Getting NaRRA, energy reform and regional opportunities right
Last week, in our article ‘Breaking Jamaica’s low growth cycle’, we summarised Senator Keith Duncan’s very comprehensive “State of the Nation” speech.
At the time of writing, it is possible that the Government may have tabled the National Reconstruction and Resilience Authority (NaRRA) regulations. This matters because the degree to which these align with the conditionalities attached to the multilateral financing will determine how much, if any, of the sovereign lending portion of the over US$6 billion we can access, other than perhaps the portion coming from CAF (Development Bank of Latin America and the Caribbean).
For the life of this current Government, the success of NaRRA is likely to be the most important item in our much-needed growth agenda, and perhaps even the make or break issue of this Administration. The only portion of the over-US$6 billion in multilateral money promised post-Melissa that has been budgeted this fiscal year is US$400 million from CAF, which requires the cash subscription from the Jamaican Government to be sent to the bank to access the money. The majority of the rest of the money, mainly from the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) and World Bank, would have the normal, more onerous conditionalities attached.
This makes the role of Jamaica Reconstruction and Resilience Oversight Committee (JAMRROC ) — an oversight committee apparently similar in intent to the very successful Economic Programme Oversight Committee created to monitor our International Monetary Fund (IMF) programme — absolutely critical.
Peter Henry
The chair of JAMRROC, noted global economist Peter Blair Henry and author of the book Turnaround: Third World Lessons for First World Growth on Jamaica (he became famous partly due to his paper comparing the economic performance of Jamaica and Barbados since Independence), wrote an article titled ‘Managing expectations about NaRRA’s role’ in the Jamaica Observer on October 28, just after Prime Minister Dr Andrew Holness’s emergency press conference on NaRRA the day before.
Blair’s key points are worth receiving. NaRRA is not responsible for hurricane relief and recovery, such as restoring basic services, like water and electricity, and replacing roofs on houses, but is instead for reconstruction and resilience through large-scale construction projects that over the long-term will:
1) improve and build new infrastructure;
2) strengthen national resilience, especially to increase our resistance and ability to better withstand climate-related threats like hurricanes and drought; and
3) accelerate economic transformation.
In addition, not all money is fungible. Relief money does not fund NaRRA activities, and investment funds allocated to NaRRA cannot be reassigned for relief efforts.
He advised that the major public role of JAMRROC is to oversee and periodically report on the work of NaRRA, commencing early 2027, and its private role is to use its research, network, and technical resources to provide advice to both the Government and NaRRA.
Electricity
The most urgent supply-side issue is electricity, on which the clock is ticking as the country awaits, first, the promised energy white paper, but even more importantly, the issuance of the anticipated request for proposals for a new energy licence. Indeed, if the white paper is issued at the same time as the request for proposals, this would effectively abort the local consultative process that we should all expect on such a sensitive issue as the countdown to the end of the Jamaica Public Service (JPS) licence on July 1 next year continues.
Amongst the many issues that should be part of the white paper are the right of first refusal; whether power generation should be separated from transmission and distribution; and whether we need a truly independent systems operator to transparently manage power dispatch, ensuring the lowest-cost producers are prioritised.
A target of halving electricity theft, at roughly 20 per cent of power generated, has to be a priority of any new agreement, although, as JPS correctly argues, this is a social problem requiring a social solution; it can’t resolve it by itself.
Another key issue is the financial mechanism for how expensive “peaking” plants can be replaced, the role of distributed generation (electricity at an individual community level), battery energy storage (BESS), and the role of pumped storage if we are to reach our 50 per cent renewables target by 2030.
Mia Mottley (PHOTO: ANGELA WEISS)
Given that King Charles III’s birthday was November 14, it is also worth mentioning the recently convened 28th Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting convened in Antigua and Barbuda, which could provide opportunities in renewable energy. All 56 countries of the Commonwealth were present, including, in person, King Charles III, Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, Rwandan President Paul Kagame, Jamaican Prime Minister Holness, and heads of various smaller island states, such as Barbados Prime Minister Mia Mottley. UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham announced a UK£40-million aid package for green energy and blue economy initiatives in the Caribbean. More anon.
Speaking of Barbados, former Jamaica Governor General Sir Kenneth Hall’s book, titled
Caribbean Integration — The Patterson Doctrine, launched last Sunday at The University of the West Indies, included speeches not only from two former Jamaican prime ministers — PJ Patterson and Bruce Golding — but also global icon Prime Minister Mottley. It is impossible to cover today her over 1 hour and 20 minutes speech on Hall’s 386-page book on the need for Caribbean integration, except to note that Mottley now appears to lead the regional integration movement in exactly the way Patterson described himself in his speech (further described in the book), as an “unrepentant regionalist”, a “passionate nationalist”, while noting that “the two are not inconsistent”.
Future Caribbean
An important example of regional entrepreneurship is Future Caribbean, a global agentic artificial intelligence (AI) development and deployment platform founded by Barbadian Lily Dash. Her platform named Caribbean Grid AI, Neptune Analytics, and Miracle as the standout companies of its investor showcase at the New York Stock Exchange last Friday evening — the final stage of a programme launched in May at IDB Invest Sustainability Week in Barbados that we covered previously.
Co-hosted by major Silicon Valley venture capitalist Bill Tai who joined virtually, the invitation-only evening brought 16 finalist founder teams before investors, family offices, diplomats, and enterprise leaders. Importantly, Finance Minister Fayval Williams told the room that the Caribbean should not just watch the AI transformation happen, but help shape it.
More anon.
Keith Collister

