The present PNP is mere perfume from its political past

Wignall's World

Mark Wignall

Sunday, December 18, 2011


IN the summer of 1967 I met Gigi and fell head over heels in love with her. To me, she was the prettiest girl in the world.

Like me, she was 17, and on her birthday she presented me with a neatly wrapped package containing a perfume made by Avon called Wild Country. The relationship lasted for a little over a year and long after that when she had travelled abroad to find her fortune I used Wild Country until I embarked on another amorous mission.

Each time I got a whiff of it, it conjured up images of my sweet Gigi. Now, I have long forgotten what Wild Country smells like, but if it still exists and I should come into its closeness I would 'see' Gigi.

In reality, Gigi would now be 61, but if I want to keep my fantasy going, it would suit me not to meet her should she ever visit Jamaica. I have that image of her and that smell of her perfume and if I want to keep that dream alive it suits me to imagine her young, beautiful and untouched at 17.

Which brings me to the PNP, its past glory and the present whiff of its past when its leaders, though flawed like all humans, were unafraid to stand out in front and be the best that they could be.

Last week I was in discussion with a group of old 'PNP socialists' who, though concerned that their party is likely to lose the next elections, were however still contending that the PNP is the better of the two parties. My question to them was, 'which PNP?'

Was it the PNP of the past or is it the PNP whose memory is 'etched' in the whiff of a perfume.

Having had two of the best leaders in Norman Manley and his son, Michael, I find it difficult to place Portia Simpson Miller in the same company as these men, even though they are no longer with us. Both Manleys were proud of their intellectual traditions and believe those were best suited in leadership for the advancement of the people.

Both men, along with PJ Patterson, were never unsure of themselves and unafraid to face up to the burning issues of the moment. All were never shy of tackling the leadership of the JLP in critical assessments of current and long-term directions. Today, however, we see a PNP leader more comfortable with populist rants from the political platform and still believing that all one has to do is show up and the magic will reappear.

Some have said that the elder Manley was a bit of an elitist, as if somehow it was a sin to strive for the best for this nation. Like the late Professor Carl Stone who believed that Michael Manley squandered valuable political capital during the 1970s, I too share the belief that Michael, like no other leader before or after, had the best chance of addressing and dealing with our problems.

To me, he wasted too much of that time in incendiary political rhetoric and in stirring up class warfare without a consideration of the fallout, both here and in the global space.

Months ago the late Professor Aggrey Brown invited me to give a presentation to a group of graduate students visiting the UWI Mona campus. My presentation was titled, 'Jamaican Political Culture and Contemporary Jamaican Politics.'

At one stage of the presentation I suggested that Michael Manley was much too intelligent a man to have so misread the intentions of our great, powerful neighbour to the north, the USA. To me, the worst decision ever made by one of the best political leaders of this country was to tackle head on the USA.

And Michael, in his convenient political naivety, did not know that America would push back after his fiery rhetoric and promises to 'walk to the mountain top with Castro?'

After I had completed the presentation and was into the question and answer phase, when I was expanding on the political exigencies of the time and suggested that all political leaders in the Caribbean in the Cold War period of the 1970s should have recognised the 'might is right' Monroe Doctrine of America and that Manley was the very author of the American push-back and the likely presence of CIA operations in Jamaica, the late professor, seated beside me, turned to me and said, sotto voce, "But he was right though, he was right."

I understand a political leader being right with his conscience, but what about in the fallout felt among the people he leads?

That said however, even when Michael was on what some saw as the wrong path, he was never afraid to openly defend it.

PJ Patterson was helped by Eddie Seaga

I voted in the February 1989 general election for the JLP but in the next election in March 1993, I voted for the PNP.

What was it which prompted both decisions?

First, I had voted for the JLP before, in 1980, 1986 local and in 1989 when I did so again, it was because of two matters.

One, I was an admirer of Seaga's management of the economy in the latter part of the 1980s, even though much more could have been achieved, considering that during that period Jamaica was receiving from America the second highest economic aid per capita, bettered only by Israel.

