Why Norman Girvan matters


Sunday, April 13, 2014

Print this page Email A Friend!

The death of Professor Norman Girvan, one of the Caribbean's most acclaimed public intellectuals, has left a huge void in the public square of debate and ideas about realisng our human, social and economic potential at a time when the region is going through its worst development crisis in a long time.

It's ironic that this quintessential Caribbean man from Jamaica and living in Trinidad died in a Havana hospital three months after he became paralysed following what I can only describe as a freakish fall while on a hiking holiday on Dominica's famed walking tour. He died as he lived.

Having known Norman from our days at Calabar High School, through several decades as a colleague, I share a sense of loss with his legion of friends and professional colleagues across the Caribbean and much of the developing world. As we mourn his death we also extend our sympathies to his family.

Norman Girvan was many things: As an academic, he taught economics for several decades and held senior positions, including professor of development studies and director of the Sir Arthur Lewis Institute of Social and Economic Studies, and, until recently, was professorial research fellow at the Institute of International Relations at the University of the West Indies (UWI), St Augustine campus in Trinidad and Tobago.

As a political economist, Professor Girvan was part of the New World Group at the UWI in the 1960s and 70s questioning the limitations of the political independence that many former British colonies won in the 1960s.

Through works such as Foreign Capital and Economic Underdevelopment in Jamaica and Copper in Chile Professor Girvan gave policymakers a much clearer understanding of how transnational corporations functioned and manipulated extractive industries for their bottom line with scant regard for the peoples who inhabited the lands in which these minerals were located.

In Jamaica's case, his public scholarship and private policy advice greatly influenced then Prime Minister Michael Manley's development of the bauxite levy which greatly increased revenue from that sector.

He was also a public official serving in the 1970s as head of the National Planning Agency of Jamaica and later as secretary general of the Association of Caribbean States, (ACS).

He has also been the United Nations secretary general's personal representative on the Guyana-Venezuela Border Controversy and a member of the United Nations Committee on Development Policy. He also served as a board member of South Centre, one of the foremost think tanks on issues of concern to developing countries.

Girvan has published extensively on the political economy of development in the Caribbean and the global south and was the recipient of several honours and awards, including an honorary doctorate of economic sciences from the University of Havana, Cuba. Much of his scholarship is freely shared on his website www.normangirvan.info.

What really mattered about all these activities was that they were part of a passion that guided his work and professional interests, namely, the imperative of regional integration as the basis for the people of the region to realise the development and growth of the disparate states that comprise the Caribbean archipelago.

Being an advocate and participant in the various regional integration efforts after the collapse of the political federation in 1961, Girvan would have been disappointed by the minimal progress of mechanisms like Caricom and the CSME. But he never despaired.

In one of his more recent writings he said: "I firmly believe that true integration can never be purely, or even primarily, a matter of economics; one that is driven by the calculus of costs and benefits.

"Economics must play its part, of course. But the bedrock of integration must be a sense, not so much of common identity because we do not have identical identities, but what could be called a 'community of identities' -- identities fashioned in response to a very special historical experience; an experience that we all share in one way or another."

That's the vision of a wider community not linked by hyphens, such as English-Caribbean, Spanish-Caribbean, Dutch-Caribbean and so on.

It is as part of this wider Caribbean that Girvan had been concerned about issues such as race in Cuba; reparations from enslavement; denationalisation of more than 210,000 Dominican Republic citizens because of their Haitian ancestry; and the continuing anachronistic United States embargo against Cuba.

Another irony of the timing of his death is that it occurred when the US Administration has forced PriceSmart Jamaica to suspend the accounts of Cubans living in Jamaica. It's about time that the US heed the wishes of most of the world and many of its own citizens and corporations and end an embargo that does nothing for American goodwill in Latin America and the Caribbean.

Confessions of a wayward economist

In a 2013 essay subtitled 'Confessions of a wayward economist' Girvan began to muse on whether cultural production can succeed where politics and economics have failed to engage the regional integration project. Music, dance, spiritualism and folk rituals "are the common language of the Caribbean" and they can be used as a unifier in a region of many spoken languages.

"Let me say that there is no question in my mind that culture, widely defined, holds the key to wider Caribbean integration. It is the means by which we develop a consciousness of ourselves as a regional people and of fostering mutual understanding and respect across the boundaries of language and ethnicity.

The sense of the Caribbean as a 'community of culture' that one experiences on these occasions stands in curious contrast with the difficulties that have been encountered in configuring the Caribbean as an economic and political community. Can we therefore not propose the establishment of a Caribbean cultural community?

It is a question that needs to be explored by the successors to the public intellectual baton that Norman Girvan passed on last week. The development of a sense of Caribbean self has been -- and continues to be -- a "constant struggle" between the legacy of our colonial inheritance and "the seductive distractions of so-called globalisation".

Unlike many of our generation, Norman wholeheatedly embraced the new communication technologies and helped to establish the website 1804CaribVoices, a forum for rethinking Caribbean history and the fight for independence.

Established January 1, 2013 -- the 209th anniversary of Haiti's Declaration of Independence and the 54th anniversary of the Cuban Revolution -- 1804CaribVoices was "inspired by the freedom struggles of Caribbean people through the centuries".

A comment on the site says 1804CaribVoices "will aim to give expression to the myriad voices calling for a united and sovereign Caribbean with social justice, responsible governance and sustainable living".

When Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago marked the 50th anniversary of Independence in 2012, SALISES (Sir Arthur Lewis Institute of Social and Economic Studies) of the University of the West Indies hosted a special conference to mark the milestone.

An editorial in this newspaper commenting on the conference argued that "... the root of our regional problems is the crisis of Caribbean thought. There is an inextricable link between thought and public policy and the state of the Caribbean." It was a call to action for the intellectual class.

At this time of challenge, when most Caribbean economies are under the gun, when violent crime and social dysfunction threaten to become the new norm, when policy options shrink in the context of the crisis in capitalism we need a new generation of public intellectuals to help shape new directions for these times. We owe it to Norman Girvan's legacy to continue his work.





1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper � email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

comments powered by Disqus



Today's Cartoon

Click image to view full size editorial cartoon