Should right and wrong be determined by the action or the person who commits it?
Dear Editor,
There is something increasingly troubling about the way we navigate right and wrong in the Jamaican society. It is not necessarily that we have abandoned our understanding of what is right and what is wrong. Rather, we seem to have become increasingly selective about when those principles should apply.
Today, right and wrong appear to be determined less by values, facts, and established standards and more by who is involved. The same behaviour that attracts condemnation when committed by someone we dislike, is defended, excused, or conveniently explained away when committed by someone we admire, support, or identify with. And that is a dangerous place for any society to find itself.
This is not about differences of opinion. A healthy democracy must accommodate disagreement, competing perspectives, and even uncomfortable criticism. The problem is what happens when disagreement gives way to denial, when facts become inconvenient, when people construct alternative realities to protect their preferred personalities, and when the truth is treated as something that can be negotiated depending on whose interests are threatened.
We are witnessing an increasingly disturbing culture in which loyalty appears to matter more than honesty, perception more than evidence, and allegiance more than accountability.
Consider the recent public discussion surrounding content creators using artificial intelligence to generate photographs of themselves in The University of the West Indies (UWI) graduation regalia branded with the regional institution’s coat of arms.
Some have found the images amusing and creative, while others, including actual graduates, have questioned whether the images trivialise an achievement that requires years of discipline, sacrifice, and hard work.
The UWI, Mona Administration has also expressed concern about the unauthorised use of its coat of arms, noting that simulated graduation photographs bearing the emblem could be mistaken for official university records.
Again, the issue should not be whether someone likes or dislikes a particular content creator. Nor should it be reduced to whether the images are funny. People are entitled to use technology creatively, and humour has its place in our society. But creativity does not exempt anyone from accountability. If an image uses an institution’s official insignia in a manner that could mislead the public, questions about authenticity, institutional representation, and intellectual property are entirely legitimate.
Why, then, should someone who raises those concerns be subjected to ridicule or accused of being bitter, classist, or unable to take a joke? The fact that something attracts thousands of likes does not automatically make it appropriate. Popularity is not a substitute for principle, just as a large following does not confer immunity from criticism.
The troubling pattern is a tendency to defend the person instead of scrutinising their actions. This is when the influence of social media becomes particularly concerning. People who ask questions, challenge narratives, or express reservations are increasingly treated as enemies. Rather than engaging with the substance of an argument, some supporters resort to personal attacks, ridicule, intimidation, and coordinated attempts to discredit the person raising the concern.
The objective is no longer necessarily to establish what is true, it is to silence the person who dares to question what has been presented as truth. This creates an environment in which people become reluctant to speak honestly for fear of being dragged, cancelled, bullied, or ostracised by online communities. Some will choose silence rather than risk becoming the next target of a social media pile-on. That should concern us all.
When people are punished socially for asking legitimate questions, the quality of public conversation deteriorates. When criticism is interpreted as betrayal, accountability becomes difficult. And when supporters are more interested in defending personalities than examining facts, misinformation and deliberate obfuscation can flourish.
There is also a distinction between defending someone against unfair criticism and defending everything that person says or does. The former is reasonable. The latter is blind allegiance. We must stop confusing the two.
We need to reclaim the courage to disagree without hostility, question without being intimidated, and acknowledge uncomfortable truths without feeling compelled to defend our preferred personalities at all costs.
Ultimately, the measure of our character as individuals and as a society is not how fiercely we defend the people we support, it is whether we are prepared to hold them to the same standards we demand of everyone else.
Right must remain right, and wrong must remain wrong, regardless of who is doing it.
Shannick Dawkins
shannick.dawkins@gmail.com.