Two, after the devastation wrought by one of the most vicious hurricanes of the century (Gilbert - direct east to west hit on September 12, 1988) Seaga's open management of that crisis made him, to me, the fitter man for prime minister than Michael Manley.

By 1993, however, much had changed. Nationally, Seaga proved to be worse in opposition than in government. He brooked no internal opposition and ran the JLP as if it were an extension of his backyard.

As 1993 rolled around, the Manley-led PNP Government elected in 1989 was on the verge of being the first one-term Government. The zinc scandal, the furniture scandal and especially the Shell waiver scandal were conspiring to tear the PNP apart.

Manley had detected illness of body in 1986 and it had grown worse by the early 1990s. The Shell waiver scandal had demoted Patterson, but when Manley recognised that his health would not allow him to be an effective prime minister, in 1992 there was an internal election for PNP president.

As of a not so recent past, Portia Simpson was the people's favourite, but in the delegate race she was bettered by Patterson. Prior to being elected by PNP delegates to the PNP presidency, Patterson had faced Portia Simpson in a national debate.

The debate was an absolute disaster for Simpson. It indicated that she had no grasp of any of the important issues. At one stage of the debates when she was fumbling badly in attempting to unravel a question, Patterson stepped in and rescued her by suggesting that what his 'comrade' colleague was trying to say was... and then he went on to speak on her behalf, in a debate!

All of Carl Stone's polls changed rapidly from November 1992 to February 1993. And it all had to do with a new PNP leader facing off with a JLP opposition leader who was perceived by many members of the public to be much too belligerent and dictatorial.

As much as I voted PNP in March 1993, it was not a vote for the PNP as much as it was an anti-Seaga vote. To me, Patterson as a leader did not fit the bill of 'transformative', but Seaga made him appear much better than he was. Also, Patterson being no student of sociology as Seaga was, tended to have a more instinctive understanding of the people. After all, he resembled them and shared much more socio-culturally with them than Seaga.

PJ Patterson could also defend himself publicly, and even though he was a most boring speaker, he had a grasp of the major issues, PNP style.

In the present PNP leader is a person who, as a first resort, is much too uncomfortable in facing up to important and pressing current issues squarely. Where competent leaders tend to have a ready-made squad of second tier political personnel delegated to handle lesser matters, one gets the sense that Simpson Miller doesn't delegate, she hides instead from the public because she is unsure of herself.

The number one question is, what had she been doing all of these years since 1976? The other questions are, where is her own, personal development and what has she done with it in an effective manner since that time to assist her in national leadership?

Very little, by my estimates.

Facing up to Andrew Holness

Unlike any of the current crop of political leaders, the JLP's Andrew Holness is the only one in many years to have come to this nation and opened up with anything resembling the raw, unvarnished, unpalatable truth.

Where America is hurting and European nations are delicately balancing their advanced economies on a knife edge, the PNP is prepared to tell us that, 'Things will be nice again' because it (the PNP) is inherently disrespectful of the electorate, of which many have wised up to the global and national realities.

Granted, there are still the political diehards who want white rum and curry goat, but over the last 15 years those have been joined by a growing army of informed voters who simply want to be told the unvarnished truth. I am not saying that the JLP has suddenly grown a conscience. The fact is, it is still a difficult party to manage and the mindset of some is still in the past.

What I am heartened at is more than the whiff of change where Holness is prepared to walk out in front and take charge and declare that he is the one responsible and the buck stops with him.

His handling of the JDIP scandal is food for thought. Contrast that with the Trafigura scandal of 2006 when Mrs Simpson Miller was prime minister. She retreated, and for about 10 days handed responsibility for outing the fire to her PNP gurus.

Going back further in time, when the Shell waiver scandal broke at the beginning of the 1990s, the late Prime Minister Michael Manley was on the airwaves taking charge like any leader should do. When the minister under whose portfolio the scandal arose (PJ Patterson) was forced to resign and then declared, 'I shall return' the nation was in no doubt as to who was in charge -- Michael Manley.

When the JDIP scandal broke, in similar fashion, the young no-nonsense Andrew Holness made the critical and difficult decision and Transport and Works Minister Mike Henry resigned, and the nation was in absolutely no doubt as to who was leading from the front, who was in charge -- Andrew Holness.

