Photo, video evidence presented at sand theft trial
PICTURES and video were yesterday shown in the US$8-million ‘sand theft’ civil trial, evidence that claimant Felicitas Jamaica Limited is relying on to prove its case that sand stolen from its Trelawny beachfront property was used by two western Jamaica hotels.
The defendants in the lawsuit are Fiesta Jamaica Limited, operator of Grand Palladium Hotels & Resorts in Lucea, Hanover; Riu Jamaicotel Limited, owner/operator of Riu Tropical Bay Hotel and the Club Riu Montego Bay; and Redrock Building and Aggregates Limited.
The video, which was made on July 17, shows what appears to be white marine sand on the Fiesta property, the majority of which is brown sand.
Felicitas’ managing director Fredrik Moe, through whom the video was entered, proceeded to point out that the brown sand was native to the area and the white sand was not, but the defendants’ attorneys objected. The white sand could be seen around the pool area and along sections of the beach.
In the video showing Riu’s Montego Bay property, what appears to be patches of sand can be seen on the property, which is made up predominantly of brown sand. Also in the video are some men on the eastern beach section of the property, who Moe told the court were spreading the white sand on the property. Mounds of white sand were also on the property.
The lawsuit stems from the theft of approximately 250 truck loads of sand from Felicitas’ 64-acre beachfront property in Coral Springs, Trelawny between May and June of 2008.
Palmyra Resort & Spa Limited was named in the lawsuit but the case against it was discontinued.
Felicitas had purchased the Coral Springs property in August 2006 for US$2.4 million to develop a 40-villa resort. However, the project did not get off the ground due to the theft and Felicitas is claiming to have suffered “substantial damages” as a result.
At the time the sand was stolen, Fiesta and Riu were in the process of developing and constructing beaches on their respective properties. Bedrock was in the business of providing sand for development and construction of beaches.
Felicitas, which is represented by Queen’s Counsel Michael Hylton, is alleging that Bedrock and/or other persons removed the sand from the Coral Springs property and that they acted as Fiesta’s and Riu’s agents. The developer is also alleging that the stolen sand was used in the development and construction of the beaches at Fiesta’s and Riu’s hotels and that Fiesta and Riu knew or ought to have known that the sand had been illegally obtained.
But the defendants are denying liability. Fiesta admits that it contracted Bedrock in April 2008 to acquire a substantial amount of marine sand and that Bedrock delivered a portion which it thought was legally obtained.
Riu has denied obtaining any sand from any external source and is contending that all the sand used in constructing its beach came from the excavations done when the hotel buildings on its property were being constructed. Additionally, it says that its beach was constructed in 2007, before the sand theft.
Bedrock denies taking any sand from Coral Spring or that it delivered any sand to Riu.

