for once, and try to see the bigger picture.
8/25/2010
In my mind, the most egregious act is that under Mr. Golding's watch 73 persons died in a military incursion. I still hold to my opinion against many Jamaicans that the situation could have been avoided and should not have happened. Why did the peacemakers and representatives not succeed in deescalating the situation? Were, all the 73 persons killed, gunmen defending their Don? Was the latest Diary found on one wanted man representative of most of those killed, or the diary a fabrication?
8/25/2010
While I cannot defend the PM's lack of transparency in handling the Dudus and TG fiasco, I will defend his right to remain PM until a full investigation proves he has broken Jamaican Laws. If Mr. Golding had found it necessary to Hire Manatt and Phelps to confer with the USA re Dudus extradition, then I see nothing illegal with that move. Certainly the reason given at that time about protecting Jamaica's laws, a citizens right, and that he may have been concerned about the impact seemed right.
8/25/2010
So desperate is this regime to forward a thesis ( that everyone else are criminals and corrupt too) , that they continue to engage in political spin, to the point of being nonsensical.
Whether they like it or not, people are going to be held accountable.
8/25/2010
Somehow I just knew that my previous post on this subject would not be carried. Observer, you are so predictable.
8/25/2010
The mistake was made when Golding's apology was accepted. He should have resigned. Play back of the SG's interviews, references to Golding's explanation and examination of the emails put the govt. squarely in the middle of this sorry saga regardless of their refutation. This is slackness man, total unadulterated slackness.
8/25/2010
I continue to be amazed at the extent of the malady of the human mind, its inability in many cases to be objective and rational. Let it be clear that an individual is entitled to their love, devotion and support of political parties as they see fit, but does this destroy our ability to recognize wrong from right. Like Trafigura was wrong and the PNP had to pay for this wrong, so is the deception and lies surrounding MPP clearly wrong , be certain with all the spin, the JLP will pay.
8/25/2010
One thing I am most convinced of, especially by the oppurtunity provided through this medium is that most of the bloggers and indeed some of our commentators were never good at Maths. They simply put two and two together and they all come up with four without looking to see whether it was positive two or negative two, because how or why do they continue to same the same things without looking on the differring circumstancies and that is typical of a Maths dunce.
8/25/2010
It very difficult to take the views of a subjective journalist seriously. Lloyd B seeminly has issues with Golding and whilst some of his commentaries might be apt, one will always consider his views predictable. Golding deserves a lot of the flack that he now recieves but it is very important who the flack comes from. My support of the call for Bruce Golding's resignation arise from the fact that he was willing to expend his political capital on the Dudus issue, so he should have accepted.
8/25/2010
I love my country. I love my country more than I love any politician. For me it is God, family and country in that order.
When Bruce Golding took the oath of office in 2007, he became the Chief Servant of the people, not the JLP. How funny that most of these people have been educated in America and want to emulate the U.S.A, yet they don't practise American-style justice.
How long shall we suffer at the hands of these people? Why do we allow these people to fool us and to fool with us?
8/25/2010
I dont think any of these people in the Justice ministry realize the consequences for their actions. In any society the Solicitor General/ Attorney General have distinct responsibilities, for them to be colluding on matters if reprehensible. Dorothy sold out her clients the people, for Bruce who had his lawyer the Douglas. These people may well end up as unindicted co-conspirators in Dudus Gate. Ho what atangle web they weave. Justice in in the US is o different from Jamaica...
8/25/2010
For Jamaica to move forward, lies by public officials must not go unpunished. Immersed in Golding's "apology", was another lie.
8/25/2010
And what about the libel suit against the US paper that linked him with Dudus? Why won't he bring the matter before a court so we can all judge for ourselves?
8/25/2010
The new JLP spin is that nothing new has been revealed in the recent emails and that its earlier assertions that this was a JLP matter was reinforced. To my friends in the JLP, one question - Is Douglas Leys an attorney for the JLP or an attorney for the Government of Jamaica. Who was he representing in his direct conversations/negotiations with MPP about the Dudus matter ?
Other Stories
3 comments
By his boards we know a minister
0 comments
Getting JEEP out of the showroom
16 comments
1 comments
Secularism engulfing the Western Hemisphere
13 comments
Kay Osborne ends her glorious TVJ innings
6 comments
0 comments
Credibility is crucial to politics
7 comments
Even the horses need a day off
5 comments
Good move to reintroduce civics in schools
15 comments
Balancing politics and patriotism
1 comments
Admit it when you are off base, Mr Christie
18 comments
The glass ceiling and Parliament
2 comments
AJ's plea reflects Jamaica's great need
5 comments
0 comments
2 comments
The CDB: Realities and challenges
0 comments
0 comments
0 comments
Building a new Afghanistan, one flower at a time
1 comments




