Accused goat thief freed after no-case submission
ISHON Wilson, a 35-year-old labourer of a Manchester address who was jailed for one year and one month, was ecstatic on Monday after he was freed of larceny of cattle and unlawful possession of property by judge Monique Harrison in the Manchester Parish Court.
Wilson’s attorney-at-law Amy Dunkley from Rodain Richardson Law Chambers told the
Jamaica Observer on Monday that her client was freed after the judge accepted her no-case submission.
“We challenged the Crown on several fronts to say that based on the complainant’s statement and version, and even the investigating officer’s statement, there was absolutely no nexus connecting Mr Wilson to the alleged offence, none whatsoever. The complainant could not say whether or not she saw Mr Wilson take the goat, remove the goat, untie the goat, unlock the pen, nothing at all beyond the fact of her saying that she saw one of the goats on Mr Wilson’s grandfather’s property,” the attorney explained.
She continued: “This presented a significant challenge for the prosecutor and the prosecution in respect to this matter. They were not able to lead any form of identification evidence beyond the fact that the complainant has known the gentleman for a while. This matter saw a him being held in custody for one year and one month.“
Dunkley told the Observer that from the earliest stage, her client maintained his innocence.
“He maintained from the very start that he knew nothing about this matter. He is a hard-working brother. He indicated that he goes out to work and the complainant, too, indicated that she hardly sees him in the community. And so, this would have affected his opportunity to go out and make a living. The most challenging part, when you’re branded as a goat thief in a farming community, no one trusts you and anything that goes wrong after that period, you’re the first person they look to.“
She said that was one of Wilson’s major concerns, especially knowing that he was not guilty of the offence.
“I would just say that an allegation, no matter how strongly made it is, remains just that. An allegation until it is supported by credible evidence and is proven, remains just that. Based on what I experienced in court today, a suspicion is not proof and accusations alone should never be enough to establish guilt of an accused. This gentleman should never have lost his livelihood for more than a year,” she expressed.
Richardson, meanwhile, told the Observer that there was absolutely no way the prosecution could have been successful in mounting a case against Wilson. He pointed out that if they had simply taken the time to review the allegations, they would have noticed that there was no case to begin with.
“Ordinarily, tribunals will take time to review matters, but this particular case, it was so patently clear after cross-examination of both the main witness and the investigating officer that there was simply not enough or sufficient evidence to make all the elements required for both offences to ask this accused man to answer to the case that the Crown had called up against him,“ he explained.
“We use the opportunity to remind the public that not all persons brought before the court are guilty. In fact, we lead with the presumption of innocence until someone is proven guilty. If we needed a reminder, ever more so now, his case is a stark reminder of such.“
According to the details of the case, the neighbours of the property adjoining the one Wilson resided, rear goats, and on October, 8, 2025 five of the goats went missing. A brown doe was found tied to a tree on the property Wilson resided, approximately 20 feet from the neighbours’ goat pen. The other goats were never recovered. The complainant didn’t witness anyone around the goat, but said she suspected that Wilson was the one who took away the goat and had unlawful possession of the animal.
Dunkley pointed out that her client worked mostly outside of Manchester and therefore was not at home all the time. Furthermore, the property where he lived belongs to his grandfather, and he was not the only person who resided there at the time.