‘I will not be intimidated’ says House Speaker Juliet Holness
Embattled Speaker of the House of Representatives Juliet Holness has declared that she will not be intimidated by any member while carrying out her duties in the nation’s Parliament.
Holness made the remark in a statement at the start of Tuesday’s sitting of the House of Representatives, the first since the near brawl that came at the end of the last sitting on November 3.
WATCH: House in turmoil over Cuba censure motion
She told her fellow lawmakers that disagreement with the chair does not render its statements improper and it should not become a demand by any member for silence.
“Let me be equally clear, I will not be intimidated into silence or pressured into abandoning my responsibilities,” she stated while promising to continue to discharge her duties as speaker “with firmness, fairness and impartiality while respecting the rights of every member while upholding the authority of the chair”.
During the November 3 sitting of the House, Opposition Member of Parliament Mikael Phillips and Government member Desmond McKenzie had to be physically separated. Opposition members have alleged that the way the speaker conducted herself during the sitting led to the standoff. Even so, the relationship between Holness and Opposition members has been both testy and antagonistic.
During her statement on Tuesday, Holness emphasised that her role as speaker is separate and apart from her marriage to Prime Minister Dr Andrew Holness. She also said the strength of Parliament rests not merely in the authority that it exercises, but in the principles it upholds and the standards it maintains.
She said while robust debate and principled disagreements are essential to democracy, “neither protest nor disagreement justifies disorder, obstruction or defiance of the chair”.
Holness said the standing orders governing the function of the Parliament are not merely guidelines made pursuant to the authority of the constitution of Jamaica. She said they govern parliamentary proceedings, protect members’ rights and establish the responsibility of the chair to maintain order.
She insisted that:“No member stands above these rules and their application cannot depend on whether a ruling meets with individual approval”.
Holness also noted that questions have been raised about her independence because of her marriage to the prime minister. She said while she has generally allowed her service to speak for itself, the constitutional position should be made clear.
She pointed out that she is the duly-elected three-term Member of Parliament for St Andrew East Rural and said it was her duty in terms of representing her constituents in the House.
“The mandate is mine in own right, neither conferred nor diminished by my marriage,” she remarked.
Holness pointed to section 43 of the Constitution which provides for the election of the speaker and the circumstances in which the office becomes vacant.
“I was duly elected to this chair and my marriage is neither a constitutional disqualification nor a measure of my independence or judgment,” she declared.
She told the House that any disagreement concerning her rulings are matters for parliamentary procedure to be assessed against the standing orders rather than her personal relationship.
“I stand by the rulings I have made and procedures grounded upon which they were given,” she said. She also told members that they are entitled to challenge decisions through the appropriate parliamentary processes but insisted that there is a clear distinction between legitimate scrutiny and personal attacks or intimidation intended to undermine her authority.
-Lynford Simpson

