Editorial
Respect due to Mr Shaw
Wednesday, March 03, 2010
Congratulations are due to Mr Audley Shaw, the embattled minister of finance, whose appointment, we'll remember, was greeted by derision by the Opposition, doubt by the financial sector, concern by his party colleagues and belittling scepticism from some media commentators.
His competence was questioned and his every pronouncement subjected to expressions of disbelief.
We note, however, that Mr Shaw seems to have silenced his critics, including his would-be nemesis, Dr Omar Davies. His achievements have been outstanding, given the desperate economic situation he inherited, compounded by the global financial crisis and handicapped by a weak technical team.
In these circumstances, we believe that Mr Shaw deserves to be congratulated, in the same way we lashed him for the botched tax package late last year.
His critics might want to send him an apology for writing off his prediction that he could get massive sums from multilateral financial institutions at very low rates of interest. The record shows that since assuming office, he has mobilised almost US$3 billion. The $1.25-billion from the International Monetary Fund is one of its most highly financed as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product. It will be accompanied by an additional $1 billion from the World Bank, the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) and the Caribbean Development Bank (CDB).
The World Bank has come up with $200 million in policy support. The IDB has lent over $1 billion, in fact, more money to the Government in the last two years than in all of its previous years. The CDB entered into policy lending for the first time in its history to support Jamaica.
The interest rate on the World Bank loan is one per cent and on the IDB loans it is 1.23 per cent. This is even lower than the three per cent money that Mr Shaw claimed he could get.
He has changed the economic team with a new Bank of Jamaica governor and a not-so new financial secretary. He has brought in a new technical advisor with a PhD in Economics. He is getting along even better now and without the 'help' of Mr Don Wehby.
A unique and unprecedented debt swap has happened on his watch with almost 100 per cent voluntary participation and without any fallout in capital flight or exchange rate depreciation. The financial system has responded with patriotism and in a manner that demonstrates belief in the direction of economic policy.
Mr Shaw has broken the self-perpetuating cycle of outrageously high interest rates on domestic national debt. Interest rates have been brought down dramatically and the gluttonous commercial banks have been forced to start doing their core business of lending.
He has increased taxation, albeit with the embarrassing scaling down of the tax package, and signalled the intention of his Government to reduce public sector employment. He has had to stand up to enormous pressure for public sector wage increases, and has told the nation that the beloved Air Jamaica has to be sold or closed. These are among the most politically unpleasant announcements any politician has had to make.
He and Prime Minister Bruce Golding have courageously changed the course of Jamaica's economic policy by finally abandoning attempts to postpone fiscal adjustment and trying to finance fictitious growth by borrowing.
Through all of this stress and strain, he has maintained his sense of humour, his sartorial comportment and his calm earnestness.
Take a bow, Mr Shaw.
POST A COMMENT
You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.
HOUSE RULES
1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.
2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.
3/10/2010
kiss teeth... how many budgets in one year? .... How many tax increases?
3/9/2010
Jamaica has become of place where we applaud announcements! JAMAICA WILL BE WORSE OFF! Mind you, he did not create the problem BUT HE IS CONTRIBUTING TO IT. The chickens will soon come home to roose. THENBLAME IT ON OMAR AND PNP.
3/9/2010
Any well thinking and intelligent Jamaican can see that the derided Mr Shaw stand head and shoulders above his predecessor. It is the first time for a long that we have had a minister makes a promise and actually kept it, whether by coincidence or otherwise. He said it and it happenend. We might agree that this is the easy part and the difficulty is to ensure that worthwhile investments are undertaken that will redound to the benefit of the country. I hate when political hacks fail to appreciate the best of the worse.
3/6/2010
Plush plush---- What are you saying?---"How can someone be praised for negotiating loans for a already indebted country?'---- Can you see no worthy praise in a country which is already indebted, negotiating a LOWER INTEREST loan that what prevails? Clearly Mr.Shaw was not responsible for the pre-existing indebtedness, but in coming into office, has not only not continued the status quo, but has negotiated rates more favorable to the country. Is this not indeed the FIRST STEP towards---as you said 'to be able to run this country from it's earnings'.
Plush plush, Here's a quote for you...."When one finds onself in a deep hole, the FIRST thing to do is STOP DIGGING"
One Love!
3/5/2010
It is true that a drowning man clutch at a straw. You people are so pathetic. How can someone be praised for negotiating loans for a already indebted country? When will we be able to run the country from our earnings? I wonder what is the national debt now? How much money has the Loan Ranger added to the national debt so far? Do you think the IMF and the world bank genuinely have our interest at heart? The only interest they have at heart is the interest that they will collect over 26 years repayment. 26 times 4% equal 104. Mr. Shaw is happy because this means more political spoils to finance the party. We need a need breed of well thinking individuals to run this country. We need to get rid of the whole bunch.
3/4/2010
Fact is JLP govt. economically and socially doing better, than any year of former PNP adminstration.
3/4/2010
Hope Alive -: Guess you also didn't read the article that explains that an Editorial is the internally agreed opinion of the senior management of a newspaper? On a side note, the "Editorial cartoon" reflects the opinion of the editor even if he personally cannot draw at all.
Lisa Betts-: Debt should used to increase your earning power. One major hindrance to productivity is the poor state of our minor roads.
george watson-: Is it coincidence that the IMF ordered him to do what he promised before going into office or did they order him to say these things in the years before he became minister?
Editor -: Proper protocol is to name the senior officers of the newspaper on the "contact us" page or on a "Corporate" page.
