Emergency work disrupts water supply in St Ann 2:41 PM
Water woes for St Andrew and St Catherine 2:32 PM
Samuels century leads Windies fightback 1:18 PM
Bolt clocks pedestrian time to win Ostrava 100m 1:03 PM
Churches raising money to fight gay marriage 12:20 PM
Escaped prisoner back in custody 12:06 PM
News
Trafigura haunts PNP
Contractor general recommends Colin Campbell be charged for obstruction in probe
Tuesday, August 24, 2010
THE ghost of the 2006 Trafigura scandal yesterday returned to haunt the Opposition People’s National Party (PNP) and, in particular, Colin Campbell as the Office of the Contractor General (OCG) has recommended that he be charged for obstructing and hindering its probe of the affair.
Contractor General Greg Christie said that there was enough evidence recorded in his 111-page report of his investigation into the oil lifting contracts between the Petroleum Corporation of Jamaica (PCJ) and Dutch firm Trafigura Beheer which established that Campbell “committed a criminal offence or offences under Section 29 (b) of the Contractor General Act”.
According to Christie, former information minister Campbell failed, without lawful justification or excuse, to comply with a lawful requirement of the contractor general and thereby obstructed the probe by withholding critical information.
Said Christie: “The repeated failure and/or refusal of Mr Colin Campbell to provide detailed and particularised answers to those of the OCG’s written requisitions and questions which were lawfully directed to him, and/or to otherwise fully co-operate with the OCG’s investigation into the specific allegations which are associated with the subject payment of $31 million to the CCOC Association, has virtually stumped the OCG’s investigative attempts and efforts in this matter.
“Consequently, the OCG is recommending that the appropriate legal action, as deemed fit by the DPP, be pursued against Mr Colin Campbell.”
Trafigura came to the attention of Jamaicans in 2006 when the then Opposition Jamaica Labour Party revealed that the firm, which traded oil for Jamaica on the international market, had donated $31 million to an account operated by Campbell, who at the time was also the PNP’s general secretary.
The money was transferred to the account just prior to the PNP’s annual conference that year.
Trafigura Beheer said the money was part of a commercial agreement, while the PNP maintained that it was a donation to the party.
“They made the offer. They said that they know elections are imminent in Jamaica and they are intending to make a contribution,” Campbell told journalists at a news conference in October 2006 at the PNP headquarters.
Campbell had also told journalists that CCOC stood for “nothing in particular” and that the account was simply one the party used to deposit campaign finances.
However, the Observer subsequently found out that CCOC meant ‘Colin Campbell Our Candidate’ and was an association formed by a group of his supporters.
The ensuing scandal from the transaction damaged the PNP, and Campbell resigned as PNP general secretary and from the Cabinet. A few days later, PNP president and then prime minister Portia Simpson Miller ordered the money sent back.
Just over a year later, in November 2007, Prime Minister Bruce Golding told Parliament that the Dutch police believed Trafigura Beheer had bribed Jamaican public officials in 2006.
On November 20, 2007, the Parliament passed a resolution giving the Dutch investigators permission to probe the donation to the PNP.
Christie, in his report, made reference to the attempt by the Dutch police to probe the scandal, saying that the OCG was contacted by the Dutch authorities in October 2006 seeking assistance in carrying out its own investigation.
However, he said he denied the Dutch police’s request, in keeping with Section 28 of the Contractor General Act, and after an exchange of e-mails between his office and the Dutch police, in which he also sought their assistance, he did not receive the requested information.
Christie said that the failure of the Dutch police and Campbell to provide him with the information he needed resulted in him being unable to ascertain the reasons for the payments and whether they had any bearing on the oil lifting contracts.
At the same time, Christie said he found no evidence to indicate that the oil lifting contracts had Cabinet approval, neither were they endorsed by the National Contracts Commission.
“The OCG also found that the PCJ did not have a Procurement Committee in place prior to 2006, which is… another breach of the GOJ Procurement rules,” Christie added.
The contractor general also recommended that, in light of the Trafigura controversy, stringent and appropriate election campaign financing laws be enacted to force the disclosure of the identity of campaign donors and financiers.
POST A COMMENT
You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.
HOUSE RULES
1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.
2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.
8/24/2010
This kind of dishonesty to the people has been going on for a long time by both parties JLPNP. I am confused as to how we make decision to put these people in power to govern us. Are we really paying attention; or we are just doing it for the party which is backward thinking. Lets start making decisions for Jamaica both parties have taken our kindness for ignorance. They point finger like kids on a playground. When was the last time a government official was successful prosecuted and convicted?
