Dear Editor,

I think the prime minister should rescind the proposed appointment of Velma Hylton, QC, to the commission that would look into the Tivoli Gardens incursion for the following reasons:

1. The Government stands to lose nothing in reappointing a new person to be commissioner.

2. The intent of the Government is to make this Commission as pure as possible and not a “kangaroo court” like the one that Bruce Golding and the JLP set up when they did the Manatt enquiry. It is for this same pursuit of making the commission above reporach why the Opposition was invited to participate in the selection of the commissioners and setting the terms of reference, something they have refused to do.

3. The Opposition will have no straw to clutch at because they are now realizing the folly of their way for refusing to take part in the process. Recognising that the people of Jamaica are not pleased that they have refused to sit at the table after being invited to participate, they are clinging to the unfortunate statements made by the notable Queen’s Counsel. But how can they truly say that they want justice for the people of Tivoli Gardens and yet stand aside and refuse to participate in the quest for justice. This is most hypocritical. Let us also recall that when Bruce Golding was setting up the Manatt Commission he solely selected the terms of reference and commissioners, and the very same persons in the JLP who are vociferous now remained silent.

Against this background I am strongly suggesting to the prime minister that she request the removal of Velma Hylton and select a new person and let us see what Messrs Holness and McKenzie will be grasping at.

Ralston Chamberlain

Toronto, Canada

ralston.chamberlain@alum.utoronto.ca