Honours from a grateful nation or grateful party?
Let me be clear about what this article is and is not. It is not against national honours. I believe in them, and I applaud those who have earned them — even those who take great pride in saying, “I am deeply humbled by this award,” rather than, “I am honoured by this award…”
A national honour is a promise a country makes to itself about what it values — altruism, noble behaviour, transformational leadership — and the process that awards it is the machinery of that promise. That machinery must remain apolitical — not as a nicety, but as the condition for the honours to mean something greater than a symbol.
My beef is not with the awards. It is with screening so opaque, and purpose so quietly stated, that Jamaicans are left to ‘guess and spell’ why some recipients were chosen. I want no one to feel undeserving. But I am unapologetic for raising processes, purpose, integrity, and accountability.
One boundary: I offer no opinion on who should join the seven national heroes. My subject is narrower: Not who wears the honours, but whether the standards still mean what they say. Jamaica understood this early, and to her credit acted on it. On July 18, 1969 — just seven years after Independence — the National Honours and Awards Act created a Jamaican system of recognition. An act of decolonisation: A new nation refusing to borrow its honours from the empire it had left, insisting that Jamaican excellence be judged by Jamaican standards.
The codified orders run from the Order of National Hero — service “of a most distinguished nature” — down through the Order of the Nation; the Order of Excellence; the Order of Merit; the Order of Jamaica; and the Order of Distinction, divided into two ranks, Commander (CD) and Officer (OD), awarded for valuable and important service; to the badges and medals of honour for gallantry, meritorious service, and long and faithful service. Note what the system provides for outsiders: the Order of Excellence, created in 2003, is reserved for foreign heads of state and government — diplomacy’s honour, plainly labelled as such — while distinguished foreigners may otherwise be admitted only as honorary members. The standards were steeped in sophistication and philosophical integrity; written by Jamaica, for Jamaica.
The Order of Merit shows the system at its best, and it is worth naming names — for the right reason. Consider 10 of its recipients: Bob Marley, reggae superstar; Louise Bennett-Coverley, folklorist and writer; Rex Nettleford, choreographer, dancer and scholar; Jimmy Cliff, singer and actor; Peter Tosh and Bunny Wailer, architects of reggae; Sir Willard White, opera singer; Orlando Patterson, sociologist and historian; Edna Manley, sculptor and painter; and Herb McKenley, Olympic champion. Terms of reference: No more than two a year, no more than 15 living members. This is what a grateful nation looks like when it means it.
Then consider, by contrast, the Order of the Nation — the second highest honour, conferred on governors general and prime ministers and, by extension, their spouses, who share the style of “The Most Honourable”. Here the system is candid: This honour attaches to the office, not to assessed performance; it is not earned but entailed. There is nothing corrupt in that; every nation honours its offices. But note the implication: The system itself knows the difference between an honour that is deserved and one that is automatic, which makes it all the harder to defend what happens when the earned honours start being handed out like the automatic ones.
But a funny thing happened to those standards on their way to National Heroes’ Day. They were never amended — no Parliament voted to lower them; no gazette announced their dilution. They were desiccated — drained of meaning by the slow, steady application of political convenience, until the husk of the rule remained and the spirit had evaporated. And so, each October, as the investitures are conferred, an uncomfortable question hangs over the ceremony like the heat. Are these honours truly from a grateful nation? Or are too many of them from a grateful party?
Consider what national honour is for. It is not merely a reward; it is a declaration. When a nation honours someone, it tells itself, and its children, what it values — courage, service, excellence, sacrifice. The honour is a mirror held up to the national character. But a mirror clouded by politics reflects a distorted face. When the roll of honorees teaches the young that affiliation outranks achievement, the system has not merely failed its recipients; it has miseducated its nation.
The watering down is visible not in the written rules, which remain admirable, but in the choices — some of which defeat every attempt at explanation except the political one. How else are we to understand recognition for which the only discernible qualification is unabashed political affiliation? When class, financial standing, and generous contributions to party coffers correlate with national honours more reliably than service does, the standards have not been amended; they have been abandoned in practice and polished in print. The difficulty is not in proving the pattern. It is in finding the innocent explanation.
This is how standards die without being repealed. The criteria — “outstanding”, “distinguished”, “eminent” — are elastic enough to admit anyone, the advisory process is opaque enough to hide the reasoning, and the prime minister — who advises the governor general, oversees the nominations, and administers the system through the Chancery — is decisive enough to settle it. No rule needs change when it is written to bend.
Then there is the endless practice of award matriculation — from Officer to Commander, from Commander to the Order of Jamaica — each elevation arriving on schedule, without any sign of accretive contribution to the nation since the last. The honour ceases to be a recognition of service and becomes a career ladder; a curriculum vitae polished one investiture at a time. A grateful nation honours what you gave; a grateful party honours that you belong and keeps honouring it at regular intervals.
Those entrusted with the system should fix their eyes on quality over quantity. Consider the arithmetic of prestige: America’s highest civilian honour has reached 672 individuals in 60 years — two in every million Americans. Jamaica honours some 200 citizens every year — 72 in every million. Scarcity is the condition of meaning. National honours must never become confetti, scattered for appeasement, for the theatre of inclusivity, or as quiet remuneration for political favours. For the moment an honour can be secured by donation or affiliation it ceases to be an honour at all; it becomes a receipt. And a receipt, however elegantly calligraphed, means nothing — least of all to those who actually earned theirs.
Let me be plain, before anyone jumps down my throat and calls me ‘bad-mind’, there are and have been many deserving recipients, extraordinary [ordinary] Jamaicans who gave without setting out to be recognised, and who a truly grateful nation could not and should not ignore. I applaud them, and I thank them for their service. It is precisely because their honours mean something that the debasement of the currency is an injury — and the first injured are the deserving themselves, whose distinctions are cheapened by proximity to the purchased kind.
One reform suggests itself with particular force, and I offer it without apology. Recognitions for media practitioners should come upon retirement — while they are alive to receive them, certainly not posthumously — but never while they are in active practice. The reason is human, not cynical. A media practitioner who owes a national honour to the Government of the day cannot scrutinise that Government without fear or favour — the obligation, real or perceived, bends the work. Nor should any benefactor wield such power over a beneficiary. The free press cannot afford even the appearance of a debt to power. Honour the watchdogs when they lay down the watch — not while they are still on it.
And let me say what I love, lest this be read as mere complaint. I love the badges of honour for gallantry, meritorious service, long and faithful service, education, safety, health, and the quiet building of the nation. These are the uncorrupted core of the system — honours that still smell of the work that earned them, given to people whose names the nation should know by heart. No one matriculates into a badge of honour for gallantry. It is given, or it is not, and everyone knows why. The transformational realignment: Grow the badges, not the honours — identify more unsung heroes and fewer of the already-honoured.
So, this is what I ask, without apology: Screening rigorous enough to be credible, purpose transparent enough that no Jamaican must guess why a fellow citizen was honoured, and machinery apolitical enough to be faithful to the 1969 Act’s original intent. Keep the pleasant surprise — no one wants the investiture to read like an examination. But surprise at the announcement is one thing; bafflement at the reasons is another. Publish the citations. Let the reasons be as public as the ribbons. Then, when the nation applauds it will know what it is applauding. A grateful nation bestows its honours. A grateful party merely distributes them. Let us keep the difference.
Christopher Burns
Send your comments to the Jamaica Observer or burnscg@aol.com