8/24/2010
The ghost of Trafigura is in fact haunting the PNP,and the Jamaican people will be the ultimate judges of the depth of this haunt, It must however be put into context that the then Minister of Information and General Secretary of the party resigned as a result of this issue, in fact the loss of the 2007 elections was punishment of the PNP for corruption or the perception of corruption.The real question is about the lies and deception of those who promised better and from whom better was expected
8/24/2010
It seems as if being in politics in JA gives you immunity from any form of justice. Government contracts are given to Dons (Criminals) the Dons use the money to buy out the community cheap. The people in the community support the Dons for trickle down dollars and that is the cycle. Birth of the die hearted supporters. These types of incidents are proof of misrepresentation and unaccountability yet these parties have die hearted supporters forever. Wake up ppl and let’s move on to better days.
8/24/2010
The reason neither the JLP or PNP have not call for legislation to kick out and bar politician fro parliament is because "the same knife that stick sheep, kick goat. Resignation calls are a waste of time. Enact legislation to force out crooked politicians out of office. The PNP has been calling for Golding to resign even though he has not committed a crime. If legislation was in place he would be tried and impeached. Hibbert, Spencer, Blythe, Campbell, et al would never hold political office
8/24/2010
A call for resignation is just that -- a call. Over the years, there has been call for members of both parties to resign w/o success. I can't keep track of how may call the JLP in opposition has called on the members of the PNP to resign. Call for resignation is nothing more than political grandstanding -- a way to gain political mileage.Neither the PNP/JLP are willing to enact strong legislation to kick politicians out of office and eventually barring them for holding public office. Why?
8/24/2010
What ever happened to the the suit Golding was going to bring against the US paper fro calling him a criminal re Dudus? As Isaid at the time, this will not see the light of day.
8/24/2010
Stephen Smith, you are so misguided in your analysis.....how can you equate 31 million campaign donation, to the web of deception Bruce and his combolos have spun over the Jamaican people.....never mind the negative press, the US millions spent to correct the fallout to the tourism sector and the unnecessary lives lost.Are you really serious?
This is not political i happen to have voted for the JLP even more than the Present PM in recent times, but i criticize where i see fit in Ja. interest
8/24/2010
O for the day when we have a govt with Lisa Hanna, Tufton, Bunting, Holness and all the others that are doing a good job and have potential working together for the good of the country.
8/24/2010
Brad Kerr. Yes. Greg Christie graduated Norman Manley Law School in late 1970s. So yeah. he is a lawyer with 30 years or so at the Bar.
As for who did what. SW Services (where 90% of the Trafigura blood money went) is the campaign fund for South West St. Andrew. And you still expect someone to accept that this isn't Portia's project? At least Bruce took responsibility for his part.
8/24/2010
Tell me something, if MPP was representing the Government of Jamaica and not the JLP, isn't it comprised of all ellected official (members of parliament who won their elected seats). Which lead me to question, if that is the case the PNP had to have known about the hire of MPP before the email and all the other nonsense that followed. Jamaica stop and think about it Gov. is represented by both parties win, loose or draw, that means its time for PNP to help build Jamaica, Gov. build countries.
8/24/2010
Why good work? When i have seen someone convicted from any of his investigations, then come to me for the congratulations. Nothing ever is done with his findings, no one is ever brought to justice....so whats the purpose? They continue to do wrong after the light has gone off them.
8/24/2010
Is it really Trafigura that haunts the PNP or is it the Observer? The Gleaner, I am sure outsells your paper for this very reason. No one cares about this old "2006 news" Mr. Observer. REPORT THE NEWS, THE CURRENT NEWS !!
8/24/2010
Trafigura and DudusGate tells the story that JLPNP cannot be trusted. If you cannot weed out the wrong doers then you are a wrong doer as well. Your credibility is shot. Do not pretend that Trafigura did not happen and all is well because all is not well in Jamaica. MPP cannot be ignored and Trafigura cannot be ignored. We need a third option because JLPNP needs to be buried. We look forward to better days without those corrupt parlimentarians in the JLPNP.
8/24/2010
We are so political in our thinking.
8/24/2010
Good work Greg Christie. Let the chips fall. Can you imagine out of all people in the world. You are my role model? I would like to be like him and would love to meet him one day. The man has no affection towards any special party when it comes on to wrong. If many more person in JA has that quality alone. Our politics would change for the better. But die hard PNP n JLP cannot be objective and that is why our leaders continue to display questionable conduct. Thanks again.
