Beyond the Moroccan fertiliser gift
Dear Editor,
The recent revelations from the auditor general’s report concerning the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Mining and the Rural Agricultural Development Authority (RADA) have rightly sparked outrage. The matter surrounding the distribution and the approximate $65-million lapse in accountability for the fertiliser donated by the Kingdom of Morocco thoroughly deserves intense governance and public scrutiny.
However, beyond the clear governance and accounting failures, there is a far more insidious potential problem arising from this controversial gift — one that could affect the entire nation, including citizens yet to be born, and for which it appears no due diligence was conducted. Specifically, did anyone determine whether this fertiliser met minimum cadmium tolerance levels, especially for application on soils already containing high levels of geogenic or native cadmium?
For context, local wholesalers and suppliers typically ascertain cadmium levels in phosphate raw materials or intermediary compounds as part of standard commercial sales agreements, even when sourcing from Morocco. In contrast, with this gifted batch, it remains completely unclear whether any baseline due diligence was performed to confirm if cadmium levels were within acceptable limits or if they exceeded those of pre-existing commercial supplies.
Phosphate raw material originates from two primary geological sources — igneous rocks and sedimentary rocks. Igneous rock sources contain very low cadmium concentrations, whereas sedimentary rock sources harbour significantly higher concentrations. Moroccan phosphate deposits are sedimentary in nature, with cadmium concentrations typically ranging from 17 mg/kg P2O5 up to 165 mg/kg P2O5 depending on the specific mining basin.
To address this, decadmiation is routinely carried out during processing to reduce the level of cadmium in phosphate fertiliser, ensuring it complies with the strict import regulations of receiving markets, particularly within the European Union. Was this gifted batch subjected to decadmiation prior to shipment, or was raw, high-cadmium product delivered?
Jamaican soils are already known to possess relatively high total cadmium levels. The indiscriminate addition of fertilisers with high cadmium concentrations could lead to a dangerous increase in bioavailable de novo cadmium, further exacerbated by soil priming effects.
It is important to note that high total soil cadmium does not automatically translate to increased crop absorption. Cadmium bioavailability is regulated by cationic species diversity and concentration, driven by soil reaction (pH), cation exchange capacity, the nature of the colloidal exchange complex, the types of silicate clays present, and the diversity and proportion of the soil’s humic fraction.
With rigorous agronomic practices, soils with relatively high total cadmium can be actively managed to keep bioavailable cadmium below tolerable absorption limits — limits that vary depending on crop type. Furthermore, good soil management can mitigate the ecotoxicological effects of cadmium by promoting chemical fixation onto the colloidal exchange complex.
Yet, without safety testing, tracking, and strict soil management guidelines accompanying the distribution of this donation, we run a severe risk. Cadmium bioaccumulates in the food chain and can cause severe, adverse long-term impacts on human health.
While financial mismanagement is unacceptable, the potential contamination of our agricultural lands and food supply poses an environmental and public health risk. The ministry must urgently declare whether heavy metal testing and decadmiation verification were conducted on the batches of Moroccan fertiliser that were gifted to Jamaica, and outline what measures are being taken to safeguard Jamaican soils and consumers.
Although the Fertilizer and Feeding Stuffs Act provides broad regulatory guidelines for imported fertiliser raw materials and intermediary compounds, the Act does not explicitly state a numerical threshold for cadmium. Perhaps the time has come for the Ministry of Agriculture to review the Act and, where appropriate, update it in line with international trends; taking into account Jamaica’s peculiar geological and pedological circumstances.
Seymour Webster
Portland
sawgrinovativesolutions@gmail.com