Phillips referred to Parliament’s Privileges Committee despite public apology
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Despite strident opposition, Government members on Tuesday used their majority to approve a motion to send the matter involving the Opposition Member of Parliament (MP) for Manchester North Western, Mikael Phillips, to the Privileges Committee of the Parliament for deliberation and recommendation.
The motion was moved by the Leader of Government Business in the House Floyd Green.
This followed Phillips’ earlier apology in Parliament for his conduct during the fracas that erupted at the end of the sitting of the House of Representatives on November 3 when he hurled expletives at the MP for West Kingston, Desmond McKenzie.
It took a divide vote for the motion to be carried. The 30 members of the governing Jamaica Labour Party who were present voted “yes” while the 25 MPs representing the Opposition People’s National Party voted “no”.
Opposition Leader Mark Golding in objecting pointed out that two people were involved in the dispute yet only one was being referred to the privileges committee.
“There was a member on that [Government] side, the member for Kingston Western who was involved in that quarrel, who has not apologised for his role in it, for whatever he said in it, and yet we’re being faced today with an attempt to refer one party to that quarrel to the privileges committee and not the other,” said Golding.
“Where is the fairness in that?” Golding asked. He insisted that it was a reference to his deceased mother [by McKenzie] that got Phillips upset to the point of using expletives.
“And he has not apologised for that reference. In fact he has doubled down on it and has said there is nothing wrong with it,” Golding pointed out.
He argued that there was a lack of balance and fairness in the approach taken by the Government and said the decision amounted to an abuse of power by the majority.
The MP for Trelawny Southern, Marisa Dalrymple-Philibert, disagreed with Golding. The Government MP asked, “Why is it that the Opposition, in a situation where it is being clearly said that the member from Manchester has apologised and the motion moved …and the matter has been sent to the Privileges Committee which has members of both sides of the aisle, and will appropriately deal with the matter?”
Leader of Opposition Business in the House Phillip Paulwell objected to the motion on the grounds that Phillips had apologised to Jamaicans two weeks earlier “and today in this Parliament, I have never heard a more full-throated apology by anybody over the years inside here. Never heard it”.
“I believe that having heard what the member said today, we inside here as reasonable representatives would see the matter at an end. And I think that is what we should agree on and conclude today that that matter which he has regretted, he has apologised for it, should now be put to bed,” Paulwell added.
However, the MP for St Andrew North Eastern Delroy Chuck did not see it the way Paulwell did. The justice minister commended Phillips for apologising to the nation but said, “With due respect, an apology cannot be the end of this matter.”
“What took place two weeks ago, November 3, was the worst I have seen on the floor of this Parliament in my nearly 30 years as a parliamentarian. Never seen anything like this, never seen anything [like it] on the floor of this Parliament, during Parliament, or after Parliament,” Chuck said.
Saying the nation and the world saw what happened, Chuck argued, “If we say that an apology — contrite, genuine as it is — is the end of the matter, this does not represent what civility and decency should be in this Parliament.”
“I think the committee should obtain the relevant footage, recordings [and] hear from the members who witnessed the exchange and intervene and give members concerned a fair opportunity to respond,” said Deputy Leader of Government Business Robert Morgan during his contribution to the debate.
Morgan said the committee’s findings should determine whether further action is warranted.
“I cannot predict what the Privileges Committee may say. They may find the apology sufficient, they may not,” Morgan said.
The Opposition MP for Portland Eastern, Isat Buchanan, argued that Phillips should not be put before any committee when he was told about his mother.
Declaring an apology to be “the greatest feat that one can think of”, Buchanan remarked that the incident took place after Parliament had adjourned.
An attorney-at-law, Buchanan told Green, who brought the motion, that “a man cannot be a judge in his own cause”.
“It is a performative and dysfunctional process that we’re undertaking in relation to the member that apologised in the public space and stood here in Parliament. What level of performance and what is the mischief we’re trying to correct by doing this to our elected officials?” he asked.
In his apology in Parliament, Phillips said, “Those were my words, and I regret them, and I take responsibility for them.”
Phillips asked for forgiveness from his parliamentary colleagues on both sides of the House and apologised to the people of Manchester North Western, whom he said had entrusted him to speak on their behalf.
Addressing the wider Jamaican public, Phillips said his actions had fallen short of what should be expected of an elected Member of Parliament.
Reflecting on his response, Phillips acknowledged that he could have removed himself from the situation instead of reacting in anger.
“I had a choice about how I responded that evening, and I could have walked away. I should have,” he said.