SICK!
•Shocking complaints about Jamaica’s ailing health sector
DELAYED admission and treatment, late diagnosis, a lack of treatment, long waiting lists, and discourteous staff are among the 1,045 cases of patient complaints registered at hospitals across Jamaica’s four regional health authorities (RHAs) since July this year.
Just over 10 per cent of the complaints have been cleared up.
These are among the findings of a troubling review of Jamaica’s public health-care sector which was made public on Tuesday by Health and Wellness Minister Dr Christopher Tufton following a statement in the House of Representatives.
The conclusions are contained in a 50-page Ministry of Health and Wellness report, titled ‘Institutional Performance Review’.
Vowing to be open and transparent, Tufton ordered the review earlier this year. The minister had, during his contribution to the 2026/27 Sectoral Debate on May 12, committed to holding public health institutions to clear standards of governance, financial accountability and performance. He committed to report transparently, on progress and ensure that accountability is reflected in the experience of patients.
On June 19, the health ministry implemented the Accountability Framework (MAF) Scorecard, which rates 13 entities against 18 governance and accountability indicators, and the Client Care Connect (CCC), which managed 1,045 client feedback cases across the four RHAs within the first quarter of the current financial year.
Together, the two instruments answer two questions: Are the institutions well-run, and are they serving people well?
The review found that, in terms of access to service, patients typically complained about waiting lists, delayed admission and treatment, limited service availability, inadequate resources, limited service availability, difficulty obtaining appointments and specialist care.
Worryingly, in terms of quality of clinical care, patients complained about delayed diagnosis and treatment, patient management and clinical decision-making, as well as poor management of deteriorating and high-risk patients.
In terms of communication, patients were dissatisfied with inadequate explanations, poor information sharing, delayed responses to enquiries, and inappropriate verbal or non-verbal communication.
Unprofessional behaviour, poor customer service and lack of responsiveness also irked patients. Additionally, they were ticked off by what they perceived to be a lack of courtesy, disrespectful treatment, along with inadequate privacy considerations for them and their families.
According to the review, access to services was the leading category of complaints in every RHA, while quality of clinical care ranked second.
“Communication, professional conduct, and rights, respect and dignity were the other principal themes. Together, access, quality of care, professional conduct and rights, respect and dignity make up about 77 per cent of complaint references nationally,” the review stated.
It also noted that complaints, which make up the bulk of client feedback, are concentrated in a small number of hospitals. Five hospitals, roughly one-fifth of the public hospital network, generate 52.2 per cent of all cases; the top eight generate 64.1 per cent; and the top ten 69.1 per cent. It highlighted that Cornwall Regional Hospital and Kingston Public Hospital — being referral hospitals — naturally had most cases because they saw most patients.
In terms of service points, the accident and emergency departments, outpatient clinics, medical wards, surgical services and maternity services were the most frequently mentioned areas in all four RHAs for client complaints. “These are the highest-volume, highest-contact areas,” the review explained.
“Their recurrence across every region indicates that the issues are systemic, not isolated to individual facilities, and that improvements in patient flow, communication and responsiveness in these areas will have the greatest effect on client experience nationally,” it added.
The review also addressed why only 10.6 per cent or 111 of the 1,045 cases were closed during the quarter, pointing to explanations provided in reports at the regional level. Factors included: Delays in receiving investigation reports and responses from service areas; difficulty obtaining complete documentation and supporting records; high active caseloads and increasing demand for complaint management services; delays in implementing and verifying corrective actions; resource constraints affecting investigation and follow-up; and cases requiring multidisciplinary review before resolution.
“Delayed closure limits the ability to identify quality problems, conduct root-cause analysis, implement corrective action and prevent repeat complaints,” the report said.
It explained that closure performance is therefore treated in the report as a measure of management responsiveness, not merely of caseload.
The report also identified recurring quality problems that suggest systemic rather than individual causes. They include: Barriers to timely access; communication, engagement and navigation challenges; weaknesses in assessment, escalation and management of high-risk patients; deficiencies in clinical documentation and records; weak compliance with clinical and administrative standards; gaps in care coordination; inconsistent investigation and case management; weak monitoring of corrective actions; workforce capacity and oversight constraints; as well as data quality and reporting deficiencies.
According to the report, improvement initiatives were already under way. These include a structured review to strengthen investigation quality and organisational learning in addition to a review of complaints to strengthen patient safety and clinical governance.
Meanwhile, the health and wellness ministry has already piloted a family care presence programme in two hospitals to improve communication, family engagement and patient experience. It also has in place mental health consent and restraint reviews — a new policy guidance on patient rights, governance and accountability. The ministry also recently launched a channel for clients to submit feedback directly to RHAs.