Paulwell calls for end to House Speaker’s ‘disparaging’ remarks about elected members
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Opposition Leader of House Business Phillip Paulwell has written to House Speaker Juliet Holness, raising concerns over what he described as disparaging remarks about elected members during her opening statements in Parliament.
In a letter dated Tuesday, November 17, Paulwell argued that the practice was inappropriate, noting that such remarks were not provided for under the Standing Orders and should not be used to criticise members’ conduct, character or political positions without allowing them to respond.
“I write in my capacity as leader of Opposition business in the House of Representatives to place on record our strong objection to the practice of using your opening remarks to make negative and disparaging remarks about elected members of the Chamber or the Opposition as a whole,” he said.
Paulwell said the Opposition had raised the issue with Holness during a meeting the previous week and was calling on her to discontinue the practice until the matter was resolved.
He warned that if the remarks continued, the Opposition would insist that affected members be granted a right of reply in the Chamber.
“The Opposition regards this as a serious matter of fairness and of the rights of Members. A member who is criticised in the Chamber must be afforded a right of reply,” he wrote.
Paulwell further argued that the right to respond was particularly important when criticism came from the Speaker in statements made outside the procedures established by the Standing Orders.
He expressed hope that the dispute would be resolved swiftly while upholding parliamentary rules and the dignity and impartiality of the Speaker’s office.
“We trust that this matter can be resolved promptly, in a manner consistent with the Standing Orders and with the dignity and impartiality of the Chair, and we remain available to discuss it further,” Paulwell said.
