What is the ‘R’ value of COVID-19 and should Jamaica be calculating it?
‘Flattening the curve’,
‘community spread’ and ‘herd immunity’ are all terms that we’ve become familiar
with due to the coronavirus pandemic.
You can now add ‘R’ value to
the ever-growing number of buzz words associated with the virus.
Like testing, the R value is
being touted as an important tool that countries can use to assess their level
of readiness, as it relates to the reopening of the economy.
What is an R Value?
The R value or
‘reproductive number’ is a way of rating a disease’s ability to
spread. The term, which is primarily used in epidemiology, is a model that
is used to determine the average number of people that one infected person will
pass the virus to.
The R value isn’t a fixed
number, so it can be affected by a range of factors including location.
The R value for the coronavirus
for example can vary from country to country, based on how densely populated
the area is.
Given that Sars-CoV-2 – the
proper name for the coronavirus– is a new pathogen scientist initially had to
calculate its R0, pronounced ‘R nought’.
The R nought value assumes that
a population is wholly susceptible at the beginning.
It further assumes that at the
time there would be no suppression measures, and it also assumes that there are
no individuals who are immune.
Early studies indicated that
China may have initially had a R value of between 2 and 2.5
What is an ideal R value?
Increasingly, we’ve all heard
countries like the UK and Germany make reference to an R value that is less
than 1.
An R value of more than 1
indicates the possibility of an outbreak or pandemic.
A R value greater than 1 can
mean a variety of things including a wave of new infections.
Given that R values are
calculated daily and may often vary, the objective is to have an R value of
below 1 for a sustained period of time, which could mean that the virus is on
the decline and eventually die out.
An R value of 0.75 means that
each sick person is transmitting the virus to less than one other person- this
is a positive indication that could be used to make decisions about the
reopening of the economy.
Is calculating an R value ideal
for small island states like Jamaica?
While the R value can be an
important piece of data that countries use to make decisions, the R value may
not be useful for smaller Caribbean states, like Jamaica.
According to a local
epidemiologist, the problem with calculating R values for smaller countries is
the inputs needed to calculate the number.
The epidemiologist told BUZZ that a country would need a
minimum of 60 new cases per day or a population of 3 to 5 million to get any
sensible values.
Similarly, Chief Medical Officer
for the Cayman Islands, Dr John Lee, said that because there are many different
ways of calculating the R value, but with much of the math rooted in
guesses, it may not be the most accurate measure.
“The R value also relates to
whole populations and as you are aware, we have had a number of different
clusters of cases and each of those clusters of cases will have its own
reproductive number; which is different from the R value of the whole
community. What people want is to know the R value for the whole
community,” said Lee.
“I am saying that these
clusters throw off the calculation and immediately lets you understand that
when you look at a small population where there is not a lot of infection going
on, it becomes a fairly meaningless figure,” added Lee.
The coronavirus has a median R
value of 5.7, according to a study published online in an online medical
journal.
Similarly, infectious diseases such as polio, smallpox and rubella have R
nought values in the 5 to 7 range.
According to the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention polio and smallpox are among the nine deadliest
viruses on earth.
Ebola which is widely considered
to be exceptionally contagious, has an R value of only 1.5 to 2.