Jewellery thieves have sentences shaved
THE three men who were in 2014 convicted for a daring daylight robbery at Tropical Jewellers on Constant Spring Road in St Andrew in April 2011, where they posed as policemen and made off with $50-million worth of jewellery, on Friday benefited from a reduction in their sentences due to an error on the part of the sentencing judge and an eight-year delay in getting their appeals heard.
The three — Jahvid Absolam, Winston Harris and Garnett Linton — after a trial in the High Court Division of the Gun Court before a judge sitting without a jury, were each sentenced to serve 15 years’ imprisonment for illegal possession of a firearm, 20 years’ imprisonment for each of the robbery offences, and five years’ imprisonment for the simple larceny. The sentences were to run concurrently.
However, despite the appeals being filed in May 2014, the transcript of the trial was not produced until June 15, 2021. The appeal court on Friday said, “there is no part of that seven-year delay that can be attributed to any of the appellants”.
It said similarly, the additional year since that time was due to the normal processes and schedule of the court led to the delay of eight years for the appeal to have come on for hearing.
“These appellants are entitled to the benefit of similar constitutional redress for the breach. Two years’ reduction in their respective sentences would also be appropriate,” the court declared.
It further, in its ruling, pointed out that the analysis of the issues raised in these appeals has shown that the conviction for larceny cannot stand and should be set aside and declared that the convictions for the other offences should, however, not be disturbed.
The court, however, said the sentences for each of the appellants are set aside because the learned trial judge failed to demonstrate that he gave the appellants full credit for the time that they spent on pre-trial remand. It said a reconsideration of the sentences and the application of constitutional relief for the unacceptable delay in bringing their appeals on for hearing requires an additional reduction of their respective sentences.
As such, the court, in setting aside the original sentences, substituted with sentences which it said reflected credit for the time spent on pre-trial remand and relief for the breach of their respective constitutional rights to have their appeals heard within a reasonable time.
Consequently, Absolam’s sentences were reduced for the count of illegal possession of a firearm to serve nine years, 11 months and one week, 12 years, 11 months and one week on count two which was robbery with aggravation and 12 years, 11 months and one week for count three, robbery with aggravation. The sentences are to run concurrently making it so that he will only serve the longest of the three periods. The sentence is being calculated as running from 2014. Similarly, Harris, whose sentences were also shaved, is to serve seven years and 11 months for illegal possession of a firearm, 10 years and 11 months for robbery with aggravation and 10 years and 11 months for another count of robbery with aggravation. Linton, for his part, will now serve nine years, 11 months and one week for illegal possession of a firearm, 12 years, 11 months and one week for one count of robbery with aggravation and 12 years, 11 months and one week for the other count.
At the trial, the prosecution led evidence that on April 6, 2011 about 11:00 am, four men and a woman held up the staff of the Tropical Jewellers store at Tropical Plaza in St Andrew, and robbed them, at gunpoint, of firearms and cellular telephones. The robbers also took away a large quantity of merchandise that was in the showcases in the store. This included rings, chains, and Movado watches.
Investigations led the police to Harris’ house and a search produced a Movado watch, three gold chains and $185,000 in cash. Harris, in a caution statement, admitted to being part of the robbery, saying he waited for, and transported, the lookout man from the plaza where the store was. When Linton and Absolam were taken into custody, Absolam said the robbery was a set-up, involving someone connected to the store.
Lawyers for the three argued, among other things, that the learned trial judge descended into the arena and played the role of the prosecutor during the trial, while also taking issue with the judge’s treatment of the “discrepancies and contradictions in the identification evidence given by the prosecution’s witnesses”.
The appeal court in its ruling on Friday said the learned trial judge’s interventions did not unfairly prejudice the defence and there was no miscarriage of justice.
In respect of the arguments by all three attorneys that the sentences were manifestly excessive, the court said the attorneys were correct that the judge erred in his approach to the sentences as while he reminded himself that the appellants had spent a long time in custody and that he was obliged to consider it, he did not carry out the mathematical exercise that was required.
“It is, therefore, not known whether he gave full credit for the remand period,” the court said.
In handing down its decision, the appeal court said “it is without a doubt that these offences require custodial sentences”, given, among other things, the prevalence of firearm offences in the country and the fact that the offences were carefully planned and brazenly committed almost in the middle of the day. In noting that the victims of the event must have been badly shaken by the crime and the way it was committed and an occupant of the store was pregnant at the time and spoke of her concern for her unborn child during the incident, the court said, strong condemnation of the crime is required.