Subscribe Login
Jamaica Observer
ePaper
The Edge 105 FM Radio Fyah 105 FM
Jamaica Observer
ePaper
The Edge 105 FM Radio Fyah 105 FM
    • Home
    • News
      • Latest News
      • Cartoon
      • International News
      • Central
      • North & East
      • Western
      • Environment
      • Health
      • #
    • Business
      • Business Bites
      • Social Love
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Basketball
      • Cricket
      • Horse Racing
      • World Champs
      • Commonwealth Games
      • FIFA World Cup
      • Olympics
      • #
    • Videos
    • Entertainment
      • Music
      • Movies
      • Art & Culture
      • Bookends
      • #
    • Lifestyle
      • Page2
      • Food
      • Tuesday Style
      • Food Awards
      • JOL Takes Style Out
      • Design Week JA
      • Black Friday
      • #
    • All Woman
      • Home
      • Relationships
      • Features
      • Fashion
      • Fitness
      • Rights
      • Parenting
      • Advice
      • #
    • Obits
    • Classifieds
      • Employment
      • Property
      • Motor Vehicles
      • Place an Ad
      • Obituaries
    • More
      • Games
      • Elections
      • Jobs & Careers
      • Study Centre
      • Jnr Study Centre
      • Letters
      • Columns
      • Advertorial
      • Editorial
      • Supplements
      • Webinars
    • Home
    • News
      • Latest News
      • Cartoon
      • International News
      • Central
      • North & East
      • Western
      • Environment
      • Health
      • #
    • Business
      • Business Bites
      • Social Love
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Basketball
      • Cricket
      • Horse Racing
      • World Champs
      • Commonwealth Games
      • FIFA World Cup
      • Olympics
      • #
    • Videos
    • Entertainment
      • Music
      • Movies
      • Art & Culture
      • Bookends
      • #
    • Lifestyle
      • Page2
      • Food
      • Tuesday Style
      • Food Awards
      • JOL Takes Style Out
      • Design Week JA
      • Black Friday
      • #
    • All Woman
      • Home
      • Relationships
      • Features
      • Fashion
      • Fitness
      • Rights
      • Parenting
      • Advice
      • #
    • Obits
    • Classifieds
      • Employment
      • Property
      • Motor Vehicles
      • Place an Ad
      • Obituaries
    • More
      • Games
      • Elections
      • Jobs & Careers
      • Study Centre
      • Jnr Study Centre
      • Letters
      • Columns
      • Advertorial
      • Editorial
      • Supplements
      • Webinars
  • Home
  • News
    • International News
  • Latest
  • Business
    • Business Bites
  • Cartoon
  • Games
  • Food Awards
  • Health
  • Entertainment
    • Bookends
  • Regional
  • Sports
    • Sports
    • World Cup
    • World Champs
    • Olympics
  • Videos
  • Career & Education
  • Classifieds
  • All Woman
  • Environment
  • Webinars
  • More
    • Football
    • Elections
    • Letters
    • Advertorial
    • Columns
    • Editorial
    • Supplements
  • Epaper
  • Design Week
IDT rules against school in dispute with physical education teacher
The Industrial Disputes Tribunal.
News
October 29, 2023

IDT rules against school in dispute with physical education teacher

A physical education teacher who challenged his employer’s decision to make his post redundant at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic was adjudged by the Industrial Disputes Tribunal (IDT) to have been unjustly terminated and is to receive $2 million as relief.

The IDT delivered its decision in the dispute between American International School of Kingston (AISK) and Allan Roper on October 24, 2023 after hearing submissions over five sittings between July 12, 2023 and August 30, 2023.

Roper was employed to the school on a fixed-term contract on September 16, 2013 and through a series of promotions ended up as athletic director, the position he held at the time his position was made redundant on August 1, 2020.

On March 8, 2021 his attorney wrote to the school contesting the redundancy, arguing that it was not genuine. The school replied, outlining the reasons for the redundancy, but that was not accepted, so the matter was referred to the Ministry of Labour and Social Security for conciliation. However, those efforts were unsuccessful; therefore, the ministry referred the dispute to the IDT on November 25, 2022.

The IDT heard that Roper was invited, via a June 1, 2020 e-mail, to a meeting scheduled for June 2, 2020 at 10:30 am. The subject line of the e-mail referenced ‘Invitation: Allan Scheduling and Contract’. Roper enquired as to the context for the meeting and if there was anything he needed to prepare. However, he was advised that he need not prepare.

The meeting was chaired by Susan Canobie, head of school, and included Ingrid Fitt, operations director, representing the Human Resource Department.

The IDT heard that Roper was told that due to the impact of the pandemic on the school’s operations, his position would be made redundant with effect from August 1, 2020.

The school’s attorney, Emile Leiba, explained that AISK was forced to close indefinitely in March 2020 based on the Government’s directives regarding the pandemic, and its operations and students’ enrolment for the September 2020 academic year were severely impacted. He also noted that athletic activities at the school were halted, with no clear signs of a return to normality, and as a consequence the school had to make a number of positions redundant, including the position of athletic director.

Fitt, who was AISK’s sole witness, confirmed that the school was mandated by the Ministry of Education to close all face-to-face classes in March 2020, and as a consequence it began conducting classes online.

She said that some of the international students and their families left Jamaica as a result of the closure, and the board decided to take on the task of restructuring the budget as student enrolment, which stood at 270 at the end of June in the 2019-2020 academic year, had fallen to 230 in the 2020-2021 registration, resulting in a loss of US$588,000.

