Financial considerations for development schemes: JMMB vs the Real Estate Board
In its recent April 2015 decision, the Privy Council interpreted portions of Section 31 of the Real Estate (Dealers and Developers) Act 1987 (“REDDA”). This section generally falls within the part of REDDA which governs the operation of development schemes, and specifically speaks to dealing with monies in trust accounts.
KES Development Company Limited (“KES”), a real estate development services company, was a developer for the Mountain Valley Development (“MVD”). The owner of the MVD land entered into pre-payment contracts with people who wanted to own houses within the MVD. KES and its attorneys-at-law collected these deposits, but they were not paid into an authorised financial institution, in breach of REDDA.
Subsequently, JMMB issued a loan to KES to finance several developments, the security for which included a mortgage over the MVD land. Also, KES granted a charge over this MVD land in favour of the Real Estate Board (“REB”) under REDDA in order to secure KES’ liability to repay the pre-payments. The charge was registered with the Titles Registrar, but the particulars of the charge were not registered with the Companies Office.
The MVD failed and KES defaulted on its loan from JMMB. JMMB later sought to sell the MVD land pursuant to its mortgage. However, the REB applied to the Supreme Court claiming that its charge over the MVD land ranked in priority to JMMB’s mortgage. On the other hand, KES contended that the JMMB charge was void due to the fact that its particulars had not been registered with the Companies Office, as required by the Companies Act.
The Supreme Court held that the Real Estate Board charge was valid and that it ranked in priority to the JMMB mortgage. JMMB appealed to the Court of Appeal, which dismissed the appeal. By the time the case was considered by the Privy Council, the Court was tasked with examining two primary issues.
Firstly, the Privy Council considered whether the Real Estate Board charge was required to be registered in the Companies Office, and concluded that it was not.
It determined that the Real Estate Board charge was not solely a statutory charge. This means that the charge did not take effect only by reason of the piece of legislation which created it. In order for the charge to exist, there would need to be an executed and registered mortgage.
Notwithstanding this, however, the Privy Council found that the sections of REDDA which regulate development schemes are part of a self-contained regime. It came to this conclusion on several grounds:
* The purpose of this statutory scheme is to provide security to would-be purchasers for the pre-payments made by them to the vendor. It separates the pre-payments and the charged land from the vendor’s estate, which is available to other creditors. Therefore, if the developer implements this statutory scheme, creditors will not have an interest in the pre-payments or the land, in so far as the land is secured to ensure their repayment.
* REDDA does not require that the charge be registered with the Companies Office. At the same time, REDDA provides that the charge must be executed and lodged with the Registrar of Titles, in order to allow withdrawal of pre-payments before completion.
* If the Companies Act were to apply, there could be a conflict between REDDA and the Companies Act, regarding the ranking of securities conferred by each respective Act.
* Practical considerations such as the fact that the charge need not be registered with the Companies Office in order for other creditors to gain notice of it.
Finally, the Privy Council assessed whether JMMB’s mortgage ranked on equal footing (in pari passu) with the Real Estate Board charge. The Court held that it did not, based on the ordinary and natural meaning of the words in the REDDA provision. One must look to the wording of the charge to ascertain its purpose and, by extension, its ranking.
In order for an authorised financial institution to benefit from a charge/mortgage having the same ranking as a REB charge (after the developer has entered into prepayment contracts), it must obtain from the developer a charge with a specified purpose of funding construction within the development. This may be by express wording or by reference to a loan document which provides funding exclusively for this purpose. In contrast, the JMMB mortgage was of a general nature, therefore ranking below the REB charge.
This is good news for buyers in development schemes protected by REB charges!
Maliaca Wong is a Partner in the Litigation Department at Myers, Fletcher & Gordon, assisted by Stephanie Ewbank, Pending Graduate of the Norman Manley Law School. They may be contacted via maliaca.wong@mfg.com.jm or stephanie.ewbank@mfg.com.jm or www.myersfletcher.com. This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.