The Vybz Kartel amendment
How a high-profile murder trial prompted legislative changes to address a gap in Jamaica’s jury law
The fate of one of Jamaica’s most publicised murder trials was altered by events inside the jury room. An allegation that a juror had offered fellow panel members $500,000 to secure not-guilty verdicts ultimately led to the quashing of Vybz Kartel’s murder conviction by the Privy Council.
But beyond the high-profile case was a gap in Jamaica’s law: There was no provision allowing a judge to discharge a jury, because of tampering and continue the same trial alone. A judge could be left with little choice but to end proceedings rather than allow a potentially compromised jury to deliver a verdict.
That gap is now the focus of legislative reform, with the Senate last Friday passing the Jury (Amendment) (No 2) Bill. It would allow a judge, under specified conditions, to discharge a compromised jury and continue hearing a case alone, rather than terminate proceedings and order a new trial.
The issue came into focus during the 2014 murder trial of Kartel, whose real name is Adidja Palmer, and co-accused Shawn Campbell, Kahira Jones and Andre St John, who were charged with murder in relation to Clive “Lizard” Williams, whose body is yet to be found.
After 64 days of proceedings, the jury forewoman reported that a juror, identified in the Privy Council judgment as Juror X, had offered fellow jurors $500,000 to return not-guilty verdicts. Juror X was subsequently convicted of attempting to pervert the course of justice.
The trial judge continued with the jury, which convicted all four men by a 10–1 majority.
In March 2024, the Privy Council quashed the convictions, finding that the handling of the alleged interference had undermined the fairness of the trial.
The court found that the judge’s directions did not adequately address the bribery allegation, Juror X should not have remained on the panel, and the judge had failed to consider whether other jurors could have been influenced. The apex court then referred the matter to Jamaica’s appeal court.
However, the Court of Appeal subsequently refused the prosecution’s application for a retrial.
During last Friday’s debate on the Bill, Leader of Government Business Kamina Johnson Smith explained that the jury-tampering provisions had originally been included in a wider Bill that also sought to increase juror payments. They were withdrawn to allow the payment changes to proceed while the tampering measures received further consideration.
The earlier Jury Amendment Act, passed by the Senate in April this year, tripled jurors’ daily stipends and introduced payments for people who attend court for jury service but are not selected. The tampering provisions were later brought back as a separate Bill.
The new legislation addresses two situations: The risk of tampering before a trial begins and interference after proceedings are under way.
Before a trial starts, either the prosecution or defence may apply for the case to be heard by a judge alone. The judge must be satisfied that there is evidence of a real and present danger of tampering and that, despite reasonable protective measures, including police protection, the risk is serious enough to make a trial without a jury necessary in the interests of justice.
Where tampering takes place during a trial, the judge may discharge the jury and continue hearing the case alone or end the trial and order a new one. Before deciding, the judge must inform the parties of the intended action and reasons for it, and allow them to respond.
Judges would also have to provide written reasons for decisions under the new provisions. If a case continues without a jury, the judge must give a written judgment explaining the reasons for a conviction or acquittal.
But the expanded powers raised concerns from Opposition senators about how far a judge’s authority should extend.
Opposition Senator Cleveland Tomlinson accepted that jury tampering posed a serious threat to justice but argued that removing a jury should remain exceptional.
He questioned the decision to lower the standard of proof for certain decisions from beyond reasonable doubt to a balance of probabilities. In simple terms, the balance of probabilities means the judge must believe something is more likely to have happened than not. Beyond reasonable doubt is a much higher standard, used to decide whether someone is guilty of a crime.
Government Senator Christian Tavares-Finson, one of the attorneys who represented Palmer during the original trial and who said the Bill is referred to as ‘the Vybz Kartel amendment’, argued that the proposed changes had particular significance because of what happened in that case.
“No one could say certainly how a judge sitting alone would have assessed the evidence, but it is my considered view that this course could have prevented the miscarriage of justice that ultimately required the intervention of the Privy Council… I am of the considered view that had this option been open to Justice [Lennox] Campbell at the time, Mr Adidja Palmer would not have served and spent 13 years in prison. That possibility is precisely why the amendment matters to me,” he said during the debate.
Opposition Senator Donna Scott-Mottley also questioned whether the safeguards were sufficient. She supported written reasons but expressed concern about the lower standard of proof and the possibility of the same judge continuing a trial after hearing allegations of tampering. She also criticised the decision not to send the Bill to a joint select committee for further examination.
Government Senator Charles Sinclair defended the changes, arguing that they were intended to protect rather than undermine the jury system.
“What this Bill is saying to people is… do not tamper with the jury if you want to have a jury trial. Do not interfere with the system of justice if you want to have a jury trial,” he said.
“How can we speak of a fair trial if a juror walks into the deliberation room knowing that a photograph of their child’s school has been slipped under their door? Any juror sees that is going to feel intimidated… When such instances arise and the jury is compromised, the trial ceases to be a search for the truth. It becomes a farce, and when justice becomes a farce, the rule of law collapses, democracy fails, and a country and its people are tarnished,” he added.
After the debate, the Senate approved four amendments to clause 2 before passing the Bill. The changes included revisions to the standard of proof and the requirements governing a judge’s consideration of fairness and in the interest of justice.