|
YouTube™ Channel
RSS Feeds twitter™

Editorial

Nationalism vs patriotism

Wednesday, August 25, 2010



THE wave of national pride that has been sweeping the country since late Monday night when Ms Yendi Phillipps placed second in the prestigious Miss Universe pageant in Las Vegas is reminiscent of the mood among Jamaicans — both here and abroad — when our athletes excelled at the Beijing Olympics in August 2008 and at the World Championships in Berlin a year later.

Ms Phillipps created history by being the first Jamaican to finish among the top three in this contest and as such deserves our heartiest congratulations.

Her achievement, we submit, was no easy feat, and it could not have come at a better time, as Jamaica is still recovering from the damage to its image sparked by the late May operation in Tivoli Gardens to arrest Mr Christopher 'Dudus' Coke and to repel a brazen attack on the state by gunmen.

But even as we celebrate Ms Phillipps' accomplishment, we cannot avoid highlighting the stark difference we have noticed here between nationalism and patriotism.

For despite the swell of national pride in our chests, there are still too many of us who do not appreciate the value of pitching in to help build the country.

Take, for example, the people who avoid paying taxes, yet are among the first to complain about poor infrastructure. The sad fact is that the majority of these people are professionals who know better but choose to ignore their responsibility to the country. They, of course, will proudly display their nationalism when necessary. But being nationalistic does not mean that Jamaica is a land we love.

For if we did indeed love Jamaica, we would care for the country in much the same way we care for our families and will do almost anything to help them develop and make them safe and happy.

Jesus Christ exhorted and challenged mankind to extend that willingness to help others beyond our immediate circle of family and friends. When He said love thy neighbour, He was telling us to be willing to help others whether we like them or not, and even if they are strangers.

This dictum, we submit, is not idealism but good sense, because if practised it makes us all better off.

We acknowledge, of course, that there are some Jamaicans who are trying to live by this credo, but they are a small minority, overwhelmed by the vast majority who care only about themselves.

However, a country cannot achieve its full potential for economic and social development without the majority of its citizens having a spirit of patriotism which, we recognise, is largely lacking among the generation born after Independence.

The task of instilling in that generation the patriotism that this country so badly needs will be difficult, given that so many of us are unapologetically materialistic, self-centred and prone to migration.

It is, however, not impossible. What it will require is outstanding leadership -- leadership of the kind displayed by the late United States president Mr John F Kennedy, who is remembered for his famous charge to America: "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country."


POST A COMMENT


You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.

HOUSE RULES

 

1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.



Comment (required):

You have characters left.
captcha 83b240db63f0498b978958cc1335e479
Enter text seen above:

For information about privacy please read our Privacy Policy.

I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions


COMMENTS (21)

