Hear the Children's Cry condemns treatment of Mona student 3:15 PM
Health of Jamaica's children improving — Ferguson 2:58 PM
Cops looking for Jody-Ann McNarrin 2:21 PM
'Ratty' killed in motor vehicle accident 2:05 PM
Woman left lying in her own urine in jail before she died 1:15 PM
Emergency repair work disrupts water supply in St James 1:12 PM
UN: Budget cuts causing cholera deaths in Haiti 11:35 AM
Modest growth for Caribbean countries in 2012 11:32 AM
Busy denied bail 10:59 AM
Man detained over New York boy's 1979 disappearance 10:43 AM
Columns
What of JEEP if JDIP funds are depleted?
Mark Wignall
Thursday, January 19, 2012
At just about the time that the JLP administration decided to embark on its worst possible socio-political excess - the Dudus extradition/Manatt affair, crafty politicians in its ranks must have given it more than a thought that the expenditure of Jamaica Development Infrastructure Programme (JDIP) funds could save the JLP from its arrogant self and win it an election.
In the end, sudden as it was, the JDIP funds only provided the JLP government with enough rope to hang its electoral hopes on the gallows of unfolding history.
"I spent about $700 million in my constituency," said a JLP politician to me who had just lost his seat after a hard-fought battle. "In plain political language, I gained more votes from the areas where the roads were not fixed. In the places where the roads were fixed, the people who would normally vote for me refused to vote JLP because, although they got the benefit of a better road network, to them, they didn't 'eat any food' out of the programme."
Last week I had lunch with a winning PNP politician, a first-time MP. In response to my questions on JEEP, the much-vaunted PNP proposal/plan/intention/promise to provide "emergency" jobs by using JDIP funds, he said, "There is nothing left in the JDIP. It is finished. The prime minister is in negotiations with the Chinese. I assume that more funds are being sought."
I thought his answer to be rubbish and asked, "It was supposed to be a five-year programme rolling out in 2010 and going to 2015. How can the funds be depleted a little over a year after it began?"
"Apart from the works that have been completed, in the funds which would have remained, those have been contracted out in other works programmes," he said.
A few days ago I contacted someone in the JLP, an ex-MP. "He is right," he said of the PNP MP. "All the rest of the funds are tied up in forward contracts. There is only about US$9 million left and that is there to cover escalation costs."
A visit to the JDIP website states the following.
"The Jamaica Development Infrastructure Programme (JDIP) represents a major undertaking by the Government of Jamaica (GOJ) to significantly improve the island's road network in order to enhance the quality of life of the citizens of Jamaica, and to stimulate economic development.
"JDIP is the result of an innovative partnership between the GOJ and Government of China and is singly the largest, most comprehensive infrastructural programme to be implemented in Jamaica.
"The Government of China has provided funding through the Export Import (EXIM) Bank of China. This partnership has made available the sum of US$400 million (approximately J$36 billion) for a programme of works to be effected islandwide, on roads and road furniture, such as bridges, drains and traffic systems. The programme will be undertaken on all roads, both main and parochial.
"The programme will be undertaken over a period of five years, commencing in February 2010 (and ending in 2015) and will be implemented by the National Works Agency (NWA), the Executive Agency under the Ministry of Transport and Works."
Under the October 2011 summary of work, I have added up the individual contracts (from October 2010) and the expenditure total is in the region of J$16 billion. Outside of the funds which I am told are there to cover escalation costs (US$9 million), should we assume that $20 billion covers either works executed before the end of 2010 and somehow were not covered in the October 2011 summary, or contracts made after October 2011?
Although former prime minister Andrew Holness had promised an audit of the JDIP after embarrassing breaches had been revealed in an Auditor General's Report, the new PNP minister of transport and works, Omar Davies, recently announced that moves to begin the audit began only after he took office last week.
The present PNP administration has a lot riding on JEEP. When I asked the first-time PNP MP to give me a rough indication of the numbers of people in his constituency who would automatically fit the profile of those who would immediately need the intervention of an emergency programme like JEEP, he said, "About 7,000!"
Assuming that number per constituency, we could be talking about numbers in excess of 400,000 people needing work right at this minute. Even if we break it in half, that is still a staggering 200,000 people.
Certainly, Mrs Simpson Miller must have thought of the likelihood of the JDIP five-year funds being exhausted in contracts when she began to form the idea in her head that JEEP, if it had an engine, would have to be fuelled through JDIP funds.
If the JDIP audit, forensic or no, indicates the general picture that I have painted, it would simply mean that any negotiations with the Chinese would have to involve the creation of a new concept for which new funding would be sought.
Even if new funds were sought and received on the same terms as JDIP, where would our focus be in identifying the source from which these funds would be repaid? And considering that our collective backs would be against the wall in terms of us Jamaicans being seen as too many canines chasing too few bones, would it not place the Chinese in an excessively superior position at which stage they, in negotiations, could demand valuable pieces of Jamaican assets?
