Judge explains why Colombians not given maximum sentence
IN sentencing three Colombian fishermen who were nabbed with cocaine valued at more than $1 billion to a cumulative 30 years each behind bars, Supreme Court Judge Justice Dale Palmer on Tuesday explained that the statutory maximum of 35 years “would not have been appropriate” given the circumstances of the case. The men will each only spend between 10 and 11 years in prison.
The three — 40-year-old Lucio Henry, 34-year-old Arith Lopez and 23-year-old Klein Sinclair Robinson — pleaded guilty two weeks ago to charges of possession of cocaine (count one), importing cocaine (count two), trafficking in cocaine (count three) and illegal entry (count four). According to the facts of the case, the Jamaica Defence Force (JDF) Coast Guard, acting on information, intercepted their 40-foot canoe off the coast of Alligator Pond, St Elizabeth, on March 21 around 4:10 am. A search of the canoe which was equipped with three 300 hp outboard engines revealed 99 knitted bags of cocaine, three GPS devices and other items. Under caution through an interpreter the fishermen claimed that they were “forced to carry” the narcotics from Colombia and that with the aid of the GPS equipment they were to have headed to a predetermined GPS coordinate after which they would be paid between US$20,000 and US$30,000.
They entered into plea negotiations with the Crown after being arraigned earlier this month and benefited from an agreement.
On Tuesday, Justice Palmer sentenced Henry to eight years on count one, 11 years each on counts two and three, and a fine of $2,000 or 10 days’ imprisonment on count four. The sentences were ordered to run concurrently, meaning he will serve the longest sentence of 11 years. Lopez received the same sentence as Henry while Sinclair Robinson received a minor adjustment because of his age. He was sentenced to eight years on count one, 10 years each on counts two and three, and a fine of $2,000 or 10 days’ imprisonment on count four. His sentences will also run concurrently.
In giving the rationale for the sentences, the judge said while the first three counts represented a breach of the Dangerous Drugs Act and each carry a precedent of up to 35 years, the sentencing guidelines “do not give a specific tabular range for this type of offence”.
Justice Palmer added that the 35-year ceiling would have been reasonable in the circumstances of the case had the men gone to trial and not negotiated the plea deal.
“I do give consideration that, notwithstanding the accused men are not said to be organisers or financiers of the voyage, they appear to be carriers, entrusted with a very large [shipment]. It is with that in mind that I would say that the statutory maximum of 35 years would not be appropriate. Had they gone to trial, a sentence of 22 years would certainly have been a more reasonable starting point,” he stated.
The judge described as “the most glaring aspect of the case” the volume of narcotics and its importation.
“I give consideration as an aggravating feature that this was clearly well-planned and premeditated crime. It involves organised crime and I give consideration to the fact that this kind of offence is not only prevalent but also would cause substantial harm — not just to the reputation of Jamaica but potentially also to the citizens of Jamaica. I also give consideration to the fact that sentence must also play the role of a deterrent for any potential future actors,” he stated.
In noting the plea in mitigation submissions by defence attorneys King’s Counsel Peter Champagnie and Able-Don Foote, who jointly represented the three men, Justice Palmer said he had also paid attention to the fact that the convicted men have no previous convictions, appear to have been cooperative when arrested, did not attempt to dispose of the substance, are fathers and were to some degree “forced to carry” the drugs although the “specifics of the coercion are not particularly clear”.
“There is mention of assistance given, to form a basis for the court to give further discounts and included in that is a reference to a particular gang or organised crime entity. There is no indication, either in the submissions or agreement, as to whether or not this information was either new to the authorities or formed the basis of any action,” Justice Palmer said.
He was referencing arguments by Champagnie that the statement of a JDF officer and others had indicated that three GPS devices were retrieved in line with the men’s insistence that they were being controlled in transporting the drugs and their families threatened if they did not comply.
Justice Palmer in the meantime said his decision in relation to counts two and three was already a substantial reduction from the 35-year maximum and pointed out that a reduction beyond this, given the amount of cocaine seized, would have the result of “shocking the public’s conscience”. He said he also gave consideration to the strength of the Crown’s case, noting that given the amount of cocaine in a vessel, that size, “possession could not be denied”.
On Monday Champagnie, addressing Justice Palmer on behalf of the men — who followed the proceedings via the services of an interpreter — had urged the judge to be “as lenient as the law will allow” after listing eight mitigating factors, including the information volunteered about the cargo and the source of it “which may or may not be useful in the long run”.
In court Tuesday, Justice Palmer ordered that the 40-foot vessel and the three outboard engines found on it be forfeited to the Crown. A plea and case management hearing was also ordered for March next year to consider a forfeiture and/or pecuniary penalty order requested by the Financial Investigations Division’s Asset Recovery Agency.