Disenchantment in the Promised Land

The shattered dreams of Jamaican kids who migrate to the USA

BY INGRID BROWN Sunday Observer senior reporter ?browni@jamaicaobserver.com

Sunday, December 20, 2009

Print this page Email A Friend!

SAMANTHA Graham was 10 years old and bursting with excitement. She had just learnt she would be joining her mother — whom she had not seen in four years — in the United States.

The picture-perfect life she’d seen in so many movies soon would be hers.

Goodbyes were said long before the day of departure ther personal items were given to relatives, now deemed less fortunate.

And as the Air Jamaica jet lifted to the sky above Norman Manley International Airport in Kingston, Samantha’s dreams and expectations soared with it. She leaned back in her seat, closed her eyes and imagined a whirlwind of good fortune in this Promised Land. Little did she know that her sweet dreams were about to become a nightmare.

The language was different — everyone except Samantha seemed to speak with an accent. She had to repeat every sentence, every word. Teachers and students complained that they could not deal with her heavy Jamaican accent.

“Some of the children would laugh and say, ‘You really sound funny’,” she recalled. The little snickers about her accent became open jokes among the children. They made fun of her all the time.

Fearful of being ridiculed, she withdrew. She rarely spoke and participated less in classes. Once a top student, Samantha lost interest in school and her grades plummeted.

She balked at homework assignments, became defiant and refused to get along with others. She dropped out of high school and lost her dream of becoming a teacher. Today, at age 28, she works as a health aide in a nursing home in Massachusetts.

Graham’s story is similar to thousands of Jamaican children who migrate to the US with hopes of a better life. These expectations are often shortlived, challenged by a new culture and a new school system, as well as the problem of reuniting with parents they have not seen in years. Sometimes, they also must adapt to a new family of siblings.

Melrose Rattray, marriage and family therapist in Brooklyn, New York, knows too well the challenges faced by children and parents when they reunite and the effect it has on a child’s performance at school.

Often, when these children rejoin their parents, there is no discussion of the emotions surrounding the separation, Rattray said.

Instead, the attitude is one of “You are here now, so let’s get on with it.”

This has serious implications for the child, who feels that what is of value is being ignored. Often, the child arrives as a near stranger, who has also lost the extended family support system of grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins back home.

“Sometimes they are coming into a new family where that parent has entered into a relationship, has other children, and so this child becomes like an outsider who does not feel like a part of the family,” Rattray said.

The problem is compounded by the lack of services to help Jamaican migrant parents and children navigate the challenges.

Rattray said about 20 per cent of her cases are related to separation issues involving parents who do not know how to reunite with their children.

Some children end up in the juvenile justice system, she said, and insisted that this issue must be addressed by Jamaica and the United States.

“Otherwise, more money will be spent to correct problems that could have been prevented,” said Rattray. “If you don’t catch these issues early, then you end up with all the crime and violence.”

Rattray sees hope as more parents seek counselling, although sometimes only when events reach a crisis.

Basil Wilson, dean of criminal justice at Monroe College and former provost and senior vicepresident of academic affairs at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, said Jamaican children who are not proficient in English find the US school system far more challenging. These children, he said, will end up in remedial classes.

This is particularly so in such states as New York, a melting pot for migrants from all over the world.

Wilson said that even with the presence of Jamaican alumni associations in urban communities such as the Bronx, more must be done to help those children adapt.

Jamaica’s consul general in New York, Genevieve Brown-Metzger, said migrant children acculturating to the US school system has long been an issue. Jamaican alumni associations sought to address the problem several years ago after they were bombarded with reports of children falling by the wayside.

“We were getting a lot of calls about problem students who were said to be disrespectful or not paying keen attention in class,” she said. “A teacher would complain that a child would not make eye contact, and that was seen as disrespectful.”

Brown-Metzger said cultural differences were somewhat to blame. In the Jamaican culture, staring down a teacher might be misconstrued as disrespectful.

