Dear Editor,

I have followed the commentary on Damion Crawford’s misguided assessment of his opponent.

I think Crawford grew up in Kingston where there does exist an elite brown and white class who descend from the plantocracy or the Arab merchant classes. He mistakenly applies this “class analysis” to rural Jamaica, where Ann-Marie Vaz grew up.

Outside of Kingston, and perhaps Montego Bay, the complexion of people does not necessarily correlate with their social position. For example, the parish of St Elizabeth has a fairly large population of light-skinned Jamaicans, often with light-brown, blue, grey, or green eyes. They are, for the most part, small farmers, country folk, or peasants, if you like this word. Their light skin and exotic eyes do not bring them a higher social position than their neighbours and relatives of darker hue.

I think Crawford should leave Kingston from time to time and explore the rest of Jamaica to test his complexion/class analysis. Outside of Kingston, no one speaks of uptown people and downtown people, nor is there a predisposition to assess someone’s class background solely based on their complexion.

I am not saying colourism does not exist at all in Jamaica, I am just suggesting that too often people use the Kingston class/colour paradigm to tar the entire Jamaica with the same brush.

The advertisement featuring Vaz’s grandma should serve to enlighten Crawford about social realities outside of the Kingston Metropolitan Area, where many dark-skinned people have wealth and social position, and many light-skinned people have neither.

Martha Brae

martha.brae@yahoo.com