When Trafigura broke in 2006 and then Information Minister and PNP Gen Sec Colin Campbell resigned, one sensed that it came after PNP gurus had met and deliberated. The face and the voice of party leader and then Prime Minister Portia Simpson Miller were conspicuously absent. No one was in charge!

It is my belief that Jamaicans will be voting for a leader who is unafraid to make the tough decisions and make them while in touch with the people. The people will vote for a leader who is unafraid of his shadow and who will walk out in front and represent their collective resourcefulness and talents.

Such a leader does not now exist in the PNP and it will be the PNP's undoing come December 29.

Debates can move the independent voter

As the debates earn discussions nationally, we are increasingly learning that the best speakers are capable of giving the worst information through the most eloquently couched answers.

It is not automatic that the lesser skilled debaters are ill-equipped with knowledge, only that they are deficient in using deception as well as the better presenters.

I am reminded of an incident which took place in the 1970s during a time when workshop representation was sought in boardrooms in the new 'democratisation'.

A union delegate short on brains sat through a board meeting during which time the discussions floated over his head. The poor man did not understand almost all of what was said. When he was asked to make an input, he simply said, 'I have nothing to add.'

As he returned to the shop floor his fellow workers surrounded him. 'So, how it go man?' they asked.

Totally befuddled himself, he turned to his fellow workers and said, 'It nuh mek no sense mi tell onnu. Onnu nah go understand anyway!'

He escaped by conferring on his fellow workers, ignorance when it was he who was so afflicted.

The intelligent voter tends to be one who has no automatic attachment to a particular political party. He may have a preference but it is never carved in stone. Where both the JLP and the PNP tend to be driven by the face of the leader, the intelligent voter is more moved by knowing that the party leader can articulate a coherent vision for the country.

It is not enough that a leader in a debate 'Gi a good talk.' It must be wrapped around a firm intellectual understanding of the human and physical resource constraints of the country and the global space within which that polity must participate. Loving the people is good, and compassion is never an overworn attribute. But in political leadership much more is needed.

Holness's resumé matches his years but he has, in the last few weeks, indicated that he intends to add much more to it where it counts. It could be that too many of us are building another dream, but what else do we have available to us? The political card pack is there, and presently we cannot invent any new cards.

We are forced to work with what we have.

LIME, Lasco and good corporate citizens

AT this time of the year when some who have it all will be content to keep it all, there are many among us who will always be moved by the spirit of giving at Christmas.

Individuals will give to those who are in need, especially at this time. It comes with the tradition of Christmas, but with a Jamaican touch. A plate of food here, toys for the children there, and just generally lifting the body and the soul of someone in need.

I have mentioned LIME and Lasco in the title because over the years I have been following the leadership directions of both companies. Lascelles Chin of Lasco is one of the most complete corporate citizens I know.

He is compassionate, but absolutely no pushover in the boardroom. His corporate 'giving back' operates right throughout the year and I know that at this time his company is touching the lives of many.

A reader sent me a letter transmitted to the newspapers in which he suggested that numerous companies, including LIME have been assisting in numerous ways.

Said a part of the letter, 'LIME caught my attention when the company executed its back-to-school event in Portmore before the beginning of the school year assisting parents and youngsters from all over Jamaica. The company provided these students with school supplies and even got the help of other organisations to conduct free immunisations, eye examinations and dental care at the event. After this very notable act of philanthropy, the company later opened a community park in Portmore, a facility set up to uplift the spirits of the people of the area.

'In its latest outreach programmes, the company has been extending helping hands and joyful cheer to the disabled. In November the company brought gifts to the Enos Barrett Resource Centre for Persons with Multiple Disabilities along with Christmas cheer. LIME donated to the resource centre a computer, a bookshelf filled with reading material and a year's supply of cooking gas. I can also recall reading in the newspaper that the Edgehill School of Special Education in Port Maria was a part of its Christmas of a Lifetime Moment project. A kind donation of a refrigerator, standing fans and a computer was made to the learning facility, which caters to almost 50 children with learning disabilities.