Alejandro Portes, a professor at Princeton University and a top US scholar on immigrant integration, captured the dynamic of migrant children’s lives in his book Legacies: The Story of the Immigrant Second Generation, co-written by Rubén Rumbaut of Michigan State University. The book is based on interviews with 5,262 children of immigrants.

According to Portes, children of some immigrant groups — among them Jamaican nationals — may be significantly at risk of dropping out of school, getting in trouble with the law and assimilating to the bottom of American society.

Portes found that when parents are poor and uneducated, they are subject to discrimination, affecting how their children assimilate.

“Those children often get a negative reception here — poor support from government agencies and often generalised discrimination. They are racially stereotyped as black or brown, and that makes the process of adaptation difficult,” he said.

According to Portes, it is telling that three-fourths of the black children in the sample — mostly Haitians and Jamaicans — say that no matter how much education they get, they will always be subject to prejudice.

Elaine Jarrett, a Jamaican who migrated to the United States at age 11, knows firsthand the difficulties of migrant children adapting to the US school system. Like many others, she was uprooted from Jamaica, arriving in New York only a few days before beginning school.

“I was excited when I heard I was coming to America because everyone always talk about going to foreign, and as a child you think everything there is so wonderful and it is paradise,” she said.

But for her, the first challenge was having to deal with diversity in the school. “Coming from an environment where all the teachers were black, to one where the majority were white was really a very different experience,” Jarrett recalled.

She kept quiet in class so her Jamaican accent did not stand out, and she focused on giving an appropriate response when asked a question.

Jarrett recalled when the English teacher asked if she knew what a period was, and she responded that it was a “full stop”, an expression used in the Jamaican school system. “At least he understood what I meant,” she said. “But the kids thought that was weird.”

She and other Jamaican children were called “coconuts”, as American children associated those from the islands with palm and coconut trees.

Like many children of West Indian migrants, Jarrett knew there was no room for slacking off. Although her father never attended a parent teacher meeting or checked her homework, he demanded a good report card. That kept her on a straight path, and helped her graduate from high school and college.

In those days, Jarrett said, special-education classes were not as available as today, and those who buckled under the pressure or failed to perform at a certain level were labelled “no good”.

She recalled a male Jamaican student who was regarded as a constant “pain in the neck” by teachers who said he would never “amount to anything”. He became a brain surgeon.

Counselling is usually not an option for many Jamaican parents, and an even greater taboo for many is to have their children on medication for behavioural disorders.

A study done by Audrey Pottinger, a consultant clinical psychologist at the University of the West Indies, noted that insensitivity to the cultural traditions of clients can impede communication.

The study said West Indians see counselling as indicative of pathology and may feel stigmatised if their child is referred for individual help.

Special orientation sessions for new immigrant children and their parents would be valuable, Pottinger said.

School counsellors, she noted, also must be aware that many migrant children are misclassified at school, because of language differences or adjustment problems.

“Often the ‘acting-out’ behaviour of the child reflects the difficulty of the transition, and this may be compounded by parental pressure and expectations,” Pottinger said.

Gail Ferguson, a clinical psychologist, is conducting a study of about 400 families in Kingston, Illinois and New York, with the goal of creating a profile of young Jamaican immigrants as compared with US-born Americans.

“We could have a profile of those kids that are doing well in school versus those who are struggling, and this profile, when put together, will help professionals and families,” she said.

More programmes, Ferguson added, are needed to help Jamaican migrant children adjust to the US school system, including the possibility of post- and pre-migration counselling.

Ann-Marie Adams, a Jamaican journalist, said in Hartford, Connecticut, which has one of the largest Jamaican communities, people are shocked to learn that children are coming from Jamaica and cannot read.

“Now you find that 100 kids might come over from Jamaica to Hartford and only six may graduate while the others fall into gangs or only want to play soccer,” she explained.




1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper � email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

comments powered by Disqus



Today's Cartoon

Click image to view full size editorial cartoon