The school, she said, took several steps to manage its operations, including cuts in salaries of between five per cent and 20 per cent, freezing salaries, changing the full-time status of some employees to part-time, and completing redundancy exercises for six posts, including the one held by Roper.

Fitt also told the IDT that, in the case of the athletic director, the school was uncertain as to what time frame existed for a return to normality, and since there could be no physical or otherwise sporting activities, “the school took the decision that it would be logical to make that position redundant”.

However, under cross-examination, Fitt admitted that in February 2021 the school had placed a newspaper advertisement for the post of athletic director, but said that the position would not have been filled before August 2021. She said that although the school was still uncertain as to when face-to-face activities would resume, they nevertheless wanted the person at hand in anticipation of a resumption of physical and sporting activities.

She also acknowledged that in May 2021 an advertisement for the post of student life director was published in the newspaper and that it was similar to that of athletic director. She emphasised, however, that the May 2021 advertisement with the change in nomenclature had nothing to do with the communications between Roper’s lawyer and the school, but arose because of the additional responsibilities to the position, to include an emphasis on field trips, both local and international. The post was eventually filled by an employee of the school in August 2022.

After hearing submissions from both sides, the IDT said that while the “abnormal and frighteningly unusual circumstances brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic, and the uncertainty as to how long the restrictions and lockdown would have lasted provided adequate and reasonable grounds for any employer to contemplate redundancy”, it could not ignore the fact that two advertisements appeared in the newspaper months later.

The IDT said the job description for first one — athletic director/activities coordinator — mirrored the core functions outlined in Roper’s job description at the time of his dismissal. Additionally, it said that it found “disingenuous at best” Fitt’s explanation that the second job — student life director — would have differed from the previous advertisement with the inclusion of “international field trips”.

“We firmly are of the view that the inclusion of ‘international field trips’ to the May job advertisement was directly influenced by communications received from Mr Roper’s attorney contesting the validity of the redundancy,” the IDT said.

“These two advertisements, we submit, cast a shadow on the genuineness of the redundancy at the time and raise questions as to the real motive behind the decision,” the IDT said.

The tribunal also said AISK ignored the Labour Relations Code and accused the school of deception in relation to the purpose of the June 2 meeting with Roper.

{"website":"website"}{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
0 Comments · Make a comment

ALSO ON JAMAICA OBSERVER

TotalEnergies-backed Vikings strike gold at Swim for the Sanctuary
Latest News, Sports
TotalEnergies-backed Vikings strike gold at Swim for the Sanctuary
November 18, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Narda Ventura, founder of Vikings Swim Club, was full of praise for sponsor TotalEnergies Jamaica after her team captured three go...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
J’can woman’s viral reality TV moment gains global attention
Entertainment, Latest News
J’can woman’s viral reality TV moment gains global attention
November 18, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — A Jamaican woman's rather colourful assessment of another woman's romantic escapades and the financial standing those ‘situationsh...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Miller-Bennett unveils blueprint for development of Hanover Western
Latest News, News
Miller-Bennett unveils blueprint for development of Hanover Western
November 18, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Member of Parliament (MP) for Hanover Western, Heatha Miller-Bennett, has proposed a blueprint for the development of the constitu...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Yanique Bosslady hits Itunes top 10 with ‘Nuh Short Ah Nothing’
Entertainment, Latest News
Yanique Bosslady hits Itunes top 10 with ‘Nuh Short Ah Nothing’
November 18, 2026
Buzzing dancehall artiste Yanique Bosslady has been basking in the continued success of her break out single entitled " Nuh Short Ah Nothing " ( Good ...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
‘Mi guh a gud, gud school’
Latest News, News
‘Mi guh a gud, gud school’
Verbal standoff erupts between Burchell and Cuthbert-Flynn
November 18, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — A below the belt war of words has erupted between Member of Parliament (MP) for St James Southern, Nickeisha Burchell, and the Mem...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Terrelonge bats for AI data centres to be built in Portmore
Latest News, News
Terrelonge bats for AI data centres to be built in Portmore
November 18, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Member of Parliament for St Catherine East Central Alando Terrelonge, is jockeying for data centres to be constructed in Portmore....
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Latest News
Gas prices and diesel down $0.25
November 18, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Motorists should see a decrease at the pumps in the price of gasoline effective Thursday, November 19, according to the latest ex-...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Cops kill man after early morning knife attack at police station
Latest News, News
Cops kill man after early morning knife attack at police station
David Dunkley, Observer Online Writer 
November 18, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica — A man was shot dead after he reportedly attacked a cop inside the Kingston Central Criminal Investigations Branch (CIB) office on ...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
❮ ❯

Polls

HOUSE RULES

  1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper; email addresses will not be published.
  2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
  3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
  4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
  5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
  6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
  7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

Recent Posts

Archives

Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Tweets

Polls

Recent Posts

Archives

Logo Jamaica Observer
Breaking news from the premier Jamaican newspaper, the Jamaica Observer. Follow Jamaican news online for free and stay informed on what's happening in the Caribbean
Featured Tags
  • Editorial
  • Columns
  • Health
  • Auto
  • Business
  • Letters
  • Page2
  • Football
Categories
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Page2
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Page2
Ads
img
Jamaica Observer, © All Rights Reserved
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • RSS Feeds
  • Feedback
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Code of Conduct