Subscribe Login
Jamaica Observer
ePaper
The Edge 105 FM Radio Fyah 105 FM
Jamaica Observer
ePaper
The Edge 105 FM Radio Fyah 105 FM
    • Home
    • News
      • Latest News
      • Cartoon
      • International News
      • Central
      • North & East
      • Western
      • Environment
      • Health
      • #
    • Business
      • Business Bites
      • Social Love
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Basketball
      • Cricket
      • Horse Racing
      • World Champs
      • Commonwealth Games
      • FIFA World Cup
      • Olympics
      • #
    • Videos
    • Entertainment
      • Music
      • Movies
      • Art & Culture
      • Bookends
      • #
    • Lifestyle
      • Page2
      • Food
      • Tuesday Style
      • Food Awards
      • JOL Takes Style Out
      • Design Week JA
      • Black Friday
      • #
    • All Woman
      • Home
      • Relationships
      • Features
      • Fashion
      • Fitness
      • Rights
      • Parenting
      • Advice
      • #
    • Obits
    • Classifieds
      • Employment
      • Property
      • Motor Vehicles
      • Place an Ad
      • Obituaries
    • More
      • Games
      • Elections
      • Jobs & Careers
      • Study Centre
      • Jnr Study Centre
      • Letters
      • Columns
      • Advertorial
      • Editorial
      • Supplements
      • Webinars
    • Home
    • News
      • Latest News
      • Cartoon
      • International News
      • Central
      • North & East
      • Western
      • Environment
      • Health
      • #
    • Business
      • Business Bites
      • Social Love
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Basketball
      • Cricket
      • Horse Racing
      • World Champs
      • Commonwealth Games
      • FIFA World Cup
      • Olympics
      • #
    • Videos
    • Entertainment
      • Music
      • Movies
      • Art & Culture
      • Bookends
      • #
    • Lifestyle
      • Page2
      • Food
      • Tuesday Style
      • Food Awards
      • JOL Takes Style Out
      • Design Week JA
      • Black Friday
      • #
    • All Woman
      • Home
      • Relationships
      • Features
      • Fashion
      • Fitness
      • Rights
      • Parenting
      • Advice
      • #
    • Obits
    • Classifieds
      • Employment
      • Property
      • Motor Vehicles
      • Place an Ad
      • Obituaries
    • More
      • Games
      • Elections
      • Jobs & Careers
      • Study Centre
      • Jnr Study Centre
      • Letters
      • Columns
      • Advertorial
      • Editorial
      • Supplements
      • Webinars
  • Home
  • News
    • International News
  • Latest
  • Business
    • Business Bites
  • Cartoon
  • Games
  • Food Awards
  • Health
  • Entertainment
    • Bookends
  • Regional
  • Sports
    • Sports
    • World Cup
    • World Champs
    • Olympics
  • Videos
  • Career & Education
  • Classifieds
  • All Woman
  • Environment
  • Webinars
  • More
    • Football
    • Elections
    • Letters
    • Advertorial
    • Columns
    • Editorial
    • Supplements
  • Epaper
  • Design Week
St Vincent court dismisses legal challenges to buggery laws
News
February 17, 2024

St Vincent court dismisses legal challenges to buggery laws

KINGSTOWN, St Vincent (CMC) – The High Court Friday dismissed the case brought by two gay St Vincent and the Grenadines citizens living overseas, challenging the island’s buggery and gross indecency law.

Among other things, Justice Esco Henry, in a ruling handed down, held that the men had no legal standing to bring the claims, filed by Javin Johnson and Sean Macleish, in light of the fact that they live overseas and have not lived in St Vincent and the Grenadines (SVG) for some time.

She also dismissed the men’s argument that they had been forced to leave here because of their sexual orientation.

The court upheld the Government’s argument that the laws are reasonably required for public health and morality.

“… To my mind, the thought of a public health crisis occasioned by an unstemmed deluge of new HIV cases, is a real and serious concern which reasonably justifies a public health response of the kind embedded in the challenged provisions,” Justice Henry said in her ruling.

She said she recognises that all states do not have the same measure of resources to tackle the myriad of health and other issues confronting them.

“Without judgment, I take judicial notice of the notoriously known inadequacies of the current health-care capabilities in the State amidst the increasing demands on it. I am satisfied that the policy issues which dictate the State’s response are matters best left to the State.”

The judge said that in all the circumstances and in light of her observations, she had no doubt that the approach adopted by the State in relation to public health and public morality concerns on the issue “has a rational connection to the stated objective, and within the context of this State’s limited resources and the mores relied on, is most likely the least drastic means to achieve that goal”.

Justice Henry, therefore, made no finding that the challenged provisions infringe either Sections 9 10 of the Constitution.

She further held that challenged provisions are not arbitrary, irrational, or contrary to the common law prohibition on irrational grounds.

The two men also contended that they were forced to leave or were expelled from the St Vincent and the Grenadines by reason of the buggery and gross indecency laws and how they were allegedly treated while in the country or socially conditioned as a result.

“I reiterate my misgivings expressed earlier regarding the claimants’ allegations of ill treatment by others,” Justice Henry said, adding that the claimants have not established their claim that they have been expelled and had their freedom of movement curtailed or infringed by the challenged provisions or consequences flowing from them.