Jason G
8/28/2010
Patriotism is a strong subject. This article is logically insufficient as it fails to address some of the basic philosophies behind patriotism.
george watson
8/27/2010
I get so much more out of the postings than from most of the Obs. articles, editorials included. I was going to say to A.Watson that being a good runner takes a whole lot of hard work while one is blessed with beauty, but I guess even if born beautiful and we don't take care of our teeth and our hair, our complexion and our thoughts then it will go.
My only problem with beauty contests is that beauty cannot be across races. Each race has its criteria but we use that of the Caucasian only.
george watson
8/27/2010
This would have been a good editorial if the patriotism bit was instilled at an earlier time. Not paying taxes is nothing new; in fact if truth be told this government is doing a better job at collection than the previous PNP government.
One should not only be patriotic at certain times, however. After all, all governments need taxes to do what they have to do, and countries like Jamaica cannot afford to pay the taxes that are necessary for the things we have grown accustomed to.
Carpe Diem
8/26/2010
When we say we feel proud of the achievement of other Jamaicans, what does that really mean? What we are really doing is trying to take a shortcut to glory. That is, we sit back and bask in the adulation heaped upon the individuals (and by extension, Ja), with no understanding of the hard work and determination that it takes. Apart from being Jamaican, what do Bob Marley, T.P. Lecky, Usain Bolt, Jodi-Ann Maxwell, Yendi Phillips, Merlene Ottey, Lisa Hanna, Rex Nettleford all have in common?
Carpe Diem
8/26/2010
So Yendi almost won the Miss Universe contest. Good for her. Bad for Jamaica. We already know that we are an exceptionally gifted ppl. We have the accolades to prove that. I put it to you that that is one of our problems. We are like addicts who get our regular fix ("national pride") from individual effort therefore there is no need to unite as a nation in order to feel that "national pride". Fill in the blanks: Jamaica, famous for ___; Singapore, famous for ___; Japan, famous for ___
John Smith
8/25/2010
Editor, I think this is a noble attempt to highlight the most important distinction between nationalism and patriotism. Many people seem to want to equate one with the other. I noticed there were several of those people during the Dudus debacle saying; "Dudus must stay here because the USA is a big bad bully." The distinction needs to be highlighted more. I note also that many people who have the option to migrate are much more patriotic than those who choose (or have) to stay.
Ash Lee
8/25/2010
OK... this article need to wheel and come again! I don't think most people have or would have a problem with paying taxes, etc. if it wasn't for the blatant, longstanding corruption and raping of our country... Also most countries use tax not only to run the gv't (which should include providing needed resources for the needs/benefit of the country) but also tax breaks to bolster enterprise and encourge entrepreneurship! This will in turn provide more jobs and additional resources... Please!!!
Paul Gentles
8/25/2010
Dear Editor - I am still looking for the part of your editorial which addresses Patriotism.
zara thustra
8/25/2010
Beauty pageants are shallow, banal and racist. If resurgent patriotism is as a result of this then it is no wonder we are in the position we are in as a nation.
Wa Tch
8/25/2010
What the heck is this? Are you living in Jamaica? Matters of critical importance are taking center stage your editorial is based on this. How can we take pride when we have a govt. that is intent on hiding from the truth and dragging our reputation through the mud.
Get with the program Observer.
Andrea Watson
8/25/2010
I bet Brooklyn Jamaica was teased when growning up about being ugly. Would it be fair to say "running fas"t is not anything to get excited about?.
Bal Ance
8/25/2010
@Kgn 13 Yute - My yute so true... You don't to look any further than how this paper's cartoonist continuously depicts Portia Simpson.
Bal Ance
8/25/2010
@Brooklyn Jamaica - Your point is absolutely clear. Of course we are proud of her achievement. However a beauty contest which is all it is despite big media and money. If you and I are wrong then it would occur to me that Jamaicans should all aspire to be athletes, entertainers and models instead of building industries. I am sure the editor's point is that we need to take pride in ourselves as a people for the state of our country.
David Armstrong
8/25/2010
This editorial is too superficial in that it makes pious and virtuous statements that have no relationship to the subject matter or the reality that exist in Jamaica. Take for example the statement: “For if we did indeed love Jamaica, we would care for the country in much the same way we care for our families and will do almost anything to help them develop and make them safe and happy.” Some families are dysfunctional and they create mayhem and destructive behavior towards their family and society. The same is true about Jamaica, it is a dysfunctional state.
key martin
8/25/2010
we need to be proud of all of our achievers athletes, beauty queens , artistes and our citizens who excel in education. Give all of them the props they deserve
Brooklyn Jamaican
8/25/2010
Beswick I stand by my comments. Being born pretty or being eye candy is not an achievement. I am not putting down the young lady I am just saying do not get carried away by beauty contests which are just certified flesh fests.
Bal Ance
8/25/2010
Patriotism is eroded as any progress made does not transcend. P.A.Y.E. individuals are among the poorest yet they pay all their taxes. What incentive is that to a tax dodger?
ernie beswick
8/25/2010
Brooklyn Jamaican, you are talking rubbish, we should be proud of a Jamaican what ever she or she does across world in no matter what field, beauty contest, politics, cricket, running, medicine, or other fields .We are the most famous island on earth, not because of the murder rate, but ask yourself how can a small island produce music, runners, coffee, beautiful women and people like Marcus Garvey and Mary Secole who is still look upon today across the globe.Just imagine what we could achieve.
kgn 13 yute
8/25/2010
Then we are told that looks don'tt matter, its what is inside. I've learned over the years that only ugly people say that.
Now we should be proud of a pretty jamaican, ask the ones not so blessed with beauty how they feel
Marlene Palmer
8/25/2010
I'm too busy being self centered, materialistic and distracted to be worrying about being patriotic. After all it's not my responsibility to get involved that's someone else responsibility. It's not my responsibility to educate myself about the history of my country both the good and the bad, So what if the PNP and JLP are destroying our country there's nothing I can do about it, all I can do is sit back watch, hope and pray that things get better after all isn't that what Marcus, Michael, Malcolm and Martin did? "It's not about what I can do for my country but what my country can do for me."
Brooklyn Jamaican
8/25/2010
I am sorry, but being born better looking or being more pleasing to the eyes is no reason for celebration or for us to be proud or carried away.

How will men speak Mr Wilmot Perkins' name?

  1 comments

 

Building our own national identity is important

  1 comments

 

Kudos for Monday night football and Montego Bay United

  2 comments

 

Kudos to GraceKennedy for its impressive vision

  3 comments

 

Nice move on that 'Kingston Interview Waiver Programme'

  1 comments

 

The unenviable task facing Dr Peter Phillips

  1 comments

 

A compelling case for evidence sharing

  14 comments

 

How Belize is showing up Jamaica

  7 comments

 

The challenge facing our woman in London

  6 comments

 

Now that Captain Burrell has spoken...

  1 comments

 

Public sector waste scandalous

  4 comments

 

Miss Lisa Hanna's first real test

  10 comments

 

Revealing the bitter medicine no one wants to take

  12 comments

 

Commissioner Ellington is right on this one

  3 comments

 

Facing the hard realities

  12 comments

 

A word to Dr Phillips: Credibility has a short shelf life

  11 comments

 

Usain, Yohan must stay on guard

  6 comments

 

The importance of trust and the IMF negotiations

  4 comments

 

Sir Patrick in a political pickle

  16 comments

 

What's in a name as long as it spells jobs?

  16 comments

 

Today's Cartoon


Poll

Did you watch American football's Super Bowl on Sunday? 
Yes, but just for the advertisements
Yes, just for the game itself
Yes, for both the game and advertisements
No, I did not watch the Super Bowl.

View Results

Results published weekly in Sunday Finance


Username:
Password: