Safe after dark
Do employers owe women a higher duty of care?
Where a female employee is required to work alone at night in circumstances that expose her to a foreseeable risk of sexual assault or other criminal harm, the employer’s ordinary duty to take reasonable care may require heightened precautions. This could include a duty to take measures that might not be necessary if they were employing a man to do the same job.
At the beginning of the 20th century, the law viewed night work as a danger from which women needed protection. The International Labour Organization’s (ILO) Night Work (Women) Convention, 1919 (Convention Number 4) generally prohibited women from working at night in industrial workplaces.
Jamaica’s Women (Employment of) Act, 1942, reflected a similar approach by restricting women from undertaking night work in industrial workplaces. While the law was intended to protect women, it also limited access to certain jobs, overtime opportunities and career advancement. This Act was repealed in 2014 by the Employment (Flexible Work Arrangements) (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act.
International Labour Law evolved, with ILO Convention Number 171 shifting the focus from excluding women from night work, to protecting all night workers. The convention called for measures to safeguard their health, assist with family and social responsibilities, provide opportunities for occupational advancement and compensate them appropriately for night work. Although Jamaica has not ratified it, Convention Number 171 reflects a broader change: the question is no longer whether women should work at night, but how its risks should be managed.
Earlier this year, the Supreme Court awarded over $10 million in damages to a female security guard who was brutally raped while on duty. The guard had been assigned, as a late replacement, to work alone during the night shift. The assailant raped her, without a condom, and discharged inside her. He also forced her to perform oral sex on him. The learned judge said, “There can be no greater violation than all that she went through.”
The judge found, among other things, that the security company had no adequate training in self-defence for the guards, in particular females, and no policy governing female guards working alone. Ultimately, the company “failed to have any system in place that contemplated the safety of a female employee deployed to a location alone at night.”
In another case, an unarmed female guard was shot while working at night. Repeated intrusions through damaged fencing had been reported to the security firm that employed her, and a guard had previously encountered an armed intruder. Violence was therefore highly foreseeable, yet adequate warning and detection measures had not been provided. The company was ordered to compensate her for her injuries.
Our courts have long recognised that there is an inherent safety risk in certain types of jobs. In a 2011 case involving another security firm, Justice McDonald-Bishop (who is now the president of the Court of Appeal) said: “The accepted principle of law is that an employer owes a duty of care to his employee even if the job is inherently dangerous. However, he is not liable to his employee for any damage suffered arising out of the ordinary risks of the service, but where one employment happens to be more dangerous than another one, a greater degree of care must be taken by the employer.”
While it would be challenging to precisely define what constitutes the “ordinary risks” associated with any job, when it comes to physical safety, size matters. Setting standards for height, weight, age and physical strength can be protective for the employee and the employer alike. The Jamaica Fire Brigade, for example, has a minimum height of 5 feet 6 inches for men and 5 feet 5 inches for women.
Given the specific risk of sexual assault that women face, what can small businesses do to protect these women and themselves? Might self-defence classes become a normal part of onboarding an employee? If a strata corporation wishes to hire a night watchman, is it legal or discriminatory to only hire men? Would that not risk returning us to a time when women’s access to employment, overtime, and advancement were unfairly restricted?
The law tells us that employers should not exclude women from night shifts or other higher-risk roles. Instead, they should take appropriate preventative measures having conducted risk assessments, including factors such as the history of criminal activity in the area, the proximity of assistance, and the adequacy of lighting.
The law requires employers to meet foreseeable risks with reasonable precautions. Still, the foreseeable risk of a multi-million dollar judgment is something that will keep many a small business owner up at night.
Drew Wheatley is an associate at Myers, Fletcher and Gordon and a member of the firm’s Litigation Department. She may be contacted at drew.wheatley@mfg.com.jm or through the firm’s website www.myersfletcher.com. This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.