The middle order of Caribbean capital
EVERY Caribbean country wants more successful businesses. We celebrate entrepreneurship, invest in programmes to support enterprise, and encourage innovation at every stage. Yet relatively little attention is paid to what happens after an idea becomes a business and after that business identifies an opportunity to grow.
How are expansions financed? How are acquisitions funded? How does a development project graduate to a stable, income-generating asset?
These questions point to a reality that is often overlooked. Economic growth depends not simply on the availability of capital, but on the availability of the right type of capital at the right stage of development.
Businesses and projects rarely rely on a single source of financing throughout their lifecycle. Instead, they move through a continuum. At one end sit founders and sponsors, who bear the earliest risks and provide the capital required to transform ideas into viable enterprises. At the other end sit larger and typically less expensive pools, including commercial banks, institutional lenders, pension capital, and public markets, which are critical to scaling businesses and financing mature assets. But these providers generally require predictability, scale, and demonstrated repayment capacity before they will participate.
Between these two ends of the spectrum sits a range of providers that includes venture capital, private credit, private equity and development finance. This segment of the financial ecosystem is the middle order of Caribbean capital markets. In cricket, the middle order consists of batsmen who come in after the foundation is set and before the innings is closed out. They must demonstrate technical soundness, skill and composure to adapt their play to whatever the innings demands. They rarely receive the recognition afforded to the openers or the finishers, but they are often who determine whether a promising start becomes something substantial.
Commercial banks play an indispensable role in every economy but their mandate is not to finance every type of risk. Regulatory frameworks such as Basel III appropriately strengthened banking systems following the global financial crisis, reinforcing the importance of prudent lending and sound capitalisation. As a result, banks are most effective when lending against established cash flows, tangible collateral, and demonstrated repayment capacity. Many growth opportunities do not fit comfortably within that framework, not because they are unsuitable for financing but because they require a different type of capital.
Public markets face a different set of constraints. Across the Caribbean our capital markets remain limited in depth, but even in more developed markets, public markets are not designed to serve businesses at certain stages. Listing requires audited financials, sustainable earnings, scale, and the ongoing governance demands of a regulated environment. These are characteristics that most growing businesses and projects are still working toward. Public markets function best as a destination for mature businesses, not as a vehicle for getting them there.
Both banks and public markets, in other words, sit at the end of the capital formation journey. How they get there is precisely where alternative capital becomes essential.
What makes this work more demanding than it appears is that the businesses most in need of growth capital are often those at an earlier stage of institutional development, with governance, reporting, and operational frameworks that are still maturing. Strengthening those foundations is as much the work as providing the financing itself. Alternative investors operating in this space take on real risk in illiquid markets with limited price discovery. Pricing that risk appropriately is what makes the model sustainable and repeatable. The measure of success is not simply whether a deal performs. It is whether the investment leaves the business better positioned to attract larger, cheaper capital on the other side.
This is why the concept of bankability matters so much. A bankable business or project is one that possesses the characteristics required to attract conventional lenders on sustainable terms. A business that secures five million dollars of alternative capital today may access twenty million dollars of commercial financing later because the initial investment improved its governance, reduced key risks, and demonstrated what the business is capable of at greater scale.
Bankability is frequently the outcome of alternative investment, not the prerequisite for it
The Caribbean’s financial ecosystem has grown considerably more sophisticated over the past decade. New pools of private capital have emerged, alternative investment platforms have expanded, and investors have become increasingly comfortable financing opportunities that fall outside traditional lending models.
But the middle order’s work has only just started. The gap remains consequential, and its cost is not abstract. It shows up in growth rates, employment figures, and the pace at which productive assets come online across the region.
The economies that prosper over the coming decades will not necessarily be those that produce the most entrepreneurs. They will be those that build financial ecosystems capable of supporting businesses and projects through every stage of growth.
Justine Powell is vice-president of investment management at Sygnus Capital Limited, the Caribbean’s leading alternative investment manager with over US$700 million in assets under management.