|

News

Doctors lament absence of CT scan machines at public hospitals

Observer Monday Exchange

BY NADINE WILSON Observer staff reporter wilsonn@jamaicaobserver.com

Tuesday, November 16, 2010



MEMBERS of the Jamaica Medical Doctors Association (JMDA) yesterday bemoaned the absence of functioning Computed Tornography (CT) multi-detector imaging machines in the nation's public hospitals which, they insist, is central to the saving of lives.

President of the JMDA Dr Shane Alexis expressed his desire to see the situation resolved, while making a presentation on health care reform to reporters and editors at the weekly Observer Monday Exchange at the newspaper's Beechwood Avenue head office.

"There are no functioning CT scans in any public hospital in Jamaica today," he said.

His statement comes more than three months after the Observer reported that none of the island's top three public hospitals — Kingston Public Hospital and the University Hospital of the West Indies (UHWI), both in Kingston, and the Cornwall Regional Hospital in St James — were in possession of a functioning CT scan machine.

As a result of the absence of functional CT scans in the public sector, public relations officer for the JMDA Dr Tahira Redwood said patients had to be referred to private health care facilities for examination.

"Because of the lack of maintenance (and) because we don't have the funds to maintain the CT scan, we have to send them somewhere private to get the CT scan that they need," she said.

The South East Regional Health Authority (SERHA) has said the referring public hospitals were responsible for footing the bill for the more seriously ill patients who have to go to the private health facilities to get a scan done.

But secretary for the JMDA, Dr Twesige Mugisa-Malcolm, said sending a patient to do a CT scan elsewhere is not a feasible solution to the current situation.

"There are some instances where there is an immediate need and you cannot be transported from one facility to another, and whatever has to happen has to happen right there (at the hospital)," she said.

Second vice-president for the JMDA, Dr Dane Miller, said the absence of CT scan machines has placed further stress on medical practitioners who are already being forced to improvise due to the lack of essential equipment in the island's hospitals.

"We are in a service where CT scan is essential to what is done, and right now at the University [Hospital], it has been expressed and it is a fear of mine, that the MRI machine that is there is going to come under more pressure because we have nothing else to use," he said.

The cost of repairing a CT scan machine at the UHWI could amount to $2.4 million, while it would cost $1.5 million and $1.6 million at KPH and Cornwall Regional Hospital respectively. KPH alone received between 400 and 450 referrals for CT scans prior to the breakdown of the machine in March of this year.

Dr Alexis said instead of giving excuses for the breakdown of the machines, the Government needs to be unveiling some additional machines to take health care in the island to another level.

"You can't explain parts to the family of a patient who had just died, you cannot explain parts to a patient who may have some metastasis — either a spread of a cancer to their brain or any other part of their body — because you are guessing because you don't know," he said.



POST A COMMENT


You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.

HOUSE RULES

 

1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.



Comment (required):

You have characters left.
captcha 824ea12a9d3f430dbb221a05d1eb4a0f
Enter text seen above:

For information about privacy please read our Privacy Policy.

I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions


COMMENTS (8)

Antonette W.
11/16/2010
There are always so many missed opportunities. Not only is it crucial to obtain these machines, it is critical and insightful for the government to ensure that technicians are trained to operate or service them, thereby solving several problems simultaneously. It's utterly ridiculous to bring technicians from abroad when the unemployment rate is so high in JA. The same applies to coroners/medical examiners. Why not train more Jamaicans for this, or are Jamaicans thought not to be capable?
Occams Razor
11/16/2010
Interesting comment Jody....
Too bad it makes no sense as the ct scan machines are owned and operated by doctors who benefit from the lack of machines In the public sector. So it would be kind of counterproductive of them.
The next time your relative has a stroke and needs a ct to determine which medicine to give to even start treating it you will understand as you wait one or two days to get transported for ct scan for free. During that time you will no doubt praise the system of freeness.
Brer Rabbit
11/16/2010
@jody hyde.....the doctors are not saying abolish free health care, they are simply saying that we do not have the infrastructure or finances to do so.........i have been to hospitals with a love one only to be told that the machine for the test is malfunctioning and the drugs that the patient needs are not there, free health with no equipment and no drugs to administer only gives us a false sense of hope....free health to those in need let those who can pay, pay what they can
Shorna Watson
11/16/2010
The doctors are asking for functional technologies to work with in the hospitals that is critical for life saving. Currently they are unable to make informed decisions regarding patients' ailment because all advance X-ray machines are broken, this is not too much to ask for, as a professional myself, I know how essential these equipements are and cannot begin to fathom the absence of such.This is how taxpayers money should be utilized,while free healthcare is good think about the quality.
Nicolas Henry
11/16/2010
The observer reports all stated that technicians will be sourced from overseas to repair the CT machines. We bought machines for millions and we did not require the supplier to train JA technicians to repair the machines if they should break. What is going to become of us? The leaders dem seem to be frighten or fool fool. Who maintain the CT scanners operating in the private sector? Could it be that government equipment is being sabotaged, to steer the sick to the private scanners?
Nicolas Henry
11/16/2010
The 'free health" would work, if it wasn't for scarce resources being diverted to treat victims of brutal merciless marauding gunmen. Many of the bullets are being fired by men from the "poor communities'. Aren't they the ones helping themselves to remain poor,
by bringing many kids into a poor miserable life. What's the point of using expensive CT scanners to make diagnosis, when we most likely, don't have the ability to treat the diagnosed therapeutically or surgically in JA health care sytem
mark jones
11/16/2010
Jody firstly there is no such thing as free health care it still costs the Government and by extension taxpayers on a whole collectively.....Secondly if the gvt cant afford to maintain it what is the point?? the quality of health care suffers and yes real people with real lives can end up dying as a result....If the Gvt is promoting free health care fine but just make sure it can be funded properly..No working CT scan machines in any Gvt hospitals?? come on!!
jody hyde
11/16/2010
Get rid of free health care so that the poor will suffer more and you the doctors will make more money in private practice. That is exactly what you guys are saying. Doctors may not see the importance of free health care but the poor does. So, when you are calling for an end to some like this, please remember the poor and vulnerable among you.

Jamaica can't afford a stimulus budget — Phillips

  7 comments

 

23.4b Tax grab - Gov't targets extra revenue

  7 comments

 

Canada pumps $62m into Ja’s polygraph programme

  0 comments

 

Experts say budget fair

  7 comments

 

Vendor says GCT reduction not enough

  0 comments

 

Tax measures the death knell for tourism — Cummings

  5 comments

 

Teen killed for laughing at man who fell from bicycle 

  0 comments

 

Shaw says taxes will hit small businesses

  2 comments

 

Tax measures pose tougher environment for businesses

  0 comments

 

CDA: We are working on implementing places of safety recommendations

  0 comments

 

Suitcase death accused couple remanded again

  0 comments

 

PEPPER POT: The strangest bedfellows

  0 comments

 

KPH staff do free Labour Day surgeries

  0 comments

 

KC May Fair back with a bang

  0 comments

 

Man gets 30 days for oral sex beating

  0 comments

 

Air passengers willing to pay US$10 enviro tax, study says

  0 comments

 

VIDEO: 'Busy Signal' waives right to extradition hearing

  0 comments

 

Work time

  0 comments

 

Emergency work disrupts water supply in St Ann

  0 comments

 

Water woes for St Andrew and St Catherine

  0 comments

 

Today's Cartoon


Poll

 Do you feel buying into Facebook now is a good investment for the long-run? 
Yes
No

View Results

Results published weekly in Sunday Finance


Username:
Password: