The Morgan doctrine on defamation should be dismissed out of hand
Government Senator Marlon Morgan is a political neophyte and should not be taken as seriously as he seems to take himself. At the same time, he is not to be completely dismissed — for two important reasons.
First, Mr Morgan is in a position of influence as parliamentary secretary in the Ministry of Education, Skills, Youth, and Information in the Dr Andrew Holness-led Administration. Second, Jamaica needs young people who are willing to offer themselves for public service to a nation that needs every ounce of talent that she can muster.
It is in that context that we would like to see his rather juvenile suggestion, as he made his contribution to the State of the Nation Debate in the Senate last Friday, that criminal sanctions be reintroduced for defamation.
While it is true that the senator was aiming his barbs at the parliamentary Opposition, their surrogates, and supporters on social media, it clearly escaped his wisdom that his party could one day be in Opposition again, having handed the Government such a draconian measure as criminal sanction for defamation.
Accusing the Opposition People’s National Party (PNP) of tarnishing people’s reputation, Mr Morgan appeared angered by what he said was the “misinformation and disinformation” being peddled by these PNP “surrogates and deplorables which served to undermine the country’s democracy”.
“They have the effect of eroding public trust, distorting truth and facts, presenting false narratives, and besmirching people’s good name and reputation,” he asserted.
Mr Morgan, regrettably, seems to interpret every caustic criticism of the Government as coming from the Opposition. He might wish to tell us how he would separate distorted truth and facts and false narratives expressed by people on social media, from PNP supporters, in order to have them jailed.
If the senator read a little more, he would have seen that when a similarly foolish suggestion was made by his colleague, Mrs Marlene Malahoo Forte in December last year, how quickly it was dismissed out of hand by the media and civil society.
Reintroducing colonial-era criminal penalties would chill investigative journalism, weaken public accountability, and risk turning regulators into censors, ultimately undermining Jamaica’s democratic principles, the Press Association of Jamaica cautioned.
Mr Morgan seemed unaware that in November 2013 the Government, with full support from the then Opposition Jamaica Labour Party (JLP), abolished criminal defamation in Jamaica by replacing the 19th-century Libel and Slander Act and the 1963 Defamation Act with the Defamation Act of 2013.
He might also find useful a 2025 statement by Dr Andrew Wheatley, a minister without portfolio in the Office of the Prime Minister, that legislation “is already in place to protect Jamaicans from online abuse”, under the Cybercrimes Act.
Going further back, he would also have seen that a committee appointed by the JLP Government in 2008 reviewed the then libel and slander legislation and recommended, among other things, support for the principle of freedom of the press and provision of reasonable protection against false and damaging publications, without criminalising the work of journalists.
Senator Morgan has much to learn.