8/24/2010
Since their were lost of lives involving Dudusgate, resignations are not enough. Now it comes to light that there were numerous individuals within Goldin's administration involved in Dudusgate. The proof exists that the government was involved from head to foot, and their involvement have led to the lost of lives. Resignations, trials, and jail time should be on the table for Dudusgate. Trying to bring back this old issue from years past is shameless and very transparent.
8/24/2010
I feel sad for those of us who really believe that The PNP is a trustworthy alternative at government. In the 18 years they rule, Jamaica has become more corrupt than Nigera in the 90's. The Government in Power is not off the hook but at least there is an element of credible workers in Govt. can someone say Tufton. If we believe that Trafigura should be left alone then i say back off MPP. all sin spells SIN. noe is different or should be treated different...I agree with the OCG. Prison Them.
8/24/2010
As a said for the Manatt affair with bruce golding, this must not be allowed to be pushed under the rug. We should not stop until all wrongdoings are exposed. If this is done it would be a plank in Jamaica's development.
.
People who are in power, whether it is bruce golding as PM or some party functionary, we can not allow them to break the law without impunity.
.
Richie
8/24/2010
Portia Simpson Miller and the PNP will form the next goverment. Will Colin Campbell be a representative? We dont know. Campbell is being recommended to be charged not the PNP. Clear house sister P and move forward. I trust the leader of the PNP, I believe she has the interest of Jamaica at heart. The JLP forms the Gov. of the day and they are doing a horrible job, there are more controversies surrounding the JLP in 3yrs than the 18yrs of PNP.
8/24/2010
Is Greg Christie a Lawyer? I am just asking... Let see what the DPP do with this recommendation, We will all keep our eyes and ears open and pay close attention. Just keep Joseph Hibbert in mind. Jamaicans will not be distracted by Trafigura again.. we want the truth from the govt about the money to pay for Dudus lawyer and lobbying. Collin Campbell did what no one in this govt have considered. He resigned...
8/24/2010
You people might not post this but this is why I do not like the Observer anymore. Your biasness knows no bounds.
The PNP paid for this in the last election. It has been 3 days since the new revelations about MPP and yet you people choose to be quiet on this issue...I am sure the Gleaner has outsold you by about 10 to 1 as the info about MPP is what Jamaica wants to hear about not this old Trafigura issue
8/24/2010
We must hold all of them accountable, whether they wear green, orange, black, yellow, or gold.
8/24/2010
Campbell resigns - Golding calls for Cabinet to go too
published: Monday | October 9, 2006
Rayon Dyer, Gleaner Writer
Opposition Leader, Bruce Golding, is insisting that the Government should resign over the Trafigura Beheer scandal.
According to Mr. Golding, the Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) will not accept the resignation of one or two Government ministers over the issue.
"This one will not go away like a nine-day wonder. We are going to ensure that everything about this $31 million donation comes to light," he said
8/24/2010
I cannot understand how Colin Campbell has the gall to offer himself up for parliament. Is the Jamaican electorate going to even allow it? Does the PNP not have any better candidates? The Electorial Commission of Jamaica cannot recommend any enforceable policy on campaign finance. The Parlament has failed to pass a law that brings transparency and credibility to political finance. Where is the public outrage? We cannot stand idly bye and continue to allow this. The PNP is not a credible option.
8/24/2010
And the Mudslinging continues. Better yet the reprisal "character assassination". I used the word reprisal beacuse it's a extremely poupular word in JA, You know why. What is going to happen to JA? I see one of the PNP lawyers on the news last night saying"If you can't prove it, it never happen". I guess the one that can hide his/her misdeeds the best will be ok and good for office in JA it seems. GOD HELP US
Other Stories
Pension reforms to be implemented this year
0 comments
‘Tourism worries’ - Opposition, JHTA seek meeting with minister
0 comments
Special constable accused of corruption
0 comments
0 comments
Broadcaster Wayne Whyte returns to court July 3
0 comments
$2-m bail for businessman implicated in lottery scam
0 comments
0 comments
0 comments
0 comments
0 comments
Mexican boy's eyes gouged out 'to save the world'
0 comments
UN chief cites unacceptable violence in Syria
0 comments
Jamaica can't afford a stimulus budget — Phillips
7 comments
23.4b Tax grab - Gov't targets extra revenue
7 comments
Canada pumps $62m into Ja’s polygraph programme
0 comments
7 comments
Vendor says GCT reduction not enough
0 comments
Tax measures the death knell for tourism — Cummings
5 comments
Teen killed for laughing at man who fell from bicycle
0 comments
Shaw says taxes will hit small businesses
2 comments