Will we be seeing the entire wharf network in Kingston going up for sale any time now? Would the Chinese not be interested in our railroads and see it is a natural extension of satisfying linkages from possession of our transshipment terminal and dock network as they push for added global space and influence in the Western Hemisphere?
Is there any bold, attractive north coast development that the Chinese would be looking at and wanting for a song as they sense our need to immediately satisfy socio-political promises and objectives?
As budget time rolls around this April, I expect that the strong financial institutions (read commercial banks) will be coming under pressure, not necessarily because the new government hates them, but simply because they have done extremely well and reported super profits in a country where too many people are "tiefing" ackee just to eat something.
Let us assume that funds are received from the Chinese, even with onerous terms attached, plus a banking levy to launch JEEP. Could JEEP carry 400,000 souls or 200,000 or 100,000 before it needs more gas?
And for how long?
observemark@gmail.com
POST A COMMENT
You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.
HOUSE RULES
1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.
2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.
1/20/2012
Everytime this man writes an article the PNP hacks come out to vilify him. If they are so turned off by him then why read his article and why comment? I can only conclude that the reason they do is because much of what he writes is factual. The truth always hurt. I say continue what you are doing Mark. Dont be deterred by these goonds.
1/19/2012
@ Nervous Investor et al, whatever Mark's intention and whether the JLP Administration committed the founds in advance, there are clearly good reasons for concern. Were there good reasons for all those dismissals and resignations? What about our record of corruption? So, Mark's deceptive skewing of the article to derail the JEEP does not detract from the basic fact; SOMETHING IS SERIOUSLY WRONG! Don't let party politics seize the issue. I look forward to the audit report.
1/19/2012
Nothing strange about contracts already signed. Very good article Mark, please don't be deterred by these comrades. BIG UP CLOVIS
1/19/2012
... no Gas money fi di JEEP .... eh eh ....
If the outgoing administration really has tied up the money this way in advance then I must congratulate them on such a wise move - ROFLMAO !!!!!!! That is what I call GREAT Management !!!!!! I am laughing so hard that I am in danger of wetting my pants !!!!!!! Poor Cosford ... was he hoping for one of the JEEP contracts?
ROFL HARD !!!!!!
1/19/2012
@Cosford Roberts - Thank you for the laughter - what in God's name is wrong with committing borrowed funding sourced for a particular project to that project with forward contracts (if that has indeed happened I guess that it was probably to minimize the risk / extent of potential calls for cost overruns over time). Were our so called intelligentsia born yesterday or do they just live in an Ivory Tower? This does not comment on the value for money side of the argument .. but .. Snookered? ROFL
1/19/2012
Why is it surprising that the contracts would be all signed? Before the implementation of the JDIP, a list would have been made of all of the roads etc in need of improvement, from which a final list would be made for actual funding. Once the list is final, it is prudent to sign contracts for each individual project, instead of dragging out the contract process over a number of years.
The source said that the funds are "tied up"; that does not mean that the funds do not still exist.
1/19/2012
The Auditor Gen. report into JDIP; is public; a table showed all projects assigned and the % of work completion. Works contracts usually have mobilization funds which means from the numbers of roads/contracts; there would be no large pool of cash sitting there from JDIP. I believe no major corruption will come from the forensic audit to be carried out. Minor irregularities; nothing major. Multi-lateral loans are geared towards infastructrual development projects. What is JEEP about ???.
1/19/2012
What Wignall is really trying to do is to continue to undermine the prospects of JEEP. Why? Because it will address the main concern of people right now - unemployment, and keep his beloved JLP in opposition forever.
Let us remember that Wignall predicted a JLP victory, and cannot get over the fact that his JLP boys and girls were demolished by the PNP.
1/19/2012
Again, if either of the 2 parties would have passed the anti-corruption legislation put forth by Greg Christie then I know some of the money would have been recovered and others sent to jail. Somehow I know they wont because they would be passing the law against themselves.
1/19/2012
Mark if the JLP can do this in just 10mths after it started and you Mark Predict they should be home by a few seats. I hope the PNP send everyone who has to do with this to prison from who in 70s to who is 39 everyone of them. People must wear short pants.
1/19/2012
If Wignall is remotely right, what does this say about the JLP? I will reserve any further comment and just sit and wait for the revelations, and any matters that may arise from them.
1/19/2012
@Cosford Roberts- Continue to tackle the day's tasks ahead of you, and hold on to your tears. This column by Mark Wignall wasn’t written in any way to highlight corruption in government, but more so to prove that there’s no money available from the JDIP for the funding of JEEP. So before you bloggers jump on Mark’s deceptive trip, please allow sometime for the audit process to be completed.
