Legislators naive
Defence attorney Peter Champagnie, King’s Counsel, says Parliament is to blame for the dilemma now playing out in the courts — with defendants charged under the new Firearms Act opting to go to trial in an already clogged system — after failing to heed the warning from legal practitioners that this would happen.
“‘Tis the season once again for our justice system to be in the spotlight; this has been fuelled by recent reports of accused persons before the Gun Court being far less inclined to plead guilty under the new firearms legislation, with the resultant risk of there being an erosion of the gains made in the reduction of the backlog cases in this court,” Champagnie said in a letter to the editor on Monday.
The attorney said this, coupled with “the inordinate delay in obtaining DNA reports in criminal cases and the unwillingness of some members of our society to serve as jurors when called upon, have also emerged as factors likely to impede any timely delivery of justice”.
“Candidly, the issues that now plague our justice system are the result of our legislators refusing to heed the warnings of legal practitioners who foretold that the new firearms law would hardly see any accused charged under that law pleading guilty,” Champagnie lamented.
“This new law doesn’t provide any incentive in the way of a reduction in sentence for those wishing to plead guilty. Presently, whether one pleads guilty or not, an accused is assured of a minimum period of 15 years of imprisonment upon conviction for having a prohibited firearm. An accused would therefore sooner take his chances at a trial rather than offer up a plea of guilty,” the attorney said.
“It was naive of our legislators to think that the necessity to be remorseful and altruistic would be devoid of any consideration of a definite 15-year prison [term] when time came for any accused to contemplate pleading guilty. The result therefore is as it is now: The vast majority of cases are now moving towards trials. This is within the context of the reality that we simply do not have sufficient courtrooms, prosecutors, and judges to try all such cases within a reasonable time,” the prominent defence attorney said.
He, in the meantime, called for proper staffing and equipping of the Government’s forensic laboratory.
“As it relates to the inordinate delays in obtaining DNA reports, surely it should have been recognised that DNA evidence would have become far more prominent in criminal cases, given what are now common features in our legislation which deal with crimes such as murder, rape, and possession of a prohibited weapon. These common features are steeper mandatory periods of imprisonment. The stakes are, therefore, much higher. Consequently, proof in the way of guilt demands the exploration of independent scientific evidence other than the mere say-so of an accuser,” Champagnie said.
“The reality is that the focus solely on laws dealing with the treatment of those accused of criminal offences is not an effective means in treating with the ills of the justice system. What is required is a recognition that the efficiency of our courts is not mutually exclusive to the proper operation of other State agencies which, of necessity, interface with our courts. In this regard there needs to be an urgent effort towards having our forensic laboratory being properly staffed and well equipped to deal with the pace at which criminal cases are moving,” he added.
In October last year Independent Commission of Investigations (Indecom), which probes more than 200 fatal shootings and reports of abuse by State agents yearly, said completion of its inquiries in a timely manner is being hampered by late ballistics reports from the under-resourced State forensic lab.
“By the nature of what we do, from time to time we have to rely on the Institute of Forensic Science and Legal Medicine for certificates regarding ballistics, chemistry, biology and post-mortem reports. Currently there are a number of investigative files that we have for which we await scientific reports,” Indecom Commissioner Hugh Faulkner told the Jamaica Observer at the time.
“The main challenge is with the ballistics reports, and Indecom investigates over 200 firearm-related incidents on a yearly basis so the timely return of many of these matters would ensure that the complainants, family members, et cetera, are in a better and more informed position to pursue civil remedies where applicable. Our submission of matters for the special coroner would be timelier, and complainants would have speedier closure to their matters,” Faulkner said then.
“We are looking to complete our investigations for our matters within a 12-month period, at the most. We wouldn’t restrict them to a date but we would appreciate the provision of these reports,” he said.
According to Faulkner, the late submission of the reports not only hampers the commission’s investigative process but also delays the submission of matters for rulings by the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions.
Prime Minister Andrew Holness in November this year gave instructions for the new Firearms Act to be amended. That directive came after the director of public prosecutions indicated that her office would be appealing the life sentence imposed on 26-year-old Atlee Murray of March Pen Road, St Catherine, who was caught with an illegal gun, with a view to having the sentence set aside.
The new Firearms Act, with prescribed sentences of up to life imprisonment for certain offences, was enacted in November 2022.