Let’s be tough on crime but merciful to the vulnerable
Dear Editor,
The national conversation surrounding Jamaica’s Firearms (Prohibition, Restriction and Regulation) Act, 2022 raises an important question: How do we protect our society from gun violence without creating a justice system that fails to recognise the vulnerability of our children?
The National Security Council has recently recommended increasing the mandatory minimum sentence for illegal firearm possession from 15 to 20 years. It has also proposed creating a specific offence for adults who groom children to use, store, transport, or acquire illegal firearms. While these proposals reflect the Government’s determination to confront gun crime, the decision to strengthen penalties must be accompanied by careful consideration of how children who come into conflict with the law are treated.
As an educator, I am particularly concerned that a rigid sentencing framework could criminalise children who are recruited, intimidated, manipulated, or coerced into participating in gang-related activities. This is not an argument for excusing illegal behaviour or weakening the fight against gun violence. Rather, it is a call for a justice system that distinguishes between those who deliberately exploit children and those whose involvement may be shaped by coercion, immaturity, and vulnerability.
We must acknowledge that children do not always exercise the same degree of independence, judgment, and decision-making as adults. A child found transporting or hiding an illegal firearm should not automatically be treated as though that child were the architect of a criminal operation. The circumstances surrounding the offence, the child’s age, the level of involvement, the presence of coercion, and the possibility of rehabilitation must be carefully examined.
This is why the concerns raised by Fi We Children Foundation deserve serious consideration. Its advocacy for a child-centered approach to the firearms legislation reinforces the need to distinguish between accountability and indiscriminate punishment. Mandatory minimum sentences can restrict a judge’s ability to consider individual circumstances, potentially resulting in disproportionate outcomes. Judicial discretion, exercised within clear legal guidelines, would allow the courts to impose appropriate penalties while maintaining firm consequences for serious offences.
Equally important is the need to hold adults accountable for exploiting our children. Those who recruit minors to carry, store, or transport firearms should face substantial criminal consequences. The proposed new offence is, therefore, a welcome development, but its effectiveness will depend on proper investigation, successful prosecution, and meaningful protection for children who cooperate with authorities. We must ensure that these children are not left exposed to retaliation from the very criminal networks that exploited them.
Parents and guardians also have an important responsibility to supervise, guide, and protect their children. However, parental accountability must not become another indiscriminate measure that disproportionately punishes vulnerable families. Instead, schools, communities, social services, and law enforcement agencies must work together to identify children at risk of recruitment and intervene before they become involved in serious criminal activity.
Prevention must be central to our national response. Mentorship, counselling, skills training, educational support, structured after-school programmes, and rehabilitation pathways should form part of a comprehensive strategy to reduce youth involvement in gun crime. When appropriate, diversion from the formal criminal justice system should be considered, alongside measures that protect victims and promote public safety.
The Government has indicated that draft amendments are to be prepared for wider consultation by the end of November. This presents an opportunity for Parliament, educators, child protection advocates, legal practitioners, parents, and young people to contribute meaningfully to the reform process.
Jamaica needs strong firearms legislation, but strength should not be measured exclusively by the length of a prison sentence. It must also be measured by the law’s ability to protect citizens, hold offenders accountable, prevent exploitation, and rehabilitate those capable of changing their lives.
Our children are not merely the future; they are members of our society who require protection today. If we fail to distinguish between children who exploit others and children who are exploited, we risk sacrificing young lives that could otherwise be redirected towards productive citizenship.
Let us be tough on gun crime, firm with those who exploit our children, and just in how we treat the young. Our children are ‘fi wi children’, and protecting them is a responsibility we cannot afford to neglect.
Ricardo E Smith
Senior educator and social scientist
ricardo.professional.edu@gmail.com