Opposition floats long shot censure motion against House Speaker Juliet Holness
KINGSTON, Jamaica — A private members’ motion calling for the Speaker of the House of Representatives Juliet Holness to be censured, allegedly for not being truthful in her claim that she was assaulted by the Member of Parliament for St Andrew South Western Dr Angela Brown-Burke, was read into the parliamentary records Tuesday night but was not debated.
Even if it were to be debated it would have no chance to pass as the Government would use its majority to kill it.
While that motion was not debated, the Government used its majority to suspend Brown-Burke from six sittings of the House ostensibly for allegedly pushing the Speaker and calling her a “coward”. This supposedly took place while Brown-Burke stood in the aisle, in breach of parliamentary rules, as the speaker exited the Chamber.
The incident unfolded on November 3 as the House descended into chaos with Opposition MP Mikael Phillips hurling expletives at Government MP Desmond McKenzie. Despite his apology, including in the Parliament on Tuesday, Phillips was referred to the Privileges Committee for possible further action. The referral was made despite vociferous objection from the Opposition which accused the Government of abusing its power.
The censure motion was read into the records by the MP for St Catherine South, Fitz Jackson.
It acknowledged that the Speaker is the guardian of the rights and privileges of every member of the House and stated that, “the authority of the Chair rests on the confidence of the whole House that the Speaker will act with impartiality, fairness and scrupulous regard for the truth”.
It accused the speaker of “causing to be published nationally and internationally”, that Brown-Burke physically assaulted her as she was leaving the Chamber.
The Opposition insisted that, “The official recording of the proceedings of the House on the third day of November 2026, broadcast live by the Public Broadcasting Corporation of Jamaica, shows no physical contact between the Member for St Andrew South Western and the Speaker, and does not support the allegation of assault.”
The motion also highlighted that the allegation has been repeated by members of the Government and by officers of the governing party, and has been used to portray Brown-Burke and the Opposition as a whole, as “violent, disorderly, disrespectful of the Chair and in breach of the good order of this House”.
The motion noted that Brown-Burke has formally called upon the speaker to withdraw the allegation, but that she has refused to do so. It also stated that the claim made by the speaker alleges that Brown-Burke committed a criminal act of assault but is false and injurious to her reputation at home and abroad, and brings the office of the Speaker and the House into disrepute.
The Opposition reminded that it has repeatedly raised its complaint of bias on the part of the Speaker and cited several examples including (i) the refusal of the written request of the member for St Andrew South Western to make a personal statement, while other members were permitted to make personal statements without prior request; (ii) the disallowance on the 28th day of April 2026 of an amendment moved by the Leader of the Opposition at the committee stage of the National Reconstruction and Resilience Authority Bill; and (iii) on the third day of November 2026, the curtailment of debate on the Opposition’s motion of censure after only two contributions, and the adjournment of the sitting while a division called by the Leader of the Opposition was pending, contrary to Standing Order 38.
The motion calls for the Speaker to be censured “for publishing, nationally and internationally, a false allegation that the member for St Andrew South Western physically assaulted her. It asserted that the allegation is not supported by the official record of the proceedings of the House, is false and injurious to the reputation of Brown-Burke, and is inconsistent with the duty of truthfulness and impartiality required of the Chair”.
— Lynford Simpson