Emergency work disrupts water supply in St Ann 2:41 PM
Water woes for St Andrew and St Catherine 2:32 PM
Samuels century leads Windies fightback 1:18 PM
Bolt clocks pedestrian time to win Ostrava 100m 1:03 PM
Churches raising money to fight gay marriage 12:20 PM
Escaped prisoner back in custody 12:06 PM
News
Lobster poachers rob Ja of US$132m
Thursday, June 02, 2011
POACHERS have robbed Jamaica of more than US$130 million in lobster meat over the past five years, according to Agriculture Minister Dr Christopher Tufton who, in addition to assuring his regional counterparts that Jamaica will fully enforce its Fisheries Act, has encouraged them to find a regional solution to the problem of illegal fishing threatening all Caricom states.
"Jamaica produces approximately 400 metric tons (MT) of lobsters per year," Tufton told the fourth Caribbean Regional Fisheries Mechanism ministerial council meeting in Antigua recently.
"Approximately one-third of the country's production is exported and the local lobster industry makes about US$8 million per year. A conservative estimate is that poachers take at least twice as much lobster as the country does, and at an average price of US$15 per pound; Jamaica has lost approximately US$132.3 million over the past five years," Tufton said in his discussion paper on 'Illegal, Unreported and Unregulated (IUU) Fishing and Border Security Issues in Jamaican Waters'.
He said the Jamaican queen conch faced a similar situation where losses due to poaching were at one time estimated as being over 400 MT.
However, since 2009, due to the intervention of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES), poaching for conch has reduced significantly, albeit it still remains an issue, Tufton said.
He highlighted recent incidents of illegal fishing in Jamaican waters, saying that over the past year the Jamaica Defence Force Coast Guard reported 42 sightings of multiple vessels poaching on the Pedro Bank, but was only able to apprehend three boats.
Two of the vessels seized towards the end of last year contained approximately 6,680 lbs of lobster meat and 4,740 lbs of lobster head meat, he said.
Tufton also pointed to the January 7, 2011 incident in which a Honduran vessel was found fishing illegally in Jamaican waters and which resulted in the injuring of two Honduran fishermen in an encounter with the Coast Guard.
The minister then told of an incident that, he said, caused Jamaica great concern -- the poaching of sharks.
"On May 8, 2011, the JDF Coast Guard intercepted a vessel of Nicaraguan registration fishing illegally on the North West Ridge of the Pedro Banks, well within Jamaica's archipelagic boundaries," he said. "This in and of itself is disturbing, however, what is of greater concern to Jamaica is the fact that this vessel was fishing for sharks. Jamaica has videographic and photographic evidence of this activity. Eighty-six sharks weighing approximately 2,000 pounds were seized."
These activities, he said, reflect the grave concern Jamaica has for IUU fishing and bring into focus other transnational issues as they relate to criminal activities and border security matters.
"Our intelligence reflects that there is a thriving business in the guns for drugs trade by virtue of using the fishing industry as a guise to carry on these illegal activities," Tufton said.
Lamenting the paltry fines imposed on poachers when they are caught, Tufton said that the US$11.60 charged for fishing without a licence and US$2.33 for operating an unregistered vessel do not act as a deterrent unless the vessel is forfeited by the courts.
In an effort to effectively combat illegal fishing, he recommended the harmonisation of legislation across the region, including the synchronisation of closed seasons for lobsters and conch.
"There is no simple, single or short-term solution to IUU fishing as it is not just an issue for the fisheries sector," Tufton said. "Successful responses will require holistic and integrated policies linked to the drivers for IUU fishing. Success will require independent action by states, bilateral action, particularly by adjacent states, and multilateral action. It will involve greater commitment to and implementation of internationally recognised benchmarks for fisheries management and Monitoring, Control and Surveillance arrangements."
POST A COMMENT
You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.
HOUSE RULES
1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.
2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.
6/3/2011
Mr. Tuftun its one thing to identify the problem the next is to fix it. these poachers know the laws in Jamaica are a joke thats why they steal or marine life. In Cayman for committing such an offence the max fine is $500,000 CI & in Barbados its $5000 in addition to your vessell might also be seized and forfieted to the state, & they are other Countries with similar laws. Then why cant we come in to the 21st century and construct laws that are not only a deterent but have some teeth.
6/2/2011
am i seeing right..its only &2.33 us..they charge them for poaching..you people are a joke..for 5 years now and only close to election you seem to care..if thats what you people charge them to poach,you lucky they dont have whole countries fishing in jamaica waters..in luasianna ,usa..poaching cost poachers their lives..thats how people who are serious bout they economy operate..plus what ever happen to the crooked jamaica politicians,who were selling fishing rights to others..no penalty ha..
