All Woman
  • Home
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
    • Home
    • Relationships
    • Features
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Health & Fitness
    • Your Rights
    • Parenting
    • Advice
I met my true love while engaged to another woman
All Woman, All Woman Front Page, Relationships
 on October 21, 2024

I met my true love while engaged to another woman

CHRIS BRODBER 

Counsellor,

I proposed to my fiancée last year on Valentine’s Day, and we are supposed to get married next January. She is extremely excited, and looking to spend the rest of her life with me, but the problem is, this summer I actually met the love of my life. It’s the biggest irony, as for years my fiancée and I were friends, and as I approached 40, I wanted to start a family and settle down, and we started a relationship that eventually led to the proposal. For me, there were never any fireworks, just familiarity, and I thought that was best to build on. But on a visit to Chicago this summer, I met the woman who I know that God ordained for me. We have been communicating, and it was instant — me knowing that she’s the one. What can I do to get out of my impending marriage, without hurting my fiancée?

 

Do you know Elvis Presley’s song, Can’t Help Falling In Love? There’s a reason he says, “Wise men say only fools rush in”. That’s because wise people know it’s important to think carefully before making life-changing decisions. Ms Chicago may have been exciting to you in the summer, but can things hold up for the long haul? Many men have learnt the wisdom of the words “only fools rush in” later in life.

Now, you’ve said that Ms Chicago is “God ordained”, and I’m not saying she isn’t “the one”. But I am saying be careful about using a summer stint to make that assumption. Because what a man needs in a good wife is a steady, “got-your-back”, “walk and work with you”, “ride-or-die” type support. It sounds a little like Ms Valentine’s Day has been just that. So be careful not to be distracted because of a “new” opportunity.

I remind the religious readers among us that it was a failed marriage that messed up the mighty Samson, and it’s a misunderstanding of romance that messed up the wise Solomon. So it makes sense for guys to take time to choose a wife carefully, and on the right basis. However, if Ms Chicago is your choice, here’s how to go about making the shift:

Speak with Ms Chicago: Let her know you have to do the right thing with regard to your former relationship. Tell her you’re going to go call off your engagement. Doing this you should get a feel of where Ms Chicago’s heart is. Then go take that time to break it off with Ms Valentine’s Day.

Sit with Ms Valentine’s Day: There’s nothing you can do that’s not going to hurt her. You can only try to let her down easy. Do all the hard work that will be necessary to shift the relationship from platonic to romantic. If she loves you and was excited as you say, then she’ll be absolutely crushed. Tell her you’re giving yourself a shot at something new. Be careful about any mention that Ms Chicago is “God ordained”. Also, if you have mutual assets with her, lean in favour of her benefit.

Rally support for her: She’ll need the support of others. Try to alert mutual friends to what’s going to happen. Explain things to them and ask them for support. You may also need to alert her parents and siblings, via a phone call, and with much apology.

Stay away from her: You’ll need to cut off regular contact with her once she becomes your ex. Know that she’s not yours to make requests of, to lean on, to share accomplishments and experiences with, to ask for advice, etc. She’ll need the distance from you in order to recover. And you’ll need the distance from her to allow Ms Chicago to take that space.

Counsellorscouch.com stands ready to offer support in situations like these. Make contact for further assistance and premarital counselling.

Get on The Counsellor’s Couch with Rev Christopher Brodber, who is a counsellor and minister of religion. E-mail questions to allwoman@jamaicaobserver.com.

 

.

{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
0 Comments · Make a comment