'The company and staff members must be commended for these heart-warming charities. LIME, in my opinion, has been setting an admirable pace for other well-supported companies in Jamaica and I hope they will continue doing so.'

It was also suggested that Supreme Ventures, Jamaica National (I am always getting its newsletters), Red Stripe and Pepsi Cola are companies that 'don't wait for a special occasion' to do good.

I know that a company like Carreras, though under pressure from the strong anti-smoking lobby that has rightfully recognised the dangers of smoking, especially in public spaces, has done well in its scholarship outreach programme. I even sat in on one such scholarship committee.

Other companies are encouraged to do more and I have no problem in mentioning such outreach programmes in this column.

68% say yes to fixed election dates
A position advocated by former Prime Minister Bruce Golding for fixed election dates has found favour with just under 70 per cent of Jamaicans interviewed by pollster Don Anderson. The poll, conduc ... more
Is the JLP's political algorithm flawed?
Politics is certainly a dynamic sport and politicians cannot take anything for granted, lest they become so inebriated by the feeling of invincibility that they overlook the need to course-correct t ... more
Labourites, Comrades hug it out in Denham Town
JAMAICA Labour Party (JLP) supporters and a handful of People's National Party (PNP) supporters are now mingling at the gates of the Denham Town High School. The PNP's candidate Earl Dawkins was acc ... more
Why they won't vote
ONE University of the West Indies lecturer is predicting a voter turnout of between 71 and 76 per cent come election day Thursday. Anthropologist Dr Herbert Gayle says his survey team has produ ... more
Tent-pitching fuss, big turnout of the elderly mark voting in St Thomas
ADDITIONAL police had to be called out at the White Horses Basic School in West St Thomas yesterday morning to quell a fracas between supporters of the two major political parties, following a repor ... more
Hot sun, slow technology fail to deter voters in E St Andrew
THE huge deployment of members of the Jamaica Defence Force Coast Guard seemed at odds with the slow trickle of voters into Port Royal Primary School in the constituency of Eastern Kingston and Po ... more
All systems go for voting by election workers, police and soldiers
THE Electoral Office of Jamaica says all systems are in place for some 35,705 electors — election day workers, the police and military personnel — to cast their votes this Thursday, De ... more
Allow Jamaicans living overseas to vote
Dear Editor, I would like to congratulate the Hon Portia L Simpson Miller, prime minister-designate and president of the People's National Party (PNP) on her resounding victory at the polls. I bel ... more
Electronic Voter ID system causes delays in Eastern St Andrew, but...
PELTING sun notwithstanding, orange-clad voters congregated at the open lot at the entrance to Jarret Lane in the Eastern St Andrew constituency, waiting to dip their fingers in the voters' ink. "I ... more
PNP: Remove Nelson from Cabinet
GENERAL Secretary of the People’s National Party (PNP) Peter Bunting is demanding the removal of National Security Minister Dwight Nelson from the Holness Cabinet. The Opposition’s cal ... more


You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.



1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed:

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email:

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.

Comment (required):

You have characters left.
captcha 45d3c49852bf42419f68d9a4a88282fe
Enter text seen above:

For information about privacy please read our Privacy Policy.

I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions


diehardr sickheads
12/23/2011 - 9:37 AM
weslie is there any stench in the pnp i guess you wont smell any diehead
Weslie Daley
12/21/2011 - 2:51 PM
Hi Mark, is there any good quality in PORTIA? Has she shown any sign of maturity? Now that the debate is past, what is your objective view of her? I know she will never be a Manley, a P.J. Patterson. But certainly, if one can rise from the ghetto to be PM of this country, there must be something to admire in her. Please cut her some slack!

By the way, how can you smell the lingering fragrance coming from the PNP and ignore the obnoxious stench coming from the JLP?