6/2/2011
Were we making money from Lobsters?. We've now heard of so many millions of dollars lost, but not how much we've earned in the past. Marine officers have managed to combat drug peddlers, why not poachers? We just cannot manage to protect and implement effective laws. We cannot control criminals in land, how are we going control illegal fishing in our waters effectively? we do not have the resources to do so.
6/2/2011
Thanks Minister Tufton; we knew about these activities for many years, but the distraction of politics, crime and business development issues pull our attention to areas of miss-prioritizing our efforts and responsibility. On other matters. I believe now is the right time for the Bruce Golding government to initiate the proces of 'persona non-grata,' to the current US Ambassador in regards to the Mining Minister's disruption of his duties by his visa decline. Jamaica now has a ligitimate reason
6/2/2011
@ DT the minister must share some of the blame "his" government is in power almost 5 years and he and the government did nothing to change the colonial laws because past and present governments love the colonial mentality so he is just crying crocodile tears.
6/2/2011
Before we jump all over the minister let us try to understand something. Most of the laws in Ja was written in the colonial days they have been ammended a bit but not enough. The politicians who can change the law will catch hell from their friends who own some of these large boats. Lets forgets about the govt for a change, it is full time for the Ja people to stand for Ja, if we dont then the worst is yet to come
6/2/2011
Nothing new here, poaching in Jamaican waters has been going on for over 40 plus yrs .If they are really serious in curbing this activity have stiffer fines and penalties with seizure of the vessel included. Also Jamaica needs to patrol its econ zone with at least 2 aircraft several times a week. Yes I know we are going to cry poor but it has to be done.
6/2/2011
Fall Out: The revolution has started to ensure government and public official are held accountability, display honesty and integrity. This news paper will be left I the lurch. So far they have not catch on to the new reality, and it’s a shame they are still working in the past aligning with a political party instead of the citizenry.
6/2/2011
@ Tufton a mus be a joke yuh a mek when you said "US$11.60 charged for fishing without a licence and US$2.33 for operating an unregistered vessel"
The government should be ashame but they have no shame all and everything in Jamaica are up for sale and give away by the government the lobsters and conch just add to the list. come one come all if you want a peice of Jamaica it is free.
6/2/2011
Without proper enforcement tools, planes and boats along with strong fines all you will ever do is talk.....you are the government so why are you not trying to remedy the situation by first passing stronger laws...
6/2/2011
It would appear that Mr Tufton is for a Caricom approach in solving problems of the region. Is this a sign of some independent thinking in this Admin ?. The Lackey mentality in this Admin is astonishing, even from people like Holness and Tufton who has done a relatively good job in their portfolios.
6/2/2011
Dr Tufton:” Jamaica will fully enforce its Fisheries Act”. Well Dr., enforcement of the fisheries act must start at home. Fishermen and hotelier are blatantly violating the law. Simple, fines under the fisheries act makes no sense. How can $500.00 be enough punishment under the law? We need laws with stiff penalty to punish and serve under the deterrent to others. We also need fish warden on our beaches to inspect fishermen catch on their return to shore.
6/2/2011
Lobster poachers rob Ja. of US$132m, money running out on Palisadoes rehabilitation proect, Diaspora conference in danger of not convening, Nurses locked in meeting with govt. over non-payment of increases, senior custom and police officers fail lie detector tests. But we have a cartoon trying to denigrate the PNP over something which is not immediately obvious.
Does anyone beside me detect some sort of bias here
or is the cartoon reflecting the most important thing that happened this week
6/2/2011
I went on to marry a young Jamaican lady after she cooked me the nicest conch soup ever, I love it and lobster is my favorite seafood. It so distressing to know that we can't get enough of our Jamaican seafood abroad especially in the UK and the prices are sky high when you do. I tried buying some conch and was told in London I have to buy the whole box for huge amount of monies. We must get rid of poachers and let our fishermen and Jamaicans reap the benefits of our seas not tiefing foriegners
Other Stories
Pension reforms to be implemented this year
0 comments
‘Tourism worries’ - Opposition, JHTA seek meeting with minister
0 comments
Special constable accused of corruption
0 comments
Broadcaster Wayne Whyte returns to court July 3
0 comments
$2-m bail for businessman implicated in lottery scam
0 comments
0 comments
0 comments
0 comments
0 comments
Mexican boy's eyes gouged out 'to save the world'
0 comments
UN chief cites unacceptable violence in Syria
0 comments
Jamaica can't afford a stimulus budget — Phillips
7 comments
23.4b Tax grab - Gov't targets extra revenue
7 comments
Canada pumps $62m into Ja’s polygraph programme
0 comments
7 comments
Vendor says GCT reduction not enough
0 comments
Tax measures the death knell for tourism — Cummings
5 comments
Teen killed for laughing at man who fell from bicycle
0 comments
Shaw says taxes will hit small businesses
2 comments
Tax measures pose tougher environment for businesses
0 comments