She dismissed Johnson and MacLeish’s case respectively in their entirety and ordered them to pay costs of EC$7,500 to the Office of the Attorney General.

Similar challenges to similar laws in the Commonwealth Caribbean have succeeded and one legal expert, in immediate reaction to the ruling, noted that unlike in some of the other cases, the court actually heard evidence from Johnson and MacLeish.

The defendants were the Attorney General, The Incorporated Trustees of the Seventh-day Adventist Church, The Incorporated Trustees of the Evangelical Church of the West Indies, The New Testament Church of God, The Archbishop & Primate (Spiritual Baptist) of SVG, The Church of God SVG, The Incorporated Trustees of the New Life Ministries, The Light of Truth Church of God, Kingstown Baptist Church of SVG, Living Water Ministries International ( SVG), and Hope Evangelism Outreach Ministries.

King Counsel Joseph Middleton along with Peter Laverack, Jomo Thomas and Zita Barnwell appeared for the claimants, while Solicitor General Karen Duncan, Senior Crown Counsel Cerepha Harper-Joseph, Crown Counsel Franeek Joseph and Crown Counsel Gabrielle Mayers appeared for the respondents.

Attorneys Mandella Peters and Cheryl Bailey appeared on behalf of the interested parties in Johnson’s case and Meisha Cruickshank for the interested parties in MacLeish’s claim, while Christopher Hummel Smith and Grahame Baller appeared for the interested party Vincy Chap.

{"xml":"xml"}{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
0 Comments · Make a comment

ALSO ON JAMAICA OBSERVER

JahDore seeks justice, apology after 7-year case ends in acquittal
Entertainment, Latest News
JahDore seeks justice, apology after 7-year case ends in acquittal
October 29, 2026
KINGSTON, Jamaica —Jamaican reggae artiste and Rastafari advocate JahDore, whose given name is Sean McDonald, is calling for justice, accountability a...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Buju Banton hits back at Holness, says it takes more than waving a flag to promote Jamaican culture
Latest News, News
Buju Banton hits back at Holness, says it takes more than waving a flag to promote Jamaican culture
October 29, 2026
Reggae and dancehall superstar Buju Banton is hitting back at comments by Prime Minister Andrew Holness that some entertainers wave the Jamaican flag ...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Caribbean among countries urged to boost long-term care systems
Latest News, Regional
Caribbean among countries urged to boost long-term care systems
October 29, 2026
WASHINGTON, United States (CMC) – The Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) and the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) are urging countries acros...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Wisdom wins third straight ‘Settle All Arguments’ Class 1 title
Latest News, Sports
Wisdom wins third straight ‘Settle All Arguments’ Class 1 title
October 29, 2026
ST JAMES, Jamaica —Police inspector Jason ‘School Boy’ Wisdom captured the Class 1 title for a third consecutive year at the Jamaica Draughts Associat...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Caribbean Cup success showcases strides in local club football, says Ricketts
Latest News, Sports
Caribbean Cup success showcases strides in local club football, says Ricketts
October 29, 2026
Kingston, Jamaica — Portmore United and Mount Pleasant Football Academy will contest the Concacaf Caribbean Cup final in December, ensuring that the r...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Over 250 Colombians killed in Russia-Ukraine war, govt says
Latest News, News
Over 250 Colombians killed in Russia-Ukraine war, govt says
October 29, 2026
BOGOTA, Columbia (AFP) — Over 250 Colombians have died and almost 1,000 have disappeared while fighting in the Russia-Ukraine war, the South American ...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
Oraine Freestyle Adventures surpasses 30 million views, eyes global expansion
Entertainment, Latest News
Oraine Freestyle Adventures surpasses 30 million views, eyes global expansion
October 29, 2026
If you have attended a major festival, concert or party in Jamaica or the diaspora, chances are you have spotted Oraine Freestyle Adventures capturing...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
MoBay deputy mayor lauds Issa for 62-foot ‘Together We Rise’ monument
Latest News, News
MoBay deputy mayor lauds Issa for 62-foot ‘Together We Rise’ monument
BY HORACE HINES Observer writer 
October 29, 2026
ST JAMES, Jamaica — Deputy Mayor of Montego Bay Councillor Dwight “Debo” Crawford has hailed hotelier Christopher Issa for his role in transforming th...
{"jamaica-observer":"Jamaica Observer"}
❮ ❯

Polls

HOUSE RULES

  1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper; email addresses will not be published.
  2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.
  3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.
  4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.
  5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.
  6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.
  7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

Recent Posts

Archives

Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Tweets

Polls

Recent Posts

Archives

Logo Jamaica Observer
Breaking news from the premier Jamaican newspaper, the Jamaica Observer. Follow Jamaican news online for free and stay informed on what's happening in the Caribbean
Featured Tags
  • Editorial
  • Columns
  • Health
  • Auto
  • Business
  • Letters
  • Page2
  • Football
Categories
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Page2
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Page2
Ads
img
Jamaica Observer, © All Rights Reserved
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • RSS Feeds
  • Feedback
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Code of Conduct