A Parliament of intemperance and childishness
The pathetic and reprehensible behaviour of some Members of Parliament in the chamber recently must be roundly, unreservedly, and resolutely condemned by all well-thinking Jamaicans. Even when the behaviour was obvious on the part of those involved, there have been all kinds of excuses or denials for their involvement. But we all saw it in plain sight, and what we saw and heard should fill us with disgust and even horror at what the Parliament is becoming.
Chairman of the Peoples National Party (PNP) and representative for St Andrew South Western Dr Angela Brown Burke was pitiable in her attempts to explain her involvement in the saga. One may recall that in an earlier sitting of the House she had removed the mace in disgust. Now we find her being accused of pushing the Speaker, Juliet Holness, which she has denied.
Whether she pushed the Speaker or not, her posture was menacing as she interfaced with her in the aisle. Her gestures were clearly intimidatory at a time when she should be seated as the Speaker walked out of the chamber behind the mace. At the very least, she should have given her free and unobstructed passage. This was the decent thing to do. This is without conjecture.
The icing on the cake for misbehaviour belonged to Mikael Phillips, Member of Parliament for Manchester North Western. Unless you are with some friends or family, every Jamaican knows that the use of expletives is hardly done for friendly banter. They are often an expression of anger, frustration, and outrage. So when used within the precincts of the Parliament, they are particularly egregious and defines at that moment the person who is using them. Their use is particularly reprehensible when backed by any hostile action towards the intended recipient. In that sense, moving towards the representative from Western Kingston, Desmond Mackenzie, could be interpreted as menacing.
Phillips seems to have temporarily forgotten that he was not in a rum bar in his constituency. In any event, he seemed to have taken temporary leave of his sanity, certainly common sense.
He has apologised for his actions, and while this is to be welcomed, one has to question his sincerity. As I have said more than once in this space, apologies are often used as a refuge for scoundrels who find them as a ready scapegoat to escape from embarrassment and the heat of the moment. Before I am flooded with e-mail, let me state categorically that I am speaking here in generic terms and certainly do not see Phillips as a scoundrel. I believe him to be an otherwise good person, who is faithful to his constituents.
My concern is that while sincere apologies are always welcomed, they can be exploited to make uncomfortable situations dissipate without ever correcting the wrong committed. A person who keeps apologising for infidelity in a relationship is a case in point. Such people tend to have a PhD in apology.
The Jamaica Labour Party’s public discussion of the matter, which inevitably took on a very partisan tone, was not helpful in mitigating the public’s disgust at what happened. Whatever Mckenzie said to Phillips, it is quite clear that he was not happy with it, and it caused an uproar which could have gotten decidedly worse. Both political parties must understand that perceptive Jamaicans do not see this incident in the house as a mere partisan matter. It is part of a trend that has been developing for some time, whereby the dignity of the Parliament is being sacrificed on the altar of political expediency of the worst kind. It must be brought under control.
Parliament has to be the place where the nation’s business is debated with temperance, and proper decisions arrived at that will advance the best interests of the country. It is clear that everyone will not agree on any particular issue, but it is the essence of the democracy we practise that people be listened to with respect and allowed to make their contribution without undue interference while the protocols of the Standing Orders are observed.
This is one of the reasons I have said in this space that the use of cellphones when someone is on his or feet making a contribution ought to be discontinued. If you pull out your cellphone while I am speaking, why should I want to listen to you when your time comes. It is a matter of etiquette, and I believe the time has long passed when the egregious behaviour ought to be reined in.
The work of the Speaker is never easy. He or she has to keep balance in the house while being fair to all concerned. Strict enforcement of the rules must be done to maintain order, but this has to be seen to be done across both sides of the aisle. Speaker Juliet Holness got the job in her own right as a Member of Parliament serving a large constituency.
Nevertheless, she has become a subject of much political carping from members of the Opposition, which often inelegantly brings up the matter of her being the wife of the prime minister. Thus, as they may want to suggest, she cannot be impartial. This is a patently false assumption on their part. I believe that in the main she has conducted the business of the House with a sense of impartiality.
I do not believe she will ever be able to remove the wet blanket on the minds of the Opposition members, who seem incapable of seeing her in the role given her proximity to the prime minister. And this is regrettable. The animosity towards her must come to an end.
In the end, it is the business of the people of Jamaica who hired them and now pay them handsomely, that is paramount. We are not entertained by the childish banter they often indulge.
Whether they want to admit it or not, one thing we know about politicians is that they often live in a bubble. It is the function of public commentary to occasionally put pin pricks in that bubble to let some of the air out so that those who live within it may wake up to the reality around them.
In my almost 50 years of doing public commentary, I have seen different iterations of this and have recognised that politicians of whatever stripe, or even leaders of organisations and institutions, do not like the discomfort of their bubbles being pricked. Yet, for the good of society, this is necessary. The people instinctively know this and this might partly explain why the percentage of independent voters has risen astronomically. Parliamentarians live in such a bubble and we must continue to prick it for the good of Jamaica.
Dr Raulston Nembhard is a priest, social commentator, and author of the books Finding Peace in the Midst of Life’s Storms; Your Self-esteem Guide to a Better Life and Beyond Petulance: Republican Politics and the Future of America. He writes a Substack — The Healing Self — on substack.com. Send comments to the Jamaica Observer or stead6655@aol.com