Beenie Man’s Weh Di Money Deh and the issue of free speech
Jamaicans have been known to be harsh critics and to have an opinion on everything under the sun, which they are not afraid to express anytime and anywhere, no matter the Administration in power.
This national character trait has no doubt been nurtured by our long enjoyment and practice of free speech. Indeed, freedom of expression is guaranteed as a basic human right under the Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms in the Jamaican Constitution.
For this reason, we wonder why some members of the governing Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) seem to have so little appetite for what they apparently regard as negative criticism of the Government.
The issue of free speech has been brought back to the fore by the contretemps between dancehall star, Beenie Man, whose real name is Mr Moses Davis, and JLP Deputy Leader Mr Desmond McKenzie, following the entertainer’s criticism about how slowly Hurricane Melissa relief funds had been trickling down to victims.
Beenie Man, in a recent interview with British broadcaster ITV News, questioned if donated relief funds were actually reaching the people, adding: “This is nothing new that the Government get the money, the Government distribute the money the wrong way. The people who supposed to get the money haven’t been getting any.”
He then followed up by releasing a track called Weh Di Money Deh.
Mr McKenzie, the local government minister, ticked off by the star’s claims, suggested at a party meeting that Beenie Man was seeking relevance: “Yuh have a certain DJ, fi di last 20 years him cyaan mek a number one hit song. And all of a sudden him cyaan mek it locally cause him nah say nutten. [So] him lef di shores of Jamaica an’ gone out deh go talk about ‘weh di money deh… Government hold on pon di money… Dat deh record nah sell at all, nobody nah buy it.”
We agree with Dancehall Magazine which wrote: “For long-time dancehall listeners, none of this feels out of character. Beenie Man has been one of the genre’s loudest voices for decades, and Jamaican music has always doubled as a running commentary on life, hardship, and politics on the island.”
Just last month, JLP Senator Mr Marlon Morgan, and long before him Member of Parliament Mrs Marlene Malahoo Forte, suggested that the Government should consider bringing back criminal sanctions for defamation, after criticism from the Opposition and social media, drawing strong pushback from the Jamaican media and civil society.
Interestingly, on the Beenie Man issue, Prime Minister Dr Andrew Holness struck a more measured tone: “I believe in freedom of speech, and every Jamaican has the right to criticise their Government and hold us accountable… What I ask is that we do so with dignity, separate the person from the problem, and stick to the facts.”
Dr Holness conceded that as prime minister he had difficult conversations with his ministers, including when there are concerns about delivery, costs, and the management of projects. At the same time, he also pointed to the reality that misinformation about the Government’s management of relief funds has the potential to damage the country’s reputation.
However, as we stated at the beginning of this editorial, criticisms are par for the course. And while Government members also enjoy freedom of expression, they should show more temperance in treating with criticisms, learning to accept the positive with the negative.
Mr McKenzie’s PR people should let him know that he might well have given more flight to Beenie Man’s record with his comments.