HOUSE RULES

  1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper; email addresses will not be published.
  2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
  3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
  4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
  5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
  6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
  7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
ALSO ON ALL WOMAN
2026: The year of intention
All Woman, Features
2026: The year of intention
ALAISHA THOMAS 
January 5, 2026
FOR many modern women, the new year isn’t about doing more, it’s about doing what’s actually sustainable. The focus has shifted from performance to pr...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
She wants a ring this year
Advice, All Woman, Features
She wants a ring this year
Christopher Brodber 
January 5, 2026
Counselllor, Women are the ones who are usually concerned about timing of proposals, but as the new year starts, I’m realising that my partner and I a...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Can I sue the parents of my child’s bully?
All Woman, Features, Your Rights
Can I sue the parents of my child’s bully?
Margarette Macaulay 
January 5, 2026
My child has been repeatedly bullied at school and I have made several reports, but not much has changed. The school has suspended the offender a few ...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Manipulated into accepting less than
All Woman, Features, Relationships
Manipulated into accepting less than
Lichelle Palmer 
January 5, 2026
IF you’ve ever talked yourself out of something you wanted because a man told you it wasn’t realistic, this piece is for you. It may not have been bec...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Kerry-Ann Stimpson: A passion for brand success
All Woman, Features
Kerry-Ann Stimpson: A passion for brand success
December 29, 2025
AT the heart of JMMB Group’s dynamic marketing strategy is a leader who believes in the power of engaging and empowering employees to be a brand’s bes...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
The proactive woman’s guide to better relationships in 2026
All Woman, Features, Relationships
The proactive woman’s guide to better relationships in 2026
Marie BERBICK-BAILEY 
December 29, 2025
AS someone who has made some unwise relationship choices in my life, I can certainly help you avoid some of those mistakes. Ladies, let’s face it: if ...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Dealing with depression during the holidays
Advice, All Woman, Features
Dealing with depression during the holidays
Christopher Brodber 
December 29, 2025
Counsellor, I am incredibly depressed his holiday season, as this year my marriage ended, and my eldest child also moved away for college and isn’t co...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Krystle Thorpe: Building a life of purpose, one client at a time
All Woman, Features
Krystle Thorpe: Building a life of purpose, one client at a time
December 22, 2025
WITH warmth, grace, and a quiet strength that instantly puts her clients at ease, Krystle Thorpe has become a shining example of what it means to serv...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
❮ ❯
Scroll
Polls
2026: The year of intention
All Woman, ...
2026: The year of intention
ALAISHA THOMAS 
January 5, 2026
FOR many modern women, the new year isn’t about doing more, it’s about doing what’s actually sustainable. The focus has shifted from performance to pr...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
She wants a ring this year
Advice, ...
She wants a ring this year
Christopher Brodber 
January 5, 2026
Counselllor, Women are the ones who are usually concerned about timing of proposals, but as the new year starts, I’m realising that my partner and I a...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Can I sue the parents of my child’s bully?
All Woman, ...
Can I sue the parents of my child’s bully?
Margarette Macaulay 
January 5, 2026
My child has been repeatedly bullied at school and I have made several reports, but not much has changed. The school has suspended the offender a few ...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Manipulated into accepting less than
All Woman, ...
Manipulated into accepting less than
Lichelle Palmer 
January 5, 2026
IF you’ve ever talked yourself out of something you wanted because a man told you it wasn’t realistic, this piece is for you. It may not have been bec...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Kerry-Ann Stimpson: A passion for brand success
All Woman, ...
Kerry-Ann Stimpson: A passion for brand success
December 29, 2025
AT the heart of JMMB Group’s dynamic marketing strategy is a leader who believes in the power of engaging and empowering employees to be a brand’s bes...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Archives
Polls
Recent Posts
2026: The year of intention
All Woman, ...
2026: The year of intention
ALAISHA THOMAS 
January 5, 2026
FOR many modern women, the new year isn’t about doing more, it’s about doing what’s actually sustainable. The focus has shifted from performance to pr...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
She wants a ring this year
Advice, ...
She wants a ring this year
Christopher Brodber 
January 5, 2026
Counselllor, Women are the ones who are usually concerned about timing of proposals, but as the new year starts, I’m realising that my partner and I a...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Can I sue the parents of my child’s bully?
All Woman, ...
Can I sue the parents of my child’s bully?
Margarette Macaulay 
January 5, 2026
My child has been repeatedly bullied at school and I have made several reports, but not much has changed. The school has suspended the offender a few ...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Manipulated into accepting less than
All Woman, ...
Manipulated into accepting less than
Lichelle Palmer 
January 5, 2026
IF you’ve ever talked yourself out of something you wanted because a man told you it wasn’t realistic, this piece is for you. It may not have been bec...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Kerry-Ann Stimpson: A passion for brand success
All Woman, ...
Kerry-Ann Stimpson: A passion for brand success
December 29, 2025
AT the heart of JMMB Group’s dynamic marketing strategy is a leader who believes in the power of engaging and empowering employees to be a brand’s bes...
{"xml":"xml"}{"allwoman":"All Woman", "jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Archives
All Woman
Jamaica Health, Beauty, Weddings &` Motherhood Stories for the Jamaican Woman.
Sections
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
  • Relationships
  • Features
  • Fashion
  • Health & Fitness
  • Your Rights
  • Parenting
  • Advice
Jamaica Observer, © All Rights Reserved