Understanding aid and its distribution
Recently, Jamaica was hit by the devastating Category 5 Hurricane Melissa, which no one could have anticipated. Melissa’s destruction left western Jamaica’s breathtaking landscape completely unrecognisable, with entire communities destroyed, homes crushed to rubble, and a once-lush green environment transformed into a barren, defoliated wasteland of snapped and uprooted trees. Essential infrastructure has been severely damaged, with roads blocked by debris or washed away by heavy flooding and landslides, power grids entirely offline, and communication networks down, isolating many areas and making contact with loved ones almost impossible. The world saw our country in its most vulnerable state — exposed, stripped, parched, and roofless, with many buildings and our hotels destroyed.
This brought together many international leaders and organisations to help Jamaica. They provided aid in the form of monetary value. However, what does aid mean, and is it for the people or for the Government to manage on their behalf?
Aid is primarily focused on the welfare and development of a country’s people. Still, it is usually managed and distributed through various channels, including both government agencies and non-governmental organisations (NGOs).
Types of Aid and Their Beneficiaries
• Humanitarian/Emergency Aid: This type of aid is rapid assistance given to people in immediate distress (eg, victims of natural disasters or conflict). It is usually delivered by aid agencies and humanitarian organisations to directly alleviate suffering and save lives, often bypassing the Government to ensure quick and impartial distribution of food, water, medicine, and shelter.
• Development Aid: This aid is aimed at long-term objectives like alleviating poverty and promoting sustainable economic and social development. It funds projects such as infrastructure development, strengthening the health-care system, and improving education. The goal of development aid is to eventually enable countries to finance their own development and reduce reliance on external assistance.
Aid may be managed and distributed as follows:
• Through the Recipient Government: A significant portion of “Official Development Assistance” (ODA), which is government-to-government aid, is channeled through the recipient country’s national systems, sometimes directly into their national budget. The idea is that the Government manages these funds on behalf of its citizens, for investments in public services like infrastructure, education, and health care, or for general budget allocation support.
• Through International and NGOs: Donors frequently channel a significant portion of aid through multilateral institutions (such as the World Bank or UN agencies) or international and local NGOs. This approach is often chosen to ensure that aid reaches the intended beneficiaries, especially in cases of weak governance, concerns about corruption, or during immediate humanitarian crises where swift, impartial assistance is crucial.
• “In-Kind” Aid: A significant amount of aid is in-kind, meaning tangible goods and services (for example, food, medicine, building materials, technical expertise) are provided instead of cash transfers. These are often purchased from the donor country and shipped to the recipient nation for distribution, which also supports the donor’s own economy.
• Direct to People: In some innovative cases, aid is given as direct cash transfers to individuals in need, enabling them to make their own purchasing choices and supporting local markets.
Countries and Partners who have Pledged Aid through the Jamaican Government are as follows:
• United States: Pledged $24 million in aid for the Caribbean, including $12 million and an extra $10 million specifically for Jamaica, to support food, medical, and rebuilding efforts. The US also deployed military task forces with helicopters to assist with transporting and distributing supplies across the island and sent search-and-rescue experts and relief volunteers.
• United Kingdom: Pledged £7.5 million in emergency funding for the Caribbean’s urgent humanitarian needs, including over 3,000 shelter kits and 1,500 solar-powered lanterns for Jamaica.
• European Union (EU) & Member States: As “Team Europe,” the EU pooled its funding with member states’ resources. Specific contributions included:
o France: Provided shelter, water and sanitation items, and sent a warship with 40 tonnes of aid.
o Netherlands: Sent a vessel with substantial supplies, including power generators, a mobile hospital, medical staff, and connectivity equipment.
o Spain: Sent a medical team and supplies.
o Germany, Belgium, and Luxembourg: Provided various supplies, including shelter and energy items.
o The EU also announced €21.5 million in new humanitarian aid for the Caribbean region’s response to the hurricane.
• Caricom countries: All member nations, including Barbados and The Bahamas, reached out to pledge support.
o The Bahamas: Donated relief supplies (bottled water, tarpaulins, medical supplies) and pledged a monetary contribution of up to BSD2 million.
o Barbados: Sent two containers of supplies (tarpaulins, cots, generators) and 10,000 food kits.
• Canada: Announced CAD$7 million in aid for the affected Caribbean nations, to provide food, clean water, and medical aid.
• Cayman Islands: Provided initial support of US$200,000 in supplies and pledged an additional US$1.2 million in relief supplies.
• El Salvador: Sent three planes carrying humanitarian aid, including personnel, to assist with recovery efforts.
These types of aid to Jamaica indicate that a substantial amount of money has been allocated or pledged to provide humanitarian assistance following Hurricane Melissa. However, it is not a lump-sum discretionary cash payment given directly to the affected Government’s treasury. The various aid we have received is intended to fund specific, life-saving services and recovery efforts, which can include:
• Emergency supplies: Providing essentials like food kits, clean drinking water, hygiene and sanitary products, and temporary shelter items such as tarpaulins and mattresses.
• Health-care and medical support: Restoring health-care infrastructure, providing medical equipment and supplies, and supporting vaccination campaigns and nutrition programs, especially for vulnerable populations like children.
• Infrastructure recovery: Helping with housing rebuilding and restoring vital utilities such as water, electricity, and telecommunications.
• Economic support: Providing grants to assist individuals and small businesses affected by the disaster in recovering their livelihoods.
• Operational costs: Covering the logistical expenses of aid organisations working on the ground to ensure safe and effective delivery of assistance to where it is needed most.
Venice Williams, Partner of Lewis, Smith, Williams & Co. E-mail: vwilliams@lswlegal.com