Listed companies, foreign subsidiaries dominate Business Leader Award nominees
Publicly listed Jamaican companies and locally managed subsidiaries of overseas firms dominate the nomination list for the Gordon “Butch” Stewart Business Leader Award that is currently under consideration.
There are 10 corporate nominees for the award which is seeking to identify and highlight the companies operating on Jamaican soil that provide the most wholesome and progressive environment for their workforce. Specifically, the theme of the award is ‘Business Leader: Employer of Choice’.
In an inauspicious outcome, no privately held Jamaican-owned organisation made it on the list of 10 nominees, a handful of genuine prospects for nomination having declined to participate in the programme.
The search for the list of potential nominees for this prestigious award had a disproportionately low representation among local private firms once the pool was reduced to the top 25 firms. These are the companies that had a real shot at being one of the 10 nominees. All 10 are survivors of a brutal culling process from a broad initial list of 60, then 40. They were further reduced to a group of 25. The members of this group were all considered potential nominees for the award, with 10 of them ultimately emerging as candidates to go forward.
Long-serving Observer Business Leader Selection Committee members Ambassador Audrey Marks and Ian Neita having a conversation at the launch of the programme renamed in honour of late Observer chairman and business icon Gordon “Butch” Stewart at the Observer headquarters in St Andrew on November 5, 2026. (Photo: Garfield Robinson)
They were selected after all 25 were asked to submit answers to a 42-question survey that was a deep dive into their industrial relations practices.
Of the 25 companies that were short-listed for the more rigorous probe, only five were privately held Jamaican enterprises. Four of the five declined to participate in the programme and so did not complete the questionnaire.
Only one publicly listed Jamaican firm declined, while three failed to meet the deadline for submitting their responses.
The questionnaires that were sent to the companies demanded significant executive time for completion under a compressed timeline. Some categories of local companies were specifically excluded from being considered for the award. Most notable is the Sandals/ATL Group which is owned by the Gordon “Butch” Stewart’s children, and whose nomination would, therefore, represent a profound conflict of interest. Companies owned by members of the Award Selection Committee were also ruled out for consideration. These are:
Long-serving Observer Business Leader Selection Committee members Audrey Hinchcliffe and Fred Smith enjoy the press launch of the event renamed in honour of late Observer chairman and business icon Gordon “Butch” Stewart at the newspaper’s headquarters on Thursday, November 5, 2026.(Photo: Garfield Robinson)
· Manpower and Maintenance Services Limited, owned by Audrey Hinchcliffe;
· MegaMart/Bashco Limited, owned by Gassan Azan;
· Paymaster Jamaica, owned by Ambassador Audrey Marks;
· Sterling Asset Management, owned by Charles Ross; and
Long-serving Observer Business Leader Selection Committee member Charles Ross.Photo: Naphtali Junior
· Tropical Tours Limited, owned by Fred Smith.
The other judge is Ian Neita, former managing director of Yellow (Pages) Limited.
Additionally, to qualify for consideration, companies were required to have a minimum of 300 full-time employees.
Workers at all 10 companies that have been nominated will be surveyed as part of the final evaluation process to determine the winner in December.
The Jamaica Observer will begin releasing the names of the nominees on Friday when the first of 10 stories will be published both online and in print.
The ‘Business Leader: Employer of Choice’ will be announced on Sunday, December 13, at a gala presentation and dinner at AC Hotel Kingston on Lady Musgrave Road.
The programme has been named in honour of Gordon “Butch” Stewart, the founder of the Sandals/ATL Group of which the Jamaica Observer is a subsidiary.
The first-ever Business Leader Award presentation was on December 11, 1996, two days outside of 30 years to the day when the 2026 award will be held.
The award is promoted by the Jamaica Observer whose name it carried for 30 years until the formal rebranding to the Gordon “Butch” Stewart Business Leader Award earlier this month.