‘Go through Jada or Shaneil first’: Spice checks Shenseea over dancehall crown claim
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Dancehall artiste Spice has challenged Shenseea’s claim to the title of Queen of Dancehall, declaring that the entertainer must first prove herself against Jada Kingdom or Shaneil Muir before attempting to claim the coveted crown.
In a video posted to Instagram on Friday, Spice pushed back against Shenseea’s recent assertion that her streaming numbers and career accomplishments had earned her the right to be recognised as dancehall’s leading female artiste.
“When you go through Jada Kingdom or Shaneil Muir, who I think is more next in line for the crown than you, and if you win one of them, then you can come talk to the queen. But until then, I’ll be waiting,” Spice declared.
Noting that she was disappointed by Shenseea’s statements, Spice described the move as an ill-conceived marketing strategy to boost sales and streams for her latest album.
Spice argued that Shenseea’s streaming figures were influenced by collaborations with other artistes and playlist placements, which she said did not necessarily reflect the strength of her own fan base.
“The numbers that you show on Spotify, they come from all these collaborations that you have, so you’re pulling from all these different people’s audiences that are not necessarily your organic fan base,” Spice said.
She further questioned the support for Shenseea’s latest project, claiming it had recorded fewer than 50 sales within its first week, and argued that the artiste was benefiting from a “borrowing audience”.
“I think that this is the worst marketing strategy in the history of dancehall music,” Spice said, adding that Shenseea needed to build a stronger independent following to attract support for her solo projects.
She also dismissed the use of statistics as a measure of who should hold the title, pointing out that, by that reasoning, artiste Nyla, whose song she said had the most streams, would also have a claim to the crown.
Spice maintained that the title had to be earned through a demonstrated commitment to dancehall and Jamaican culture, rather than popularity, appearance or international success.
“You can’t just waltz in and say you are the queen,” she said, questioning what Shenseea had done culturally to justify the claim.
The entertainer also took issue with what she described as Shenseea’s shifting musical ambitions, referencing previous statements in which the artiste expressed a desire to become the next Rihanna and described herself as a pop artiste.
Spice questioned how Shenseea could now claim dancehall royalty after previously expressing doubts about the genre’s longevity.
“You say you’re not giving dancehall more than five years, you say your a pop artiste, you know, you say, ‘I want to be the next Rihanna’,” Spice said.
She argued that the next woman to carry the title should be authentic to Jamaican culture and willing to embrace the challenges associated with establishing herself in the genre.
Drawing on her own experience, Spice said she had faced significant struggles to earn her place in dancehall, including clashes with male entertainers and the challenges of getting her music played by selectors.
She recalled that her first stage performance involved clashing with Bounty Killer and Powerman, and said she had also clashed with Beenie Man and Elephant Man.
Spice further pointed to the rivalry between former queen Lady Saw and Macka Diamond, arguing that clashes were part of dancehall’s culture and that Shenseea should be prepared to face similar challenges.
“Remember, dancehall is a clash culture. All the queens, Lady Saw clash Macka Diamond. You can’t just waltz in and use your pretty privilege and say you are a queen. That’s not how it works,” she said.
She also named Jada Kingdom and Shaneil Muir as artistes she believes are more deserving of consideration as the next woman in line for the crown.
Despite her criticism, Spice said she was not interested in fighting anyone for the title, insisting that her concern was the preservation of dancehall culture.
She said the Jamaican people ultimately had the right to decide who should carry the crown, but maintained that the successor should be someone who genuinely represents the genre.