1/19/2012
Mark; could you give Chris Burns some objective journalistic lessons. He is such a triblist, each time the comrades try to accuse you of being bias I laugh because Chris paints everything good orange and everything bad green. We (most well thinking Jamaicans) love reading your column. Thanks for this insight......very interesting.
1/19/2012
I have also heard that funds are depleted but I don't see why anyone should be surprised.From day one the speculation was this money would be used to "purchase" the elections.All I am saying is that any skulldugery is discovered the perpetrators should go to gaol.I know politicians on both sides are friends but friendship should be put aside and allow the law to take it's course.
1/19/2012
JEEP will prove to be Jamaica Emergency Education Program. Collectively we are responsible for where we are so it is only right that we come together with workable solutions. Handouts have to come from somewhere (borrowed, grants, remittance etc) choosing the govt base on promises via borrowed funds is unrealistic. The reality is soon to be realized in JA that govt can’t solve all our problems and govt that make such promises are only contributing to more poverty. Stop creating dependencies!
1/19/2012
Mark remove JEEP from your headline, that the least of our problem. Replace it with PRISON! Head must roll for this one!
1/19/2012
If di money done already, what next? I wont comment because it will not be posted.
1/19/2012
To have a 5 year contract tied up in forward agreemen/contract is nothing new and has been happening with all long term contract since forever so this is nothing new. Having work for the pass 10 withseveral government bodies over the 2 administration I know its common to have the money on paper but not in the bank because the contracts are already given. The JEEP never had gas anyway its is a cross that bridge when we get there programme
1/19/2012
I have to agree with Fallmouth! The PNP should ignore Wignal completely. Nuh eat food wid deem man yah! He snaked the PNP at every turn for the last 10 years, showed total disrespect to it's leaders and followers, down to a level that was just plain dirty. He tried to destroy the Party and it's leadership. There is nothing good here.
1/19/2012
It is not surprising that most of the JDIP funds may already be contracted. After all, when money is borrowed, there is every incentive to invest it quickly so that it might begin generating the returns necessary to pay the carrying charges. Why borrow to sit on the money? Obviously this doesn't mean there were no improprieties in letting these contracts; just that the spending is not particularly unusual.
1/19/2012
Fall mouth, you seem to be a political blockhead. Step back and think about your country instead of your party. You may find an enlightened path to put your energies on.
Mark, The new government will realize soon, how dangerous it is 'in this time', to 'fool up the people, fi win election.' Jamaica's problems are emense, and truth and integrity in it's governance are essential to start it on the way to sustainable development. Gob bless Jamaica!
One Love!
1/19/2012
@Fall mouth just like how you are asking why any PNP should cultivate any friendship with Mark. One could also ask you why do you read his columns and also take the time to write comments. Let me answer that for you because he is good.
1/19/2012
Mark, I woke up filled with energy and ready to tackle the day's tasks then I read this article as I settled down at my desk. I am not ashamed to admit that I felt the tears deep inside my being. How could this be happening 50 years after independence while the Jamaican people yearn for a better life? All those responsible should imprisoned and made to clean the streets daily as a public example for wrong doing against the people of Jamaica. Enough is enough.
1/19/2012
If Mark is even close to be correct, don't we have a bigger problem here than JEEP on our hands. How on earth could a 5yr contract be virtually sealed up within the first year in terms of signed contract etc.
This is staggering, I will not jump to say this is the "mother of all scandals" as I do not know the nature of the contracts and how they were arrived at, but I cannot see how all the money "gone" already.
Amazing, only in Jamaica !
1/19/2012
The PNP should be too busy to have lunch with this man or cultivate him in any way. Why eat with him (if you can believe him), when it seems that his sole mission in life is to destroy the party? One can always be civil without being friendly to the stage of sitting down with him to lunch.
I don't see why the PNP should try to cultivate this "friendship." when he tried to humiliate, denigrate and discredit PSM in any way he could when she tried so many times to hand him the olive branch.
Other Stories
0 comments
Credit unions and crisis leadership
0 comments
11 comments
Crosskill's departure from TVJ marks end of an era
5 comments
Issues to consider during Child Month
0 comments
'Compassion without Compromise': Church throws down the gauntlet
23 comments
Gloria Palomino: A lifetime of voluntary service to the police
0 comments
2 comments
Parents have ultimate responsibility for their children
5 comments
0 comments
Needed: a collective voice in the G20 for developing countries
0 comments
No growth without social cohesion
0 comments
Let's get our priorities right
1 comments
A high price to pay for physical perfection
0 comments
0 comments
A time to deal with the CAL/Liat conflict
0 comments
Greece gets another chance to tackle its fiscal dilemma
0 comments
Time for a revolution in education
1 comments
Obama: President, not Pastor of America
15 comments
Taxi drivers and a clean Kingston Harbour
4 comments





