Disappointing handling of relief funds
Dear Editor,
A family still waiting for a roof after Hurricane Melissa should not have to read an audit to learn that money earmarked for roof repairs and emergency housing was spent on other things.
The Government should place the director general of the Office of Disaster Preparedness and Emergency Management (ODPEM) on administrative leave while a thorough, independent investigation is conducted. Administrative leave is not a finding of guilt. It allows investigators to examine decisions made under the director general’s leadership while an acting director keeps relief moving.
The auditor general’s report, tabled in Parliament on November 17, found that ODPEM spent $45.1 million from earmarked donations on clearance costs and other expenses. Of that sum, $32.97 million went to clearing goods intended for third parties. ODPEM could not show auditors that it had authority to use the money that way or that all the goods reached their intended recipients.
Shipments valued at approximately $780 million were left off the donation schedules provided to auditors. Auditors also found 15 unopened containers that were not recorded in the inventory and could verify the existence of only 31 of the 200 prefabricated houses listed. That does not establish that the other 169 were stolen; however, ODPEM owes Jamaica a documented answer for every one of them.
ODPEM says no donated money is unaccounted for, that it acted urgently to clear relief shipments, and that it will reimburse the donation account. But knowing where money was spent is not the same as showing that it was spent as authorised. And a receipt showing that goods cleared the port is not proof that a family received them.
Investigators should have full access to payment approvals, shipping manifests, warehouse records, and delivery receipts. Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee should hold a public hearing and demand an initial accounting within 30 days of what each parish received, what remains in storage, and what still cannot be traced. If the evidence establishes wrongdoing, recover the money and goods and pursue disciplinary action or criminal charges as warranted.
The hurricane took enough from Jamaican families. They should not now have to chase answers about the help sent in their name.
Dr JD Wood
jafnam@yahoo.com