Why vulnerability should be a man’s greatest strength
WHEN the world goes sideways, and the power is out, the roof is leaking and the children are bored, everyone looks at the same person first: the man.
It’s practically muscle memory in society. Disaster strikes, and the collective gaze turns to the guy in the room. He’s supposed to stay calm, fix things, protect everyone, and definitely not, under any circumstances, panic.
Men are told to step up, but never to open up. But this ‘Movember’, as we continue the month-long campaign that highlights a host of men’s issues, including men’s mental health, let us cauterise these expectations.
From the moment boys can walk, they’re fed a steady diet of stoicism. We grow up believing our worth is measured by how much chaos we can shoulder without breaking a sweat. But here’s the thing, constantly playing the hero has a cost. You can only stuff so much stress, fear, and exhaustion into the emotional glove compartment before it bursts open.
Think about it. In a crisis, true leadership isn’t about being bulletproof, it’s about being real. The men who get others through disasters aren’t the ones pretending everything’s fine; they’re the ones who can say, “Yeah, this is tough, but we’ll figure it out”.
That’s not weakness, that’s connection, and connection is what keeps people alive physically, mentally and emotionally.
The irony is that vulnerability, the thing men are taught to suppress, is exactly what makes us more resilient. The ability to express fear, ask for help and admit uncertainty is the same mental flexibility that helps us adapt when the plan goes off-script (which it always does).
A firefighter who admits he’s scared before running into a burning building isn’t less brave, he’s just honest enough to acknowledge the high stakes. The soldier who talks about trauma doesn’t lose his edge; he sharpens it through understanding.
It’s time to rewrite the rule book about manning up. Manning up doesn’t mean shutting down, it means showing up fully. It’s about recognising that mental health isn’t a side quest, it’s a part of survival. The same grit that helps you push a car out of a gully should apply to pushing back against burnout or depression.
Opening up doesn’t make you less dependable in a disaster. It makes you more human, and humans are what people trust when everything’s falling apart.
Let’s stop pretending strength and sensitivity are opposites. They’re partners. The strongest men feel everything.
The man who can both fix the generator and admit he’s scared about losing his job is twice as strong as the one who buries it all under silence. Because anyone can lift a sandbag to create a dam during a storm, but it takes a real man to say, “I’m struggling and I still showed up”.
Jevaughnie Smith is a communications professional. Send feedback to allwoman@jamaicaobserver.com.