Devon T
12/19/2011 - 7:37 AM
Three bloggers takes up the entire forum and they have nothing constructive to say. Thery have selective hearing, seeing, smelling, tasting, feeling...I am not a Portia hater and i am not one who thinks Mark (wignall) hates portia. I think he is (like me) unconfortable with her LACK OF LEADERSHIP when it matters just like he did seaga.
Robert Ranger
12/18/2011 - 9:27 PM
Three bloggers take up the whole forum wow.......
12/18/2011 - 7:37 PM
Portia Simpson Miller is a very outstanding Jamaican woman who has dedicated her life to public service, and every Jamaican regardless of their political preference should be very proud that we possess a giant of a woman, with such great leadership qualities.
Dan cee
12/18/2011 - 6:11 PM
I have become very selective with whom I tend to read,there is just too much to read and too little time.I must say this, however, Mark Wignall's articles are a must read for me and many of my friends here in the U.S. There are two main reasons for this, Mark is a prolific writer and more importantly Mr. Wignall is highly credible and objective , character traits that are lacking in academia,politics, even national justice.
Meat Head
12/18/2011 - 2:19 PM
Most would measure a leader primarily by their effectiveness at improving our economic condition. Intellect, command of the issues, honesty, etc., are all necessary, but obviously not sufficient. By an effectiveness standard, our country has failed so far at leadership, even when the necessary conditions were present. When the necessary conditions are lacking, as you suggest, it is a tautology that effectiveness cannot be achieved.
Mark Forbes
12/18/2011 - 2:15 PM
Well, blow me down @real southy, why did we get rid of Seaga! He went to 'Hahvaad', didn't he? Also, if schools attended is so important shouldn't we be saying PM Tufton instead?
British Deportee
12/18/2011 - 1:44 PM
Instead of worrying about who has inferior IQ, Wignall should put more emphasis on securing sufficient supply of alka-seltzer for December 30, 2011 & thereafter. Portia cannot be stopped now; for almost four decades, she had relentlessly toiled the soil and her day of redemption has been expedited by young and naive, Andrew Holness. Brace yourselves, labourites! Oh, one more thing, where is customary smooth flow that Mark's articles are famous for? One love!
Mark Forbes
12/18/2011 - 1:41 PM
@pwilson, you be the judge. He is here saying that Holness makes decisions by himself in contrast to Portia who depends on PNP 'gurus'. This, despite the fact that Holness himself said that it was at a meeting of JLP gurus that a decision was made for Henry to resign.
You really believe that Wignall of Stone Poll fame is not aware of the one-term danger that caused the JLP to call a snap election in 1983, ten years earlier than what he is claiming here?
I could go on from just this column alone
Vivian Brown
12/18/2011 - 1:39 PM
Almost everyday I have heard and read so called experts and university graduates talking nonsense , flavored with a whole lot of generalizations. Mr. Holness is a graduate from a well recognized university, and yet he came on the political platform with so much inaccurate information, that he had to apologize for those same inaccuracies. If he was so smart and highly educated as most seem to claim. Why did he not check his facts first?
Mark Forbes
12/18/2011 - 1:19 PM
@RGray, thank you. Thank you very much. Wignall is shameless and his shredding his credibility among those who aren't JLP die-hards. The 'Portia Haters' are a bunch of self-hating, classist idiots who are wilfully blind to anything that is complimentary to her. What they try to blow up into major flaws are merely residual indications of the many obstacles she has had to overcome to reach this far. If Golding had an ounce of her strength he wouldn't have had to resign in disgrace.
real southy
12/18/2011 - 1:06 PM
@Robert one rates a degree from Union Institute and University in Maimi,U.S.A.
Stephen Fox
12/18/2011 - 12:50 PM
Mark, there is nothing wrong with taking advise from your experts or decision making by consensus. Maybe if Michael Manley were not so quick to take the bull by the horns he would not have made so many mistakes. Maybe if Edward Seaga were not so dictatorial the JLP might have won a majority in the 90s. Do not castigate Portia for attempting to distribute responibility. No one knows everything not even Andrew Holness. We may prefer Andrew but Portia has earned due respect.
Dan smith
12/18/2011 - 12:10 PM
Mark who really sit in a classroom and listen to you, You hate the opposition leader so much that you tell so much on her long live PORTIA our next PM long live PORTIA Mark is not everybody is a fool.
Robert Gray
12/18/2011 - 11:48 AM
