AI in health care: Greater efficiency, better quality, but at what cost?
IN my February 4, 2024, Jamaica Observer article, “Artificial Intelligence in Nursing and Midwifery Education”, I emphasised that AI-enhanced learning could contribute to a competent and adaptable nursing and midwifery workforce, improved patient care, and quality outcomes, provided appropriate policies, procedures, guidelines, and safeguards were established.
I also cautioned that AI-driven learning platforms could dehumanise education and diminish the development of empathy, human connection, and social and emotional skills.
Further, on March 21, 2024, I organised a webinar, titled “The Use of Artificial Intelligence in Emergency Search and Rescue”. This initiative was driven primarily by my exposure to cutting-edge technology during a visit to China. The Chinese presenter highlighted the importance of exploring innovative technologies beyond traditional clinical environments.
This growing focus on AI reflects the extent to which the technology is transforming various sectors globally, including healthcare delivery systems. There is renewed hope for greater efficiency and improved health outcomes. However, an important question remains: Will AI improve the efficiency and quality of health-care delivery, or will its increasing use introduce new risks that undermine patient-centred care?
Can AI improve efficiency and quality in the Jamaican health-care system?
For Jamaica and the wider Caribbean, where health-care systems struggle with workforce shortages, financial constraints, overcrowded wards and emergency departments, and unequal access to specialised services, AI presents significant opportunities. However, its successful integration demands investment, regulatory oversight, professional competence, ethical safeguards, and a commitment to preserving the human component of healthcare.
Evidence suggests that AI can improve healthcare efficiency, particularly in diagnostic imaging, clinical documentation, disease surveillance, and administrative processes. However, improvements in efficiency do not automatically translate into better patient outcomes because the quality of healthcare depends not only on the speed and accuracy of technological processes but also on timely clinical interventions, professional judgement, effective communication, continuity of care, and the availability of appropriate resources. Consequently, while AI may improve the efficiency of healthcare processes, these improvements must translate into measurable benefits for patients.
A case in point is that, in Jamaica, timely cancer diagnosis remains an important public health priority. Imagine a client attending a health-care facility for mammography. An AI-assisted system identifies a suspicious lesion requiring further investigation. The radiologist reviews the findings and recommends appropriate follow-up. Early identification could facilitate timely treatment, potentially improving survival. However, AI must support rather than replace professional clinical judgement.
AI also offers opportunities to reduce the administrative burden on health-care professionals. Bracken and colleagues examined AI-assisted clinical documentation systems and their potential to improve efficiency and prevent burnout. Respondents’ experiences indicate a cautious optimism towards AI integration. AI-assisted clinical documentation could allow nurses and medical officers to spend less time documenting care and more time interacting with patients. Consider an overcrowded emergency department where nurses spend considerable time recording observations, updating nurses’ notes, and completing reports. A validated AI documentation system could assist with these responsibilities, freeing valuable time for direct patient care. Nonetheless, AI-generated records must be reviewed for accuracy to minimise errors that could potentially compromise patient safety.
Jamaica’s readiness for AI-driven health-care system
Jamaica has recognised the transformative potential of AI, and the Ministry of Health and Wellness, in its wisdom, published an AI in Health-Care Concept Paper for Jamaica in June 2025. The document outlines proposals for governance, infrastructure, workforce development, implementation, and continuous evaluation.
The proposed five-year approach recognises AI’s potential to improve health-care efficiency, strengthen clinical decision-making, and support universal health coverage even as the nation grapples with communicable and non-communicable diseases. This initiative also signals the ministry’s commitment to advancing the integration of AI into Jamaica’s health-care system and establishing a foundation for successful nationwide implementation.
While Jamaica as a whole could benefit from AI-supported diagnostic services, patient scheduling and appointments, disease surveillance, and emergency response, rural communities stand to benefit the most, given their limited access to specialist services. AI-assisted telehealth could facilitate earlier assessment and more timely referrals, thereby reducing delays in accessing essential health-care services and potentially improving patient outcomes.
In conclusion, the success of AI in Jamaica’s health-care system should not be measured merely by the extent of technological utilisation, but by demonstrable improvements in the accessibility, efficiency, equity, safety, and quality of patient care. In addition, professional judgement, accountability, and the human connection that remain fundamental to health-care delivery must be preserved. Artificial intelligence should serve as a tool to strengthen, rather than replace, the expertise and compassionate care provided by health-care professionals. By and large, its use should translate into meaningful and sustainable improvements in the health and well-being of all Jamaicans.
Professor Adella Campbell is a lecturer in the College of Health Sciences, University of Technology, Jamaica.