A stomach for war
Recent results in the United States Senate and congressional elections indicated a significant swing away from the current Government in that country. The reason for the swing is largely based on the economic hardships being experienced due to the oil crisis that has emanated from the attack on the Islamic Republic of Iran. This is a divisive issue, even in Jamaica.
I will not really comment on whether I agree with it. I prefer to analyse whether the response is reasonable, given that some people did not believe America should have attacked Iran, or whether America doesn’t have a stomach for war anymore.
The reason given for the attack is that it was a necessary step to prevent Iran from constructing a nuclear bomb. Well, although I acknowledge that it is the presence of nuclear weapons that has prevented World War Three or Four from ever happening, I don’t think any country is responsible enough to own nuclear bombs.
This, needless to say, includes Iran. So it is a good reason.
I am not sure how much research has been undertaken by the voters on the impact of the atomic bombs that were dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945. However, if they had done some research they would probably agree that any steps necessary to prevent a bomb like that landing on your city need to be taken.
Was there really any proof, though? Even if they had a bomb, is intercontinental capability automatic?
Well, it’s hard to say, because Iran blocked weapons inspectors in 2023 and again in 2025. They had previously agreed to allow these inspections. So if you don’t know, and if Iran is breaching agreements, then I am not so sure if taking a pre-emptive strike is such a bad idea.
That being said, I want to believe most people living in the United States would agree. The problem is, when it starts to impact your standard of living, you don’t look at the importance of the decision based on the risk it represents. You just want your problem solved.
Not every country has a stomach for war. I hear a lot of people speak with pride about former Prime Minister Michael Manley standing up to the Americans in the 70s. Most of them are not old enough to remember the consequences we suffered because he did so. They did not have to fight for flour and bread like those of us post-50.
Back then, we weren’t puffing up our chests with pride; we were too busy worrying about food for our stomachs. Although I respect Prime Minister Manley’s strength of character, I recognise that the consequences of his manhood were felt by the rest of us and not him. I did not see him or his inner circle fighting in supermarkets because of American-sanctioned shortages. Our country was destroyed and has never quite recovered from that era.
I see the present Government being criticised for its recent abstinence from voting at the United Nations. I don’t feel good about it either, but, being a pragmatist, I understand the reason for the decision.
We survive at the will and wishes of the United States. They can take away our SWIFT codes. This means we can’t pay for anything electronically. We would have to hand over barrels of cash to buy oil.
In Dominica, our Caribbean neighbour, you have to pay US$10,000 for a one-entry visa, which is treated as a bond until you return. Do you want us to live like that? Do we have a stomach for that war?
Only the Americans sell us guns and ammunition. Not even the British, to whom we are still subject to rulings from their Privy Council, will sell us guns and ammunition. So how would we arm our police force and army? Do you want to see licensed firearm holders having to buy junk guns again?
OHIO, United States — People cast their vote on election day during the midterm elections at Glenville High School in Cleveland, Ohio, on November 3, 2026. Photo: AFP
The vast majority of money that comes into our country through remittances comes from the United States. This is the biggest earner in our economy. They can lock that down in a minute. They did that to Cuba after Barack Obama left office. The majority of our tourists are Americans.
There are quite a few countries that have shown they have a stomach for war. When Hanoi was bombed back into virtually the Stone Age, they continued to fight. When the Ho Chi Minh Trail was bombed so significantly that no truck or vehicle could drive on it, the Vietnamese used bicycles to supply their troops with ammunition. They have a stomach for war.
If we had a stomach for war, the People’s National Party (PNP) would not have been voted out in 1980, because of the economic and political backlash of standing up to the United States.
If the Americans had a stomach for war, the Republicans would not have got this thrashing in the midterms.
I look at the amazing results of police operations that have brought our country back into a period of relative control in relation to our homicide rate. However, when it results in combat, and the criminals that take up arms against the police lose, we start to blame the men and women we send to fight for “us”.
There are many things that we need to emulate in the United States. Their approach to hardships is not one of them. When they were losing the war in Vietnam there were demonstrations across the country. I did not see any demonstrations when they crushed Panama and Grenada in days. The anti-war movement only seems to raise its head when they are losing.
We have to be logical; we also have to be proud. It’s a difficult call for leadership. They have to ask themselves, do I think of my legacy, or do I think of my citizens? What are you willing to give up for what you believe in?
For many years I have accepted that I am risking my life and my liberty by deciding to fight gang domination. It does not take a lot to lose your life in this line of work. Neither does it take a lot to lose your liberty. Anybody can tell a lie on you. That’s all it takes. It is quite likely to happen if you are engaging gang members in volatile communities. It is significantly less likely if you stay home and criticise, or jump on a human rights bandwagon.
We, as citizens, make decisions by ourselves to suffer those consequences or to stay out of it. A Government has to be a little more careful, because the consequences of their actions affect the entire country. If your country has a history of having a stomach for war, like the Vietnamese, then you represent the wishes of the majority. When, however, you know your country does not really have that stomach for war, you have to be more careful.
I wonder what the election results would have been if the Iran war had never taken place? I would gamble that the results would have been similar to the presidential election.
This was not a vote against ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) and their fascist approach to combating illegal immigration. This was not a vote against the Venezuelan military action. This was a vote against the consequences of the Iran war on the day-to-day life of the American people.
This is not a very good look. If you genuinely believe that Iran was developing nuclear weapons, then preventing that is quite honourable. You must expect consequences for that action; just like you must expect consequences when you take military action against highly armed, barricaded criminals in Tivoli Gardens.
Everybody believes that you need to do what needs to be done, but nobody is willing to face the consequences if it ultimately affects them personally.
This is human nature.
Dr Jason McKay is chief executive officer of McKay Security and a noted criminologist. Send comments to the Jamaica Obserbver or drjasonamckay@gmail.com.