3/3/2010
Thanks for saying what a lot of rational people are saying. I say rational deliberately because, unfortunately, politics has so invaded the mind of many that they can only see things from a party political perspective. For those whose minds are thus enslaved, they will not see any reason for saluting Mr Shaw's success.
One jusrt hopes that his efforts will usher in the new phase of economic development has has evadewd us under the high intestt rate regimes.
Take another bow Mr. Shaw.
Lloyd A Vermont
3/3/2010
Give thanks and praise to him who worked diligently to serve the Jamaican people. Thank God for sound minds in leadership; they never smoke 'ganjah!'
3/3/2010
George Watson's post ------"before we begin praising him as the best finance minister Jamaica ever had,"------- Where in this editorial was it implied that Mr. Shaw is being praised as the 'best finance minister Jamaica ever had'? The editorial simply states the KNOWN facts, and suggest that acknowledgement is due. It's a fair and balanced editorial and in my opinion a well deserved acknowledgement of Mr. Shaw's work.
One Love!
3/3/2010
Mr Audley Shaw's policies of low interest rate and going to the multilateral lending institution were not implemented at the IMF dictates as George Watson and other desperate comrades are now promoting. Its the exact policies that Mr. Shaw use to put forward from he was in opposition. He was always ridiculed and told by the PNP including Dr. Omar Davies that and the more that 90 percent media practitions/commentators/analyts that that was impossible. Some are dumb struck now, but I am sure that they are just waiting on one opportunity to POUNCE on Audley and the JLP again. To me the greatest error that the JLP made since coming to power was to run the PNP's economic 'MUDDLE' for little over two years.
A question that needs to be ask is, if there was no recession, would Jamaica economy reflect a growth bigger than any PNP year?
ReplyReply AllMove...Inbox
3/3/2010
Oh how desperate George Watson any the comrades are. Its the exact policies that Mr. Shaw always advocated from he was in opposition. He was ridiculed by the PNP and the more that 90 percent media practitions/commentators/analyts. Some are presently dumb struck but I am sure that they are just waiting on one hint to POUNCE on Audley again. To me the greatest error that the JLP made since coming to power was to run the PNP economic 'MUDDLE' for little over two years.
A question that needs to be ask is, if there was no recession, would Jamaica economy reflect a growth bigger than any PNP year?
3/3/2010
The person who writes an editorial does not have to declare who he or she is, therefore, I will not even read the article. Utter rubbish!
3/3/2010
Just goes to show that being bright and 'lettered' is useful..........but way overrated......
My colleague related an incident from a visit to Britain in which some committee was being formed and there was a policy of seeking to include member (on the committee) with COMMON SENSE........yes.......no other qualification but COMMON SENSE.....
.
I am sill taken aback..!!....
3/3/2010
US dollar debt to do what ? - should he really be congratulated for this? - no congratulations should be in order to borrow US dollars to fix "housing scheme roads" - "run wid it" - whichever side of the political fence you are on
3/3/2010
Thank you Observer.
I was wondering IF and WHEN Mr. Shaw would be given the credit he RICHLY DESERVES.
I still read comments about the JLP government being "incompetent" which causes me to wonder if the achievements I am seeing are in another country.
Credit must be given where credit is due, and I wondered why so many are blind to the GLARING fact that this government's financial policies are WAY SUPERIOR to those of Dr. Omar Davies and the previous PNP administration. And I speak more to comments posted in this forum than from the media at large.
3/3/2010
I don’t always agree with the position that you take on many issues but I must say that this is a fair assessment of Mr. Shaw performance.
Also, I think that the Observer Newspaper is the most objective and balance of all the daily newspaper in Jamaica.
3/3/2010
I think what Mr. Shaw did was at the dictates of the IMF, so what are you praising him about? Of course how he did it was completely bad and will have repercussions on this and future governments to trust their government with their money again. Mr. Editor you seem to think that it is the same day leaf fall a riva bottom it rotten. Wait until they need money to borrow again.
We should also wait to see what they will do with this "debt swop" before we begin praising him as the best finance minister Jamaica ever had, as you seem anxious to do. And what about this collective responsibility you always talk about..
3/3/2010
Emballted by who?
You mean the corrupt former Comrade Government and their agents of the 4th Plantation?
In any case it early days yet keep unno powdah dry because if it becomes necessary for Mer. Shaw to take more action to carrect it I am pretty sure ole house will tumble dung pon him in a hurry.
There is still that matter of the Public Service, including the Nurses, Teachers, Police, Fire, etc who have not yet got the message that Jamaica is stone broke.
Other Stories
How will men speak Mr Wilmot Perkins' name?
1 comments
Building our own national identity is important
1 comments
Kudos for Monday night football and Montego Bay United
2 comments
Kudos to GraceKennedy for its impressive vision
3 comments
Nice move on that 'Kingston Interview Waiver Programme'
1 comments
The unenviable task facing Dr Peter Phillips
1 comments
A compelling case for evidence sharing
14 comments
How Belize is showing up Jamaica
7 comments
The challenge facing our woman in London
6 comments
Now that Captain Burrell has spoken...
1 comments
Public sector waste scandalous
4 comments
Miss Lisa Hanna's first real test
10 comments
Revealing the bitter medicine no one wants to take
12 comments
Commissioner Ellington is right on this one
3 comments
12 comments
A word to Dr Phillips: Credibility has a short shelf life
11 comments
Usain, Yohan must stay on guard
6 comments
The importance of trust and the IMF negotiations
4 comments
Sir Patrick in a political pickle
16 comments
What's in a name as long as it spells jobs?
16 comments




