Sports
'Minimum' penalty!
BY HG HELPS Editor-at-Large
Friday, August 20, 2010
A Jamaica disciplinary hearing has recommended a minimum form of punishment for World and Olympic 100-metre champion Shelly-Ann Fraser, the Observer has been reliably informed.
Fraser, who tested positive for the banned substance Oxycodone after competing at the Diamond League athletic meet in Shanghai, China on May 23, has effectively ended her 2010 season, as with only one Diamond League meet remaining, and the Review Board of the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) yet to ratify or broaden the punishment recommended, she will not race again for this year.
The recommendation by the three-member local panel comprising retired head of the judiciary, former chief justice Lensley Wolfe, lawyer and former minister of national security and justice and ex-attorney general Winston Spaulding, and consultant psychiatrist Aggrey Irons, is for a "minimum punishment".
"A decision will be handed down soon," a source connected to the IAAF told the Observer on condition of anonymity, when this tabloid sought to find out the delay in making public, a decision on the fate of the multi-talented sprinter.
"The Jamaican Disciplinary Committee recommended a form of punishment, which is well below the maximum two-year ban that can be imposed by the IAAF.
"I cannot say what the punishment is, but it is much less than two years. Of course, the IAAF has the right not to accept that recommendation. This is an offence that
can attract a punishment anywhere from a public warning to a two-year ban," the IAAF source said.
Fraser was sanctioned after her urine samples reflected traces of the drug said to be used in the treatment of moderate and severe pain.
It has been on the World Anti-Doping Agency's list of banned substances for 2010, as a narcotic, and is not regarded as a performance-enhancer, nor masking agent.
Fraser's management team has already stated publicly that the much-loved and admired sprinter erred by not informing meet organisers that she had taken the drug to ease pain caused by a toothache, before she competed at the China meet.
However, Fraser is not the only one who will likely feel the heat. Her coach, Stephen Francis, could be sanctioned as well, the IAAF source said.
"The real problem is how she came by it and her coach will have to answer some questions," the source said.
Apart from Fraser's misdemeanor, the Maximising Velocity Power (MVP) Track Club of which she is a member has maintained a clean record of drug testing over the years.
The club parades some of Jamaica's finest athletes, including one-time world's fastest man Asafa Powell, sprinter Michael Frater and 400-metre hurdler Melaine Walker.
High-ranking officials of the JAAA could not be reached for comment last night to comment on the latest developments.
A decision had been expected from the IAAF from July after the local committee met, but the failure of the five-man Review Board to meet has left the final decision in limbo.
The Review Board, which includes the IAAF president, Senegalese Lamine Diack and general secretary, has already seen the recommendation, but sent back correspondence to the JAAA for more information on the circumstances of the case.
The IAAF reserves the right to hand down its own punishment in respect of high profile or 'elite' athletes like Fraser.
While the local association can recommend punishment for such athletes, the IAAF is usually mindful that favouritism could set in on the part of the local body in handing down lighter sentences than fit the charges.
"The mere fact that the IAAF is deliberating, means that the recommendation from the local panel is for a reduction in the maximum sentence," the source said. "If the local association had recommended a two-year suspension, it would have been ratified long ago," the source added.
It is likely that the IAAF Review Board will meet at the end of the Junior Olympic Games being held in Singapore.
Fraser has not competed since she withdrew from the IAAF Diamond League Meeting in Lausanne, Switzerland on July 8, following reports that she had tested positive for the prohibited substance in China. Her decision not to run at the Lausanne meet was influenced by a directive from the IAAF, the Observer understands, and is in contrast to claims made by her MVP club that it was the organisation that decided that she should not run at the same meet.
POST A COMMENT
You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.
HOUSE RULES
1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.
2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.
8/21/2010
Question: Why is it that a NON PERFORMANCE ENHANCING DRUG is on the IAAF's BANNED LIST? I have been trying to get some level of understanding from that......
8/20/2010
I feel there is no need for a heavy handed disciplinary action against Ms. Frazer.She was in pain, and still wanted to compete. Yes, she made a mistake by not disclosing a ''non-performance'', ''non-masking'' drug. There is too much noise over nothing of consequence.
8/20/2010
Ignorance is not a defence. If you did not know you should have known. Not after what happened to Yohan Blake and company.
You are earning tens of hundreds of dollars from your profession. You need to hire a nutritionist who is versed on the do's and don'ts. Stop being so cheap and start being professional.
8/20/2010
Mr Writer, you have already EXHIBITING !BIAS! on your PART including the ANTI-MVP-ITES.
She and her COACH has no resonable REASON to answer to anyone, than the SELECTED ATHLETICS BOARD that they have already ANSWERED to.
Now did you? are any other SPORT WRITER from this News Paper, or another Local news paper SUGGESTED that the ATHLETES of RACERS TRACK Club whom were INVOLVED in a DOPE SCANDAL, and their COACH, Glenn Mills should have answered QUESTIONS of such actions. Leave FRNACIS alone;
8/20/2010
I just believe that ShellyAnn should just be admonished and allowed to pursue her career. No one in their right mind would never consider ShellyAnn a cheat on the basis of this incident.. naively stu... maybe.
8/20/2010
There are reasons why we have a code of conduct, or a code of ethics. Those who advise, or represents us must abide by the rules, or be held accountable.
8/20/2010
I thought this was much ado about nothing. However, in reading the story I noticed that the writer decided to name a few of the athletes who represent MVP. My question is, which team do Bridgette Foster-Hylton, Sherone Simpson, et. al. represent? We must be careful that we do not diss by omission.
8/20/2010
If this don't humble Frano nothing else will. If it doesn't that I would suggest the "elite" athletes who do themselves a favor by finding another club. Stuff happening for a reason but it depends on how we look at it. I have noticed his silence throughout this scenario (which is commendable) - better to keep your mouth close.......
8/20/2010
Good decision. No need to overthink the situation. Shelly-Ann's use of Oxycodone was clearly not to enhance her performance.
A clear message still has to be sent however to others who might consider doing likewise in the future. I suggest the disciplinary committee ask Shelly-Ann and MVP to forfeit any appearance money they got at the event. The money was probably the motive for using Oxcodone in the first place, so as to ensure Shelly-Ann could compete.
Other Stories
Mathurin chokes Ja - His five-for restricts hosts to 180
0 comments
Asafa to receive Chancellor's Medal at gala dinner tonight
0 comments
Johnson, Deonarine steady Guyana against Leewards
0 comments
Ardenne claim U-16 crown, as Hydel, STATHS face game 3
0 comments
What price of victory in high school sports?
0 comments
LIME gives $250,000 for 2012 Karl Dalhouse swim meet
0 comments
Jamaican football needs more 'team spirit', says Mitchell
0 comments
0 comments
0 comments
Jamalco put FASTNET title on the line
0 comments
Top schools triumph in ISSA TT
0 comments
Paper airplanes competition comes to universities in Jamaica
0 comments
Jamalco regain lead in Clarendon Major League
0 comments
'Herbert' surprise Muschett in basketball final
0 comments
First Mystic Mountain Invitational meet runs off today
0 comments
Bullets pierce Ballers to take Game One
0 comments
'Legendary' trio to be honoured at track meets today
0 comments
Upfront ahead in LIME Division One
0 comments
Trench Town 5K road race, sports day
0 comments
Super League back on the ball after suspension
0 comments




