A stake has been driven into the heart of Trumpism
Last Tuesday the American people voted in what in my view was the most existential elections in recent times. It was a rejection of indecency, graft, corruption, and incompetence in office that has compromised the health of millions of Americans and put their general well-being under severe strain.
It was a statement to leaders that truth matters and one cannot govern people on the basis of falsehoods dressed up as rigorous policy. The cruel dimensions of US President Donald Trump’s rabid and aggressive immigration policy left many decent Americans appalled at what America was becoming — a nation that no longer cared for the stranger in its midst, which is an insult to a policy that has really made the country great.
In policy after policy, whether domestic or international, the conduct of the Trump Administration in the run-up to the elections was woefully lacking, abysmal, and in some instances, frightening. On the international front, the Administration embarked on an unnecessary war with Iran in league with Israel, which had its own axe to grind with that country. If containment of the Iranian ability to build nuclear weapons was the key to the attack on Iran, it was misguided and certainly not properly thought out.
The Barack Obama Administration had already secured agreements on important fronts in this regard, but Trump could not cede this success to the former president, who he seems to hold in disdain. Now the country is being seen as a pariah nation as the war grinds on and the lives of Americans and others around the globe are made more difficult by inflationary pressures brought on by the oil crisis attendant upon the war. And Trump’s aggressive tariff policy has not helped to endear America to the world.
The Republican party lost control of the US House and Senate in the recent midterm elections.
For these and many other reasons, the people came out and sent his Administration the loud and clear message that they were fed up with things as they were and desired a new direction. One cannot be sure that the message was heard and understood, and given the posture of the Administration, there can be no certainty that the people’s concerns will be taken seriously. But, in recent memory, this was the most broad-based rejection of any political party in an American midterm election. The more serious-minded in the Republican Party would be well advised to take heed.
The question has been asked as to whether the Make America Great Again (MAGA) movement will survive Trump. No one really knows the answer, but if I should seek to answer it, I would venture that it is not likely. One of the most important reasons is that the movement was built around the cultic personality of one person and does not have any overarching philosophy or moral underpinnings that can sustain it. In terms of loyalty to a political ethos, however brief, Trump has been the cultic leader of the biggest mass political movement in the country. I stress mass political movement as distinct from the religious ones that we know readily. He inspires the same fanaticism and loyalty in his followers as the religious ones, such as Jim Jones.
But the midterm elections in my view evidenced a breaking of the dam of this loyalty. As I said to my wife, I perceived a silent majority in MAGA who came to believe that Trump had no interest in them other than to exploit them for his own political and economic needs. This sentiment I believe was greatly cemented by the Iran war and strengthened by the way in which Trump, his cronies, and members of his family seemed to be benefiting while they suffered and were hardly getting by. So there was, I believe, a silent anger against him which might have resulted in many not bothering to vote, or if they did, they voted in defiance for the other party’s candidate.
In any event, MAGA’s survival is doubtful because it is built around the chequered personality of one man. In other words, MAGA is Trump and it lives only as long as he is alive. A movement built on personal animosity; a thirst for revenge for assumed wrongs done against him; and is predicated on a notion that the maximum leader has all the answers, is always right, and does not brook any opposition is not likely to outlast the death of its founder.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio (Photo: AFP)
But what about people like Vice-President J D Vance, Marco Rubio, Ron Desantis, and others? As far as I see it, there is no personality in the Republican Party and perhaps in the society at large who can get away with the things that Trump has been allowed to, especially by the Supreme Court and the Republican Party. None! There is none that has the gall to deliver publicly the indecent barrages that often flow from Trump’s mouth, sometimes laden with expletives. There is none that could post an expletive-laden comment on Easter Sunday and survive as president. None! It demonstrated complete disregard for this holy day and the people who commemorate it.
So my prophetic intelligence tells me that there is none to out-trump Trump. They would never get away with spewing nastiness, calling people names, mocking the disabled, and vilifying a war hero such as the late, illustrious Senator John McCain. Thus, he stands in a league all by himself, an aberration, a political phantom that will vanish as all phantoms do.
The results of the midterm were akin to a dagger driven into the heart of Trumpism or MAGA.
From he began his second term, Trump was essentially a lame duck. He became even more so last Tuesday. I have written of my pity for him because of the excellent opportunities he has been given to leverage power on behalf of the people he swore to swerve. But, to date, he has failed miserably at this task. Even now he cannot find it in himself to forgive those he believes have hurt him.
I listened to an interview he gave to 60 Minutes with Ross Douthat in which he talked about death, forgiveness, heaven, hell, and the end times. My pity for him grew because he could not bring himself to say he would when asked if he could ever forgive the likes of Nancy Pelosi and James Comey.
It is pitiable to see an old man who is rightly concerned about his mortality taking that kind of tone and at the same time hoping to make it to heaven. Far be it from me to cast any judgement or make any prognostications about a person’s soul. That is a duty best left to God. But it boggles the mind for anyone to think that getting to heaven is a kind of transactional arrangement with God which does not necessitate self-transformation.
If he persists in this vein, I can see a broken man without the comfort of friends and even family to give him solace when it matters most. As the inevitability of the ageing process takes its toll and mortality bends to it, one hopes that somehow he may find the peace which seems to have eluded him. At least, as a priest, that is my hope.
Dr Raulston Nembhard is a priest, social commentator, and author of the books Finding Peace in the Midst of Life’s Storms; Your Self-esteem Guide to a Better Life; and Beyond Petulance: Republican Politics and the Future of America. He writes a Substack — The Healing Self — on substack.com. Send comments to the Jamaica Observer or stead6655@aol.com.
Raulston Nembhard