At Paul Wilson. The writer of the article said she has not developed herself for leadership since 1976. Is that fact or fiction? Check the JIS archives for information on her academic/intellect/leadership achievement. I am not saying she is perfect (sometimes comes across as being too aggressive or pushy) but the lies and deceptions has to stop. A united Jamaica is what we need and constitutional change !
Paul Gentles
12/18/2011 - 11:25 AM
Our biggest problem is not one of "intelligence" but honesty.
As PM it's unquestionable that Portia is out of her depths, that said - this govt has proven to be the most corrupt and placed the Jcan population at the gravest danger just to support no less that a noted gun-runner. How can we support a govt that puts it's own citizens at danger? AH does not represent anything that is new and different, how can we support them?
12/18/2011 - 11:23 AM
The magnitude of the Trafigura deception is what makes it such an enormous political failure. The trust factor was wiped out and 5 years later, the truth is still to be told. No amount of perfume can mask the whiff of deception.
paul wilson
12/18/2011 - 11:04 AM
@Robert Gray is it all lies Mark is telling? I think Portia was indecisive during her time at the helm she got the chance to take action more than once and was absent, just remember her ask the PNP comment
Robert Gray
12/18/2011 - 10:00 AM
May the best person/persons in Jamaica form the next government . The country is in a crisis and we need a united effort to solve the problems. We just need to stop telling lies. Here in the U.S.A., the "birthers" don't believe that President Obama was born here even after he had produced his birth certificate. In Jamaica, the "Portia Haters" don't believe Mrs.Simpson Miller has a Bachelor's degree or even an honourary Doctorate or even certificates of management. GOD HELP THEM !
Robert Gray
12/18/2011 - 9:52 AM
Who gave that speech to the International Labour Organization meeting representing Jamaica as minister of labour and got a standing ovation? Who was voted by the respectable and world renown Forbes magazine as one of the world's most powerful women? Who received that award for most important women involved in sports leadership? Who got an honourary Doctorate degree(PHD) from her university and was the keynote speaker at a graduation at said university? The answer is Portia Simpson Miller!
Robert Gray
12/18/2011 - 9:43 AM
I was living in The U.S.A when the horrible 9/11 incident happened. Who was minister of tourism at that time? Portia Simpson Miller was. She handled the fallout very well. When the planes began to fly again she lead with effective leadership to get the industry stable again. She did not do it all by her self. She had to delegate competent people to do the job. That is the mark of an effective leader. I think some people dislike her because she is from the wrong class,skin tone and gender.
Robert Gray
12/18/2011 - 9:37 AM
What is effective leadership? Someone who abstained from a vote and not voted with her party because she has a conscience? As minister of Labour ,Welfare and Sports, there was relatively calm in the labour industry via the partnership;The Reggae Boyz got tremendous support from public and private organizations; the national indoor sports arena was built and The world netball championship was brought to jamaica; the Cricket world cup was staged in Jamaica -infrastructure was develop.
Robert Gray
12/18/2011 - 9:29 AM
My first ever vote was for the JLP (Kingsley Sangster in South East St.Catherine (Portmore). In addition, I have family members and friends who are pro-JLP. With that being said, ever since casting that vote in which The JLP lost and have never won Portmore again, I have stopped voting for party. Instead I vote for the candidate who has the better vision. Portmore has the largest concentration of university graduates in the caribbean. That means as university graduates, we vote wisely!
Robert Gray
12/18/2011 - 9:21 AM
Mark you are very intellectually dishonest or just blinded by your hatred for the Opposition leader. What has this woman done to you? You said she has not developed herself since 1976. That is a big fat lie! You need KD Knight to describe you? If you are honest, it is public knowledge that she has a Bachelor's degree from the Union Institute and University in Miami,U.S.A. In addition, she also has several management/leadership certificates from schools like Berkley.
Paul Gentles
12/18/2011 - 9:13 AM
The magnitude of the sums involved with JDIP and now this bus loan..Trafigura pales in comparison and Jcans will not have to pay for Trafigura unlike JDIP and bus loans which never went through the scrutiny/oversight of parliament. It's instructional that all we hear is many serious scandals have this govt had in it's short history? I think this govt is the most arrogant ,deceptive and anti